Mulch is widely used for improving soil quality and maintaining crop productivity. The effects of mulch use in agroecosystems can be assessed by the state of the soil biota. Springtails (Collembola) are a representative group of soil animals in agroecosystems that survive well under agricultural field conditions. We assessed the effect of adding a detrital subsidy with different carbon to nitrogen ratio (C:N) on springtails in a 4-year series of field experiments in winter wheat agroecosystems located in two agroecological zones (broad-leaved forest and steppe). The mulch effect depended on weather conditions. In dry years, the addition of mulch led to an increase in the proportion of epedaphic (upper-litter dwellers) springtails in the broad-leaved forest zone and to an increase in the proportion of atmobiotic forms (mostly inhabiting macrophytes) in the steppe zone. These changes begin to manifest approximately 1.5 months after the detrital subsidy addition. In general, mulch application had a positive and stabilizing effect on the springtail community structure in winter wheat agroecosystems, regardless of the agroecological zone. Our study showed that the addition of detrital subsidy helps to increase the abundance and stabilize the diversity of the springtail community. Changes observed in the structure of the Collembola community can be an indicator of improved soil health, and springtails can be used in assessing the effectiveness of agricultural practices.