Preimplantation embryos can experience stress from laboratory interventions and a sub-optimal culture environment. Though research has demonstrated advanced maternal age impairs oocyte quality, the response of embryos derived from such oocytes to vitrification-thawing and culture in a high oxygen (O2) environment in the assisted reproductive technology laboratory is unknown. Therefore, in this study, embryos produced by in vitro fertilization (IVF) using oocytes from two- and eight-month-old Swiss albino mice were vitrified and thawed during their 6–8 cell stage. and cultured at low oxygen (5%) tension (LOT) and high oxygen (20%) tension (HOT). Embryo development, apoptosis, inner cell mass (ICM) outgrowth proliferation ability in vitro and pluripotency were assessed. Embryos from advanced maternal age cultured at HOT showed reduced fertilizing ability (p < 0.05), poor survival post-thawing (p < 0.05), and increased apoptosis (p < 0.01) in comparison to sibling embryos cultured at LOT. Importantly, the extended culture of vitrified-thawed embryos from advanced maternal age led to a significant (p < 0.001) reduction in complete ICM outgrowth formation at HOT in comparison to the LOT environment. The findings of this study suggest that HOT is detrimental to embryos from advanced maternal age, and importantly, vitrified-thawed embryos are more susceptible to stress, which could have negative implications, especially during the peri-implantation developmental period.