Narrowleaf cottonwoods (Populus angustifolia) occur in disjunct populations along rivers in a north-south corridor of the Rocky Mountain regions from Alberta, Canada, to Arizona, USA. This distribution should allow genetic divergence to provide localized ecophysiological adaptation. To test this, we compared 167 genotypes in ten source populations from across the full latitudinal range of 16° (1800 km). Replicated clonal saplings were grown for three years in a common garden at the northern range limit, where we found that shoot characteristics were correlated with the latitude of origin. Southern populations displayed increased height and stem diameter (populations: r2 = 0.489 and 0.472) due to extended in-leaf growing seasons. However, this produced a phenological mismatch, with increased fall frost injury and shoot die-back. With increasing latitude of origin there were foliar differences across the populations, with higher chlorophyll content (chl, r2 = 0.836), nitrogen (N, r2 = 0.429), and leaf mass per area (LMA, r2 = 0.474). Similar latitudinal correspondences were observed across the individual genotypes, again with the strongest correlation for chl (r2 = 0.188). Across the genotypes, chl was positively correlated with leaf length, width, area, and mass, and especially with foliar N (r2 = 0.354), which was also correlated with foliar δ13C (r2 = 0.230). The heritable correspondences between source latitude and foliar characteristics could enable vigorous photosynthesis during the shorter, northern growing season, providing latitudinal compensation. Conversely, slower photosynthesis would reduce the foliar aging rate, enabling leaf function through the longer, southern growing season. The alternate foliar strategies could accommodate the limited ‘leafspan’, or leaf lifespan. This adaptive variation in foliar physiology would impact natural or assisted northward migration of cottonwood populations in response to climate change. It could also be useful for poplar breeding, with northern genotypes contributing genes to increase photosynthetic capacity. Finally, groupings of the populations based on the combined ecophysiological traits were very consistent with genetically defined ecotypes, supporting the evolution of subspecies types within this obligate riparian tree.
Read full abstract