MLR, IOI.2, 2006 553 is illusory, for itmust finally return to thewomb ofMother Earth; and accompanying the depictions of bodies absorbed by swamps and rivers, Cestaro finds a concomitant stress upon semiotic flow and the instability of language. The final chapter seeks to show how, in the latter part of the Purgatorio and the Paradiso, the metaphor of the nurse's body is deployed by Dante to articulate a new Christian understanding of selfhood and language. In the maternal presence of Beatrice and Matelda, the classical paradigm is deconstructed tomake way for a new Christian subject which, throughout the Paradiso, will remain inseparable from the mother. The book ends with a brief survey of metaphors of nutrition and maternal corporeality in the Paradiso. One disappointment here is the brevity of Cestaro's treatment of the Empyrean cantos and, in particular, the fact that he misses the opportunity to contrast the balia image of canto xxx, as it declares the symbiotic dependence of the commune on the empire, with the definition which he finds in the Inferno of both 'ego and empire' as 'patriarchal projects' that require the repression of nursing corporeality (p. 78). These reservations aside, however, Cestaro's subtle, complex, and thought-pro voking book is awelcome demonstration of how much can be gained by reading the Commedia not only as a product of preceding traditions but also as an anticipation of themes central to thinkers such as Kristeva and Lacan. Above all, his thesis of fers a cogent challenge to the standard view that the poem tends ultimately towards evanescence and the diminution of corporeality, for Cestaro recognizes that at the heart of the Paradiso there is an affirmation of the body as 'a site of joyous process' (P. 136). SHINSHUUNIVERSITY DAVID RUZICKA The Ugly Woman: Transgressive Aesthetic Models in Italian Poetry from theMiddle Ages to theBaroque. By PATRIZIABETTELLA. Toronto: University of Toronto Press. 2005. viii+259pp. $6o. ISBN o-8020-3926-x. The reader would be justified in thinking that this is essentially a book concerning the history of misogyny in Italy. In fact it could be argued that the book would benefit from an outline of such a history, since, as the author admits, 'the antifeminist theme in medieval and early modern Italian literature, and poetry specifically, has been long ignored and largely eschewed' (p. I3). This aspect of Patrizia Bettella's research is partly covered by the introduction and by Chapter i. These are followed by three further chapters, dealing respectively with 'Transgression in the Trecento and Quattrocento: Guardian, Witch, Prostitute', 'The Portrait of the Ugly Woman in the Renaissance: The Peasant, theAnti-Laura', and 'New Perspectives inBaroque Poetry: Unconventional Beauty'; each chapter has clear subdivisions. The chapters are followed by a short conclusion (pp. I65-70), an appendix (pp. I7 i-86) containing some texts concerning old women, extensive notes (pp. I87-232), a bibliography (pp. 233-49), and an index (pp. 25 I-59). Although this work has been in the making for a number of years (it started as a Ph.D. thesis written in Italian, presumably in the early nineties), it still bears the traces of an academic dissertation. It is a diligent and scholarly piece of work, covering a substantial number of primary texts, but it is still rather dependent on secondary material, even when this is rather bland, and the author's views are therefore obfuscated. One example will suffice, but I could quote many. When talking about the praises of a dark lady by Marcello Giovanetti (1598-I631), the words ofWilliam Crelly, who wrote amonograph on this author, are quoted, as follows: the poet 'is polite and correct and never betrays the slightest hint of controversy, vulgarity or even 554 Reviews satire. Though bright and inventive it is resolutely discreet and high-minded' (p. I38). These are the kinds of statement we ask our students to avoid. Considering primary sources, some of the unpublished material which is referred to remains marginal to the main narrative and is quoted without clear reference to its present location, at least in the appendix, where the numbering of texts is sometimes confused with that of the stanzas. The book deals mainly...