Examining changes in evapotranspiration with forest management is one starting point for comprehensively understanding the impacts of forest management on water resources and forest resilience. This study builds on our previous work and develops a practical model that predicts changes in evapotranspiration with the management of Japanese cedar and cypress plantations. The model has distinct features that it requires only stem density, mean diameter at breast height, and basic meteorological data as inputs. This study first confirms that the model predicts annual evapotranspiration for cedar and cypress with relatively small errors (approximately 60 mm at the maximum). Next, this study shows that the model predicts changes in annual evapotranspiration with thinning and clearcutting of cedar and cypress with small errors (the mean absolute error of 86 mm). This study then demonstrates that coupling the model and yield tables enables prediction of annual evapotranspiration for different management scenarios and then the assessment of policy recommendations. Indeed, our model prediction suggests that the decrease in annual evapotranspiration with cedar and cypress aging is seemingly much smaller than that assumed in existing policy recommendations. Our model also suggests that the decrease in annual evapotranspiration with aging can more than triple by thinning at a rate of 50%, although this suggestion should be tested by future observation studies. The model is applicable only to Japanese cedar and cypress plantations under Japan’s meteorological conditions, but similar models for other mono-specific plantations can be developed. This study will thus inspire forest scientists to develop models that assist policymaking for other species in other areas.
Read full abstract