Magnetic flux ropes (MFRs) at the center of interplanetary coronal mass ejections (ICMEs) are often characterized as simplistic cylindrical or toroidal tubes with field lines that twist around the cylinder or torus axis. Recent multipoint observations suggest that the overall geometry of these large-scale structures may be significantly more complex. As such, contemporary modeling approaches are likely insufficient to properly understand the global structure of any ICME. In an attempt to rectify this issue, we have developed a novel flux rope modeling approach that allows for the description of arbitrary distortions of the flux rope cross section or deformation of the magnetic axis. The resulting distorted MFR model is a fully analytic model that can be used to describe a complex geometry and is numerically efficient enough to be used for event reconstructions. To demonstrate the usefulness of our approach, we focus on a specific implementation of our model and apply it to an ICME event that was observed in situ on 2023 April 23 at the L1 point by the Wind spacecraft and also by the STEREO-A spacecraft, which was 10.°2 further east and 0.°9 south in heliographic coordinates. We demonstrate that our model can accurately reconstruct each observation individually and also gives a fair reconstruction of both events simultaneously using a multipoint reconstruction algorithm, which results in a geometry that is inconsistent with a cylindrical or toroidal approximation.