188 Book Reviews TECHNOLOGY AND CULTURE Millikan’s School: A History of the California Institute of Technology. By Judith R. Goodstein. New York: W. W. Norton, 1991. Pp. 317; illustrations, notes, bibliography, index. $25.00. Published to coincide with the one hundredth anniversary of the California Institute of Technology, and prefaced with short, boosterish remarks by the current and former presidents of the institute, Millikan’s School is clearly meant as a celebratory history of Caltech. Given this intent, Judith Goodstein is remarkably evenhanded. Rely ing on archival material, published secondary sources, and interviews with institute scientists, Goodstein presents a highly readable account of Caltech’s beginnings at the turn of the century as Throop Univer sity, an institute with support from its wealthy Pasadena community but without a defined mission, and its transformation, beginning with the First World War and completed by the Second, into a nationally prominent scientific institution. This transformation was largely ini tiated by astronomer and institute trustee George Ellery Hale and the Nobel-prize-winning physicist Robert Millikan, Hale’s choice for institute president in 1921. Well positioned within the nation’s scien tific elite, they assiduously and successfully wooed private founda tions, philanthropists, and local industrialists for support and lured to Caltech such promising or prominent scientists as Arthur Noyes, Linus Pauling, and Thomas Hunt Morgan. The book concludes with Millikan’s retirement at the end of World War II and the arrival of Lee DuBridge as Caltech’s new president. Although Goodstein is a Caltech “insider,” having served for two decades as the institute’s archivist and now as university registrar (and taking suggestions on her manuscript from “friends” such as Caltech president Thomas Everhart and Lee DuBridge), her account is thankfully free of dogmatic assertions about institutional “excellence” and unreflective praise for “entrepreneurship.” Goodstein also ad dresses squarely one of the less-than-appealing aspects of Caltech’s past—institutional anti-Semitism during Millikan’s tenure. But, if Millikan’s School is not uncritical, neither is it probing. The larger questions in the literature on institution building and on science and patronage are left unexamined, particularly how the relationship between industry and the university developed over time and was institutionalized and how it influenced the way scientists pursued their research. Further, specific incidents that might give us insight into issues in the history of science and universities, or at least a fuller picture of Caltech itself, are not explored. Why, for example, did President James Scherer decide in 1910 that Caltech should become an all-male institution (a decision enthusiastically endorsed by Hale)? Inquiry into numerous social and institutional issues is eschewed in preference for a Whiggish approach to Caltech’s history. Goodstein TECHNOLOGY AND CULTURE Book Reviews 189 focuses almost exclusively on the institution’s scientists and the research that brought them national prominence and on Caltech’s administrators and their efforts to bring to the institute both money and prestige. This approach works best for the early years, when the influence of Hale and a few wealthy trustees is clear. Here, in fact, Goodstein rounds out the picture provided in Robert Kargon’s 1982 study of Millikan and Caltech by rooting institution builders such as Hale in the context notjust of their professional connections but also of their local community and social relationships. This focus on Caltech’s “great” men is, however, wholly inadequate for the later years when the institute was no longer marginal and isolated from powerful national political and economic forces. The absence of an analytical framework limits the appeal of this book. Some may also find annoying the failure to document sources other than those from which direct quotations have been drawn. For the most part, these are the professional historian’s complaints, and Millikan’s School is clearly directed at a different audience, most likely one with some link to Caltech. Those readers will find Goodstein ’s book to be substantive, informative, and a good read. Rebecca S. Lowen Dr. Lowen holds a Ph.D. in American history from Stanford University. She has a Guggenheim postdoctoral fellowship at the Smithsonian Institution’s Air and Space Museum, where she is completing a book on patronage and...
Read full abstract