Project Criteria Research Articles

Project Evaluation Criteria for Feasibility Project Towards Inclusive Growth in Indonesia

This monograph discuss about measuring project variables as well as parameters of various project especially in Green Growth through inclusive growth. We elucidate the link between financial modeling, economic modeling and poverty alleviation in Indonesia. We explicitly perform how the model is perform. We focus on measuring the project with Economic Rate of Return to measure the benefit of the project.

FDG-PET–driven consolidation strategy in diffuse large B-cell lymphoma: final results of a randomized phase 2 study

AbstractDose-dense induction and up-front consolidation with autologous stem cell transplantation (ASCT) remain controversial issues when treating patients with high-risk diffuse large B-cell lymphoma. GELA designed a randomized phase 2 trial evaluating the efficacy of either rituximab, doxorubicin, cyclophosphamide, vindesine, bleomycin, prednisone (R-ACVBP) or rituximab, cyclophosphamide, doxorubicin, vincristine, prednisone (R-CHOP14) induction and a positron emission tomography (PET)-driven ASCT or standard immunochemotherapy (SIC) consolidation in age-adjusted international prognosis index 2 (aaIPI2)-aaIPI3 patients. PET was performed at baseline, after 2 (PET2) and 4 (PET4) induction cycles, and centrally assessed using international harmonization project (IHP) criteria. PET2−/PET4− patients were assigned SIC, PET2+/PET4− patients were assigned ASCT, and PET4+ patients were treated with the investigator's choice. The primary end-point was the 2007 international working group complete response (CR) rate after induction. Change in maximum standard uptake value (ΔSUVmax) after PET assessment was explored. Two hundred eleven patients were randomly assigned to R-ACVBP (n = 109) or R-CHOP14 (n = 102). PET4−/CR rates were 53%/47% with R-ACVBP and 41%/39% with R-CHOP14 (CR 95% confidence interval [CI], 38%-67% and 28%-54%, respectively; P = .076). Consolidation in the R-ACVBP and R-CHOP14 groups was SIC in 26% and 23% of patients and ASCT in 28% and 18% of patients, respectively. PET4 positivity was higher with R-CHOP14 vs R-ACVBP (54% vs 41%; P = .08), leading to more salvage therapy (37% vs 26%; P = .07) and lower event-free survival (EFS; 4-year EFS, 31% vs 43%; P < .01), but progression-free survival (PFS) and overall survival (OS) were similar in both groups. PET2−/PET4− and PET2+/PET4− patients had similar outcomes. Using ΔSUVmax, 79% of the patients were PET2−/PET4−. ΔSUVmaxPET0-4 >70% was associated with better outcome (4-year PFS, 84% vs 35%; 4-year OS, 91% vs 57%; P < .0001), whatever the consolidation. Superiority of R-ACVBP over R-CHOP14 was not established, as IHP criteria did not properly reflect disease control. ΔSUVmax may help better select patients needing an alternative to SIC, including ASCT.

Effects of Some Breeding Criteria on Financial Evaluation Indicators for Dairy Cattle Investment Projects

This study was conducted with the aim of determining the probable effects of different real interest rates (RIR: 5, 6 and 7%), some key breeding criteria such as calving rate (CR: 80, 85 and 90%) and mean lactation milk yield per milking cow (MLML: 5000, 6000 and 7000 kg) on the financial evaluation indicators such as Benefit Cost Ratio (BCR) for a dairy cattle farm investment project taken as model, consisted of 100 heads of Holstein cows, which was established and operated during 20 years period in Turkey. In the study, firstly, current investment and annual operating costs for that kind of dairy cattle farm were determined according to optimal workmanship, housing, maintenance, feeding and health protection and then revenues were calculated from current sale prices of raw milk, slaughtered/breeding animal and manure. For each assumed different real interest rate, calving rate and mean lactation milk yield per milking cow, the parities of unit (1 kg) sale price of raw milk to unit (1 kg) cost of concentrate feed (M/F-parity) (current unit cost of concentrate feed was assumed as to be 1.00 Turkish Lira (TL) were calculated to make BCR that is one of the financial evaluation criteria for the investment projects, as to be 1.00. Calculations showed decreasing each 1% of the real interest rate in Turkey, increasing each 5% of calving rate and increasing each 1000 kg of mean lactation milk yield per milking cow had, separately, about 5-12% positive effect on the parity of unit (1 kg) sale price of raw milk to unit (1 kg) cost of concentrate feed.

DEMATEL-ANP Risk Assessment in Oil and Gas Construction Projects

Oil and gas construction projects are complex and risky because of their dynamic environment. Furthermore, rising global energy demand has increased the need for trustworthy risk assessment models for such projects that can provide adequate and precise policy planning. Traditional risk assessments in oil and gas construction projects do not consider the interrelationships of factors in the best-fit models. The Decision Making Trial and Evaluation Laboratory (DEMATEL) and Analytic Network Processes (ANP), called the DEMATEL-ANP approach, have been applied to other research disciplines to address this shortcoming. This method is able to construct a structural relationship among the different influence factors to visualize complex correlations. Thus, the purpose of this study is to showcase the DEMTAL-ANP risk assessment model to assess the overall risk factors of OGC projects. This study thus identifies the crucial risk criteria of such projects. Data were collected in 2016 through interviews with experts active in OGC projects in Iran. DEMATEL in this situation is used to determine the interdependencies’ relative strengths among the risks. The ANP method is applied to assess the relative importance of the risk factors and to determine the best strategy for implementation of a risk management program. The results presented in this study are a novel adaptation of the risk assessment methodology to OGC projects that determines the important risk factors that directly affect the project success, which in turn helps in formulation of policies for ensuring reliable energy supply planning.

Vibration Safety Criteria for Surficial Rock Mass of Open Pit Slope Affected by Underground Mining Blasting Operations

Introduction: Blasting vibration velocity is an important index to evaluate the stability of mine slopes under blasting operations. Objective: In order to determine the blasting vibration safety criteria for slope rock mass scientifically and reasonably, the influence of stress waves on surficial rock mass of mine slopes was analyzed when stress waves propagate to the slope surface, and mathematical models for blasting vibration safety criteria are proposed based on the ultimate tensile stress criterion, the ultimate shear stress criterion and the Mohr-Coulomb criterion. Results and Conclusion: Combined with the field blasting operations during the open-pit to underground mining in Daye iron mine, the blasting vibration safety criteria is calculated. It is obtained that the blasting vibration safety criteria for the north slope and the south slope are 11.08cm/s and 10.20cm/s respectively. The results agree well with the Safety Regulations for Blasting in China and provide a reference to determine blasting vibration safety criteria for other similar projects.

Interim PET-CT may predict PFS and OS in T-ALL/LBL adult patients.

T lymphoblastic leukemia/lymphoma (T-ALL/LBL) is highly aggressive. Although intensive chemotherapies such as ALL-type regimens are commonly used, about half adult patients eventually relapse and die of T-ALL/LBL. Overwhelming evidences have confirmed that interim PET can predict survival outcomes and guide subsequent treatments in Hodgkin lymphoma. However, whether interim PET-CT can predict survival outcomes or not in T-ALL/LBL patients remains unclear. 47 adult patients of T-ALL/LBL were retrospectively reviewed. Interim PET-CT was done after induction therapy and evaluated according to the International Harmonization Project criteria. After induction therapy, interim PET-CT was positive in 19 patients (40.4%). After a median follow up time of 34 months, the 2-year and 3-year progression free survival (PFS) rate were 39% and 30%, respectively, and the 2-year and 3-year overall survival (OS) rate were 54% and 45%, respectively. Using Kaplan-Meier survival analysis, it was found that interim PET-CT positivity correlated with significantly inferior PFS and OS (2-year PFS rate for patients with positive or negative interim PET were 21.1% or 56.0%, respectively, p = 0.002; 2-year OS rate for patients with positive or negative interim PET were 31.6% or 63.7%, respectively, p = 0.010). However, there was no significant relationship between PFS, OS and bone marrow infiltration, lactate dehydrogenase level, and stages (p > 0.05). Interim PET-CT may predict PFS and OS in adult patients of T-ALL/LBL, which needs to be validated in prospective clinical trials. The optimal criteria for interim PET-CT evaluation and risk-adapted treatment strategy determined by interim PET-CT should be investigated in future clinical practice.

Prediction of outcome in pediatric Hodgkin lymphoma based on interpretation of 18FDG-PET/CT according to ΔSUVmax, Deauville 5-point scale and IHP criteria.

Minimizing side effects by using response-adopted therapy strategies plays an important role in the management of pediatric Hodgkin lymphoma (HL); however, the criteria for the definition of adequate or inadequate response are controversial. The aim of this study is to compare different methods of interpretation of 18F-FDG-PET/CT (PET) in the prediction of disease outcome in order to determine the optimum method in this regard. Baseline, interim and post-treatment PET scans of 72 children were interpreted according to revised International Harmonization Project criteria (IHP) and Deauville criteria. Cut-off values for changes in interim and post-treatment FDG uptake (ΔSUVmax) in the prediction of progression-free survival (PFS) were measured using ROC analysis. Quantitative and visual data were compared with each other in the prediction of PFS. Mean interim and post-treatment ΔSUVmax of the primary lesions were 77.4±19.5 and 68.8±30.4% and respective cut-off values were 82 and 73%. However, only post-treatment ΔSUVmax yielded statistically significant results in the prediction of 3-year PFS (p=0.043). Interim ΔSUVmax was further analyzed according to the values reported in the literature (66 and 77%) yet statistically significant results were not reached (p=0.604 and 0.431). For interim evaluation, IHP criteria was correlated to Deauville criteria (p=0.002 and p=0.001) and ΔSUVmax (p=0.03), whereas for post-treatment evaluation, significant correlation with ΔSUVmax (p=0.04) but marginally significant (p=0.055 and p=0.058) correlation with Deauville criteria were achieved. Overall, 1, 3 and 5-year PFS were 95.7±0.2, 89.6±0.4 and 80.8±0.7%, respectively. All methods demonstrated comparable performance in the prediction of 3-year PFS; however, interim PET using Deauville criteria and post-treatment PET using IHP criteria were statistically significant. All methods demonstrated high negative-predictive value but substantially low positive-predictive value. Deauville criteria are superior to other methods in the prediction of pediatric HL outcome using interim PET data. On the other hand, quantitative evaluation and visual evaluation by IHP can be used reliably at the end of the treatment. In this regard, we report the optimal cut-off value of SUVmax reduction as 73%.

Environmental and economic foundations of system optimization of operational, technological and construction parameters of rice irrigation systems

The paper substantiates the necessity to carry out system optimization of operational, technological and construction parameters of water regulation in the operation of rice irrigation systems, lays out methodological approaches and results. This research formulates approaches to the selection of project criteria and conditions of economic and environmental optimization during the construction of complex optimization models in the projects of their reconstruction and operation taking into account climatic management strategies of such objects. The proposed set of measures as a result of system optimization is focused on improving the natural and amelioration state of rice irrigation systems, improving their technological and technical parameters, introducing of water and resource saving regimes of rice irrigation and related rice crop rotations.

DEVELOPING A FRAMEWORK FOR THE SUCCESS OF INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROJECTS IN THE MALDIVES

&#x0D; &#x0D; &#x0D; The paper concentrates on International Development (ID) projects implemented in the Maldives, an island nation in the Indian Ocean. Some of the critical issues reported on these projects include failure of contractors and consultants to deliver goods and services, non-compliance issues on financial management / reporting practices, and project delays. The overarching central question guiding the study is “How can project success be achieved in ID projects implemented in the Maldives?” This paper seeks to assess the challenges facing projects, explore the critical success factors, and project success criteria of ID projects in the Maldives. Furthermore, the study will look into developing a framework for the success of ID projects in the Maldives. It is intended to be carried out based on a qualitative case study approach. The study hopes to capture the views of beneficiaries, project teams, and donors, and thus, help resolve the misalignment between theoretical frameworks and practice.&#x0D; &#x0D; &#x0D;

Emilio Duhart, la arquitectura como estructura del espacio público: Plaza Foro Abierto - Universidad de Concepción

In 1957, Emilio Duhart Harosteguy was commissioned to plan the physical growth of the University of Concepcion for the next 25 years. What would initially be the development of a Master Plan for the entire university, became an elaborate urban-architectural plan, since the commission also included the drawing up of the associated architectural projects. This entailed a double opportunity for Duhart: to provide a coherent structure to the entire urban organization of the university campus and to shape the public space of the whole by means of the precise configuration defined by the new architecture. This paper attempts to reveal the project criteria assembled by the architect for the conformation of the Plaza del Foro Abierto (Open Forum Square), a public space that can be considered as the synthesis of the arguments elaborated by Duhart for the general plan. This square, which the architect himself designated as the center of gravity or heart of the university, has become, sixty years after its genesis, one of the public places with the greatest sense of belonging and identity for the city of Concepcion - the premise upon which this article is based.

Estimation procedure of the efficiency of the heat network segment

An extensive city heat network contains many segments, and each segment operates with different efficiency of heat energy transfer. This work proposes an original technical approach; it involves the evaluation of the energy efficiency function of the heat network segment and interpreting of two hyperbolic functions in the form of the transcendental equation. In point of fact, the problem of the efficiency change of the heat network depending on the ambient temperature was studied. Criteria dependences used for evaluation of the set segment efficiency of the heat network and finding of the parameters for the most optimal control of the heat supply process of the remote users were inferred with the help of the functional analysis methods. Generally, the efficiency function of the heat network segment is interpreted by the multidimensional surface, which allows illustrating it graphically. It was shown that the solution of the inverse problem is possible as well. Required consumption of the heating agent and its temperature may be found by the set segment efficient and ambient temperature; requirements to heat insulation and pipe diameters may be formulated as well. Calculation results were received in a strict analytical form, which allows investigating the found functional dependences for availability of the extremums (maximums) under the set external parameters. A conclusion was made that it is expedient to apply this calculation procedure in two practically important cases: for the already made (built) network, when the change of the heat agent consumption and temperatures in the pipe is only possible, and for the projecting (under construction) network, when introduction of changes into the material parameters of the network is possible. This procedure allows clarifying diameter and length of the pipes, types of insulation, etc. Length of the pipes may be considered as the independent parameter for calculations; optimization of this parameter is made in accordance with other, economical, criteria for the specific project.

Generation of Rainfall Intensity Duration Frequency (IDF) Curves for Ungauged Sites in Arid Region

We developed a method for Intensity Duration Frequency (IDF) curves in ungauged locations in arid region. The arid climate which covers most of Saudi Arabia is typically characterized by large temporal and spatial variations in rainfall distribution. The availability of long-term records of rainfall-runoff series would be useful to better estimate effective rainfall depth. The development process for an IDF curve for a remote, ungauged site is addressed through the use of rainfall record. The analyses focused on the application of two distributions: the Gumbel and Log Pearson III functions combined, to estimate the maximum rainfall for the various return periods in three stations in Al-Madinah region. The empirical intensity frequency equation is used to estimate rainfall intensity for design purposes for the ungauged location. The results of this research contribute to the development of IDF-based design criteria for water projects in ungauged sites located in arid and extreme arid regions.

A randomized, double-blind phase III study of ibrutinib versus placebo in combination with corticosteroids in patients with new onset chronic graft versus host disease.

TPS7072 Background: Chronic graft versus host disease (cGVHD) is a common complication of allogeneic stem cell transplantation, with pathophysiology involving alloreactive and dysregulated T and B cells and innate immune populations. Ibrutinib, a first-in-class, once-daily inhibitor of Bruton's tyrosine kinase, is indicated by the US FDA for the treatment of patients (pts) with CLL/SLL. Ibrutinib recently received breakthrough therapy and orphan drug designation for the treatment of pts with cGVHD who did not respond to one or more lines of systemic therapy. Ibrutinib reduces severity of cGVHD in murine models and recently was shown to achieve an NIH-defined overall response rate of 67% in pts with steroid relapsed/refractory cGVHD (Miklos Blood 2016). Methods: The primary objective of this Phase 3, multicenter, international, randomized, controlled, double-blind study is to evaluate the 24-week response rate of ibrutinib versus placebo in combination with prednisone. Pts with newly diagnosed moderate or severe cGVHD, as per NIH Consensus Development Project Criteria (2014), will be randomized in a 1:1 ratio to receive either oral ibrutinib (arm A) or placebo (arm B) in combination with oral prednisone. Ibrutinib or placebo will be given until unacceptable toxicity, relapse of underlying disease, death, or the need for a new systemic treatment for progressive cGVHD. Eligible study pts (age ≥12 yrs) must require systemic treatment with corticosteroids and have no prior systemic treatment for cGVHD. The primary endpoint is response rate (complete or partial response) at 24 weeks, as per NIH Consensus Development Project Criteria, and must occur in the absence of both new therapy for cGVHD and relapse/return of the underlying disease that was the indication for transplant. Secondary endpoints will assess for additional clinical benefit including corticosteroid dose reduction, improvement of Lee cGVHD Symptom Scale scores, withdrawal of all immunosuppressants, and overall survival. This study is currently enrolling pts. Funding source: Pharmacyclics LLC, an AbbVie Company. Clinical trial information: NCT02959944.

Project Leadership and Quality Performance of Construction Projects

Background: The construction industry in Nigeria, is pigeonholed by poor quality of construction products as a result of the inherent corruption in the country. Lack of purposeful leadership and inappropriate choice of leadership styles in the industry have been attributed to project failure. Abandoned and failed projects are more predominant in the public sector which litters every corner of the country. Objectives: The objective of this paper is to assess the impact of leadership styles on quality performance criteria of public projects in Nigeria. Methodology: A total of 43 questionnaires were distributed to 3 key groups of respondents (Quantity Surveyors, Builders, and Architects) who are project managers in Nigeria. Descriptive and Inferential statistics were used to analyse the data using the Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS). Likert Scale was used to measure the independent variables (leadership style): facilitative, coaching, delegating and directing; and the level of achievement of projects based on the dependent variables (quality and function performance criteria) which are: achieving highest aesthetic quality; and functional building that fits its purpose. Findings: The study revealed that Directing is the major leadership style used by project managers in Nigeria. Amongst the leadership styles which has the most impact on quality performance indicators is also directing which has the most relative influence on achieving highest aesthetic quality and functional building that fits its purpose. Conclusion/Recommendation/Way forward: The underlying relationship between Directing leadership styles and the performance criteria of achieving highest aesthetic quality and functional building that fits its purpose will be beneficial to the Nigerian construction environment.

Evaluation of Urban Planning Projects Criteria Using Fuzzy AHP Technique

In this research, Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Process technique is applied (Fuzzy AHP) which is one of multi-criteria decision making techniques to evaluate the criteria for urban planning projects, the project of developing master plan of Al-Muqdadiyah city to 2035 has been chosen as a case study. The researcher prepared a list of criteria in addition to the authorized departments criteria and previous researches in order to choose optimized master plan according to these criteria. This research aims at employing the foundations of (Fuzzy AHP) technique in evaluating urban planning criteria precisely and flexible. The results of the data analysis to the individuals of the sample who are specialists, in this aspect. The land use criteria are more important than the rest of the criteria in these projects, where it received the relative importance with percentile (42.1 %).

Evaluation of Planned Construction Projects Using Fuzzy Logic

The study presents a model for the evaluation of construction projects from the point of view of the client (e.g. developer company). The problem lies in choosing the best solution from the point of view of many criteria. The proposed model is based on a multi-criteria comparative analysis using fuzzy logic. The first part of the paper presents a selection of criteria describing the construction project along with their description. The set of attributes describing the analysed object was determined on the basis of the synthesis of specific proposals for the parameters of construction projects. The set of criteria has been divided into two groups: technical, technological and organisational criteria and separately the economic criteria. Then, the number of variables describing the observations was checked using principal component analysis (PCA). Course of action was presented in the event of multiple criteria analysis using the fuzzy set theory. Both the weights and the evaluations of individual criteria were modelled using membership functions due to the fact that when describing a construction project, or the validity of the criteria of describing variables, they are approximate. An analysis of the correlation of selected project criteria was presented. The proposed decision support model of assessing a construction project makes possible to compare various variants based on 11 factors identified. The use of fuzzy logic has enabled more accurate description of the phenomenon analysed when the exact parameters of the project in the planning and preparation stage of the project are not known.

Implementing the INTERGROWTH-21st fetal growth standards in France: a 'flash study' of the College Français d'Echographie Foetale (CFEF).

To assess potential differences in fetal size between the French population and the international population from the INTERGROWTH-21st (IG-21st ) Project and to measure the impact of switching to the IG-21st reference standards for fetal size. This was a nationwide cross-sectional study of fetal ultrasound biometry. Low-risk singleton pregnancies were recruited prospectively within the network of the national French College of Fetal Ultrasound, CFEF, over a 6-week period. Further selection was performed based on the criteria of the IG-21st Project in order to obtain a comparable population. Head circumference (HC) was used as the main fat-free skeletal measure of growth for comparison of French fetal size with that of the IG-21st population. The impact of switching to the IG-21st fetal growth standards was quantified by comparing Z-scores calculated using the IG-21st standards with those calculated using locally derived reference ranges for HC, abdominal circumference (AC) and femur length (FL). Following selection, 4858 cases were analyzed. The distribution of HC demonstrated clear similarity between our French population and the IG-21st population: our observed centile curves closely matched those of IG-21st and the Z-scores were close to 0 across gestational age. The IG-21st standards performed as well as did locally derived charts in terms of screening for small-for-gestational age by AC, while they identified significantly fewer small FL values than were expected and than did the locally derived charts. Under strict selection criteria, fetal size in France is similar to that of the international population used in the IG-21st Project. The discrepancies in FL are unlikely to impact on prenatal management. Therefore, switching from locally derived reference ranges to the IG-21st standards appears to be a safe option. Copyright © 2016 ISUOG. Published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd.

Spatially blind or place based policy? A comparison of innovation support in the Czech and Slovak Republic

With the ongoing changes in development of the European Union, also conditions for fi nancial support are changing. For Central Europe, most fi nancial aid comes from Cohesion policies. The same applies for the support of innovations, which are considered to be a driving force of development. One of the main debates concerning cohesion policy is the issue of “placed based” versus “spatially blind” policies. Their role mainly differs within the area of economic growth. This paper deals with the evaluation of innovation support as a driving force for economic growth from structural funds in two neighbouring EU member states – in Slovakia and the Czech Republic. This article provides a picture of what kinds of policies are implemented and how consequently the resources of the European Union are territorially distributed to support innovation. We especially dealt with the question of the support criteria for projects and their role in the implementation of support. Based on this, the paper tries to identify where assistance is concentrated and how the criteria infl uence the geographical distribution of this support. As a result, we found that, despite very similar spatially blind policies in both countries and very similar systems of providing support, they still have very different regional effects. In the Czech Republic, support was allocated to developed regions and high tech sectors to a greater extent. In the Slovak Republic, support was concentrated more on disadvantaged regions and in traditional sectors with lower added value. It shows the need to pay much more attention not only to policy set up, but also to policy implementation.

Theoretical and methodological foundations of organizing students’ project activity in institutions of children’s and youth arts

The paper presents theoretical and methodological foundations of students project activity organization in institutions of childrens and youth arts. The retrospective analysis of scientific publications and advanced pedagogical experience related to young people creative development in the system of supplementary education (centers of childrens and youth arts et al.) proves that project technology plays a dominant role in encouraging students to learn modeling and design engineering as well as acquiring skills of independent creative activity. Values and advantages of project technology distinguish it favorably from traditional and innovative pedagogical technologies. The paper shows that project technology is oriented to integration, synthesis of students theoretical knowledge and their practical activity: it means that carrying out a project we not only set a specific creative task but also do our best to put it into practice in the form of pictures, drawings, applications, software, dummies, devices, robots, etc. Undertaking a particular project the student is supposed to learn how to identify social and technical contradictions and problems and overcome them. Project technology is focused on students creative work which helps to develop and strengthen the skills required to organize their independent work. The paper introduces the typology of training projects used in the center of childrens and youth arts as well as the techniques of their individual and selective choice. There is a focus on basic classification criteria of training projects: leading modality of students training and cognitive activity; the levels of interdisciplinary integration of knowledge acquired by the students while carrying out the project; subjects and conditions for project activity organization.

Success criteria of toll road projects from a community societal perspective

PurposeWhile the success of the toll road projects procured through public private partnerships (PPPs) routes are widely confined to the cost, time and quality performance in the delivery context, considerable evidence suggests that such success criteria are not sufficient when the toll road projects are assessed in relation to meeting the long-run community expectations. The purpose of this paper is to examine the key factors associated with the success of the toll road projects from a societal perspective in Indonesia.Design/methodology/approachBased on the input from 12 experts and a rigorous literature review, a questionnaire survey was designed and a total of 206 respondents from three broad stakeholders’ groups, namely, government, private and end-users’ communities were surveyed to measure the performance of eight toll road projects. The data were primarily analyzed using exploratory factor analysis and reliability test using SPSS Software.FindingsFour significant factors associated with the project social benefit were established as a measure of the overall success criteria in toll road projects. It is expected these can be used as guidance to deliver project social benefit to the community in the overall project lifecycle.Research limitations/implicationsThis research contributes to the incorporation of social project benefit attributes to the the toll road projects’ success criteria in overall project lifecycle.Practical implicationsThis study can be used as guidance for the overall stakeholders, such as the government and the project manager to address the current social problems and better navigate the project direction in order to achieve the overall toll road project success in the overall project lifecycles.Social implicationsThe research highlights how the Indonesian government’s program of developing toll road projects using the PPP procurement routes can be supported for complete social inclusivity by considering the social dimension to achieve long-term success.Originality/valueIdentification of the key project social factors based on the data set with a wide representation of the stakeholders has made the research original and unique.