CPR Providers Research Articles

Prospective evaluation of tools to assess the psychological response of CPR provision to a relative who has suffered a cardiac arrest: A pilot project

Objectives We aimed to evaluate assessment tools to measure the psychological impact of providing CPR to a relative. We set out to evaluate the Revised Impact of Event Scale (IES-R) and Texas Inventory of Grief (TIG) for comparing CPR providers and non-providers, and to establish whether research of this nature had a negative impact on the participants. We also collected narrative data from CPR providers. Methods Prospective sampling of relatives of patients presenting to hospital who had witnessed their relative have a cardiac arrest and who had performed or witnessed CPR. Participants performed two interviews and completed the IES-R and the TIG. Results Twenty-nine cardiac arrest victims presented, with ten relatives enrolled. The IES-R and TIG were feasible, and registered moderate responses from CPR providers and non-providers. There was no significant difference in the IES-R score between CPR providers and non-providers (1.96 vs. 1.04, p = 0.3). There was no significant difference between scores obtained at two different time points (1.75 vs. 1.63, p = 0.43). Participants demonstrated a moderate response on the TIG (mean TIG score 2.8, SD 1.7). Participants did not have a negative perception of study involvement, and actually perceived a benefit from discussion with a health professional. Conclusion It is acceptable and achievable to prospectively assess the response of a cardiac arrest victim's relatives to the provision of CPR. The test instruments used were appropriate and feasible. Results suggested a sample size of 48 to achieve a statistically significant result.

The Impact of Education on Provider Attitudes Toward Family-Witnessed Resuscitation

The majority of acute care facilities have not developed policies or guidelines to facilitate family presence during cardiopulmonary resuscitation. Prior studies have shown that the personal beliefs and attitudes of hospital personnel involved in resuscitation efforts are the primary reasons family presence is not offered. This 2-phase, before/after study was conducted in a 388-bed academic trauma center, and in a 143-bed community hospital in eastern Washington State in 2008. In phase I, a convenience sample of physicians and registered nurses from both facilities were surveyed about their opinions and beliefs regarding family-witnessed resuscitation (FWR). Spearman's rho and independent t-tests were used to compare support of FWR between and within roles and practice location subgroups. In phase II of the study, clinician subgroups in the community hospital were re-surveyed following an educational program that used evidence-based information. Independent t-test and one-way ANOVA were used to compare pre and post-education mean scores of subgroups on indicators of effective teaching strategies and improved FWR support. Opinions on FWR vary within and between practice roles and locations, with the strongest variable of support being prior experience with FWR. Following FWR education, mean scores improved for survey variables chosen as indicators of FWR support and teaching effectiveness. When CPR providers are presented with FWR education, their opinion-based beliefs may be modified, decreasing barriers to family witnessed resuscitation and improving overall support of FWR as an extension of family-centered care.

“Rolling Refreshers”: A novel approach to maintain CPR psychomotor skill competence

Objectives High quality CPR skill retention is poor. We hypothesized that “just-in-time” and “just-in-place” training programs would be effective and well-accepted to maintain CPR skills among PICU staff. Methods “Rolling Refreshers”, a portable manikin/defibrillator system with chest compression sensor providing automated corrective feedback to optimize CPR skills, were conducted daily in the PICU with multidisciplinary healthcare providers. Providers practiced CPR until skill success was attained, prospectively defined as <3 corrective prompts within 30 s targeting chest compression (CC) rate 90–120/min, CC depth >38 mm during continuous CPR. Providers completing ≥2 refreshers/month (Frequent Refreshers [FR]) were compared to providers completing <2 refreshers/month (Infrequent Refreshers [IR]) for time to achieve CPR skill success. Univariate analysis performed using non-parametric methods. Following actual cardiac arrests, CPR providers were surveyed for subjective feedback on training approach efficacy (5-point Likert scale; 1 = poor to 5 = excellent). Results Over 15 weeks, 420 PICU staff were “refreshed”: 340 nurses, 34 physicians, 46 respiratory therapists. A consecutive sample of 20 PICU staff was assessed before subsequent refresher sessions (FREQ n = 10, INFREQ n = 10). Time to achieve CPR skill success was significantly less in FREQ (median 21 s, IQR: 15.75–30 s) than in INFREQ (median 67 s, IQR: 41.5–84 s; p < 0.001). Following actual resuscitations, CPR providers ( n = 9) rated “Rolling Refresher” training as effective (mean = 4.2; Likert scale 1–5; standard deviation 0.67). Conclusions A novel “Rolling Refresher” CPR skill training approach using “just-in-time” and “just-in-place” simulation is effective and well received by PICU staff. More frequent refreshers resulted in significantly shorter times to achieve proficient CPR skills.

Teaching recognition of agonal breathing improves accuracy of diagnosing cardiac arrest

Agonal breathing is present in up to 40% of pre-hospital cardiac arrests and is commonly mistaken as a sign of circulation leading to omission of bystander resuscitation. The aim of this study was to test the hypothesis that specific tuition on agonal breathing improves the accuracy of checking for signs of circulation as a diagnostic test for cardiac arrest. First year medical students were randomised to control or intervention groups. The control group were taught standard CPR according to current guidelines. The intervention group received standard CPR training plus specific tuition on the characteristics of agonal breathing. Two weeks after initial training, the students' ability to recognise cardiac arrest was tested using a simulated cardiac arrest victim demonstrating normal, absent or agonal breathing. Diagnostic accuracy, sensitivity and specificity for the decision to start CPR was calculated. Sixty-four students were equally randomised to intervention and control groups. The intervention group had greater diagnostic accuracy for cardiac arrest compared to the control group (90% versus 78%, P=0.03). The intervention group were more likely to recognise cardiac arrest correctly and initiate CPR than the control group (sensitivity 90% versus 78%, P=0.02). The improved results were predominantly due to recognition that agonal breathing is a sign of cardiac arrest (75% intervention group versus 43% control group, P=0.01). This study demonstrates improved diagnostic accuracy and sensitivity of "checking for signs of circulation" by teaching CPR providers to recognise agonal breathing as a sign of cardiac arrest.

Decay in Quality of Closed-Chest Compressions Over Time

Study objective: To characterize fatigue-induced deterioration in the adequacy of closed-chest compressions performed over a period of 5 minutes and to determine whether CPR providers can recognize the effects of fatigue on compression adequacy. Design: Prospective evaluation of study subjects performing closed-chest compressions on an electronic mannequin that assesses compression placement and depth. Setting: Major resuscitation room in rural university hospital emergency department. Participants: Eleven experienced nursing assistants who regularly provide CPR in the ED. Results: Each study participant performed 5 minutes of closed-chest compressions. Compression adequacy (for placement and depth) was assessed with the mannequin and reported on an attached monitor out of view of the study subjects. Subjects were asked to verbally indicate the point during their 5-minute compression period at which they felt too fatigued to provide effective compressions (arbitrarily defined as a minimum of 90% of all compressions being judged correct by the mannequin). We used one-way repeated-measures ANOVA and regression analysis to determine whether compression adequacy diminished over time. ANOVA was also used to determine whether the total compressions performed per minute diminished over time. The percentage of correct chest compressions decreased significantly after 1 minute of compressions (P =.0001). We found 92.9% of compressions performed during minute 1 to be correct. The percentages for minutes 2 through 5 were as follows: 67.1%, 39.2%, 31.2%, and 18.0%. Regression analysis revealed a decrement in compression adequacy of 18.6% per minute after the first minute of compressions. The number of total compressions attempted per minute did not decrease (P =.98). Study subjects did not accurately identify the point during their 5-minute sessions at which their fatigue caused compressions to become impaired. Whereas mean compression adequacy declined below 90% after only 1 minute, the time of indicated fatigue was 253±40 seconds (mean±SD). Conclusion: Although compression rate was maintained over time, chest compression quality declined significantly over the study period. Because CPR providers could not recognize their inability to provide proper compressions, cardiac arrest team leaders should carefully monitor compression adequacy during CPR to assure maximally effective care for patients receiving CPR. [Hightower D, Thomas SH, Stone CK, Dunn K, March JA: Decay in quality of closed-chest compressions over time. Ann Emerg Med September 1995;26:300-303.]

A comparison of chest compressions between mechanical and manual CPR by monitoring end-tidal Pco 2 during human cardiac arrest

To compare the use of mechanical and manual chest compressions during cardiac arrest based on continuous monitoring of end-tidal PCO2 (PETCO2). Prospective, randomized, crossover design. Fifteen consecutive adults ranging in age from 33 to 78 years who presented in nontraumatic cardiac arrest to the emergency department of a large teaching hospital. Study protocols were begun late in the resuscitation after initial resuscitation attempts were unsuccessful. Patients received four alternating five-minute trials (two manual and two mechanical), being randomized to begin with either technique. Mechanical compressions were performed by a mechanical device at a compression depth of 2 in. Both mechanical and manual compressions were delivered at a rate of 80 with a ventilation delivered after every fifth compression. Persons performing manual CPR were experienced American Heart Association basic life support providers, and no person performed manual CPR more than once during the study period. No resuscitative drugs were administered during the study period. PETCO2 was monitored continuously; those performing manual CPR were blinded to the PETCO2 monitor. Data were analyzed with repeated-measures analysis of variance and Scheffé multiple comparisons with the alpha error rate set of .05. Mean PETCO2 during mechanical CPR was 13.6 +/- 4.14 mm Hg compared with 6.9 +/- 2.42 mm Hg during manually performed CPR (P < .001), a difference of 97%. Average mechanical CPR PETCO2 was higher in all cases. No patient was resuscitated successfully. Capnography also indicated that most CPR providers were inconsistent in their chest compressions. This study suggests that cardiac output produced with mechanical chest compressions is greater than that produced with manual compressions as demonstrated by the significantly higher PETCO2 levels during mechanical CPR. Reasons for this are unclear. In addition, monitoring of PETCO2 may help optimize chest compressions during CPR.

Infection control guidelines for CPR providers

Infection control guidelines for CPR providers