Bleeding events are common in patients prescribed anticoagulants and can have devastating consequences. Several specific and nonspecific agents have been developed to reverse the effects of anticoagulant drugs or toxins. Vitamin K, as the oldest of these antidotes, specifically counteracts the effects of pharmaceuticals and rodenticides designed to deplete stores of vitamin K-dependent factors. In cases of life-threatening bleeding, the addition of prothrombin complex concentrates (PCCs) allows for the immediate replacement of coagulation factors. While the use of PCCs has been extended to the non-specific reversal of the effects of newer direct oral anticoagulants, the specific agents idarucizumab, targeting dabigatran and andexanet-α, binding factor Xa inhibitors, have recently been developed and are being preferentially recommended by most guidelines. However, despite having rapid effects on correcting coagulopathy, there is to date a lack of robust evidence establishing the clear superiority of direct oral anticoagulant-specific reversal agents over PCCs in terms of haemostatic efficacy, safety or mortality. For andexanet-α, a potential signal of increased thromboembolic risks, comparatively high costs and low availability might also limit its use, even though emerging evidence appears to bolster its role in intracranial haemorrhage. Protamine is the specific agent for the reversal of unfractionated heparin anticoagulation used mainly in cardiovascular surgery. It is much less effective for low molecular weight heparin fragments and is usually reserved for cases with life-threatening bleeding.