Scholars seeking to relate the Middle English Athelston to its historical contexts have worked primarily to identify historical prototypes for the tale's major characters, especially its rash, violent, and easily led king. Unfortunately, such a profile leaves open all too wide a field of medieval monarchs, and no consensus has been reached.1 This essay approaches the relationship between history and an anonymous romance from another direction: it examines the historical basis for the tale's urgency, the reasons for its representation of a world beset by personal anxiety and national crisis. In simple binary terms, Athelston dramatizes a long, slow, and highly complex cultural shift that took place in England over the course of the Middle Ages, the gradual transition from a social system based on personal, oath-based relationships to a centralized bureaucracy reliant upon documentary records.2 Although the tale's stark polarizations simplify a complex process, the anonymous author conveys with clarity and emotional force his perspective on a highly significant cultural change.While many Middle English romances introduce themselves as tales of a particular hero, this strange and angry narrative, untitled in its unique manuscript version, announces itself as a tale of 'falsnesse' (line 8).3 Four men with no blood relationship - 'Þat sybbe were nou3t off kyn' (line 12) - and no common place of origin - 'Ylke man was of dyuers cuntre' (line 20) - share the same occupation: 'alle foure messangeres þey were, / Þat wolden yn Yngelond lettrys bere' (lines 13f.). Like many characters in medieval narrative, including the 'sondry folk, by aventure yfalle / In felaweshipe' (I.25f.) in the opening lines of Chaucer's Canterbury Tales,4 the four messengers take pleasure in their fortuitous meeting and quickly decide to enter into an oath-based relationship. As we shall see, the poet considers such relationships essential to social life,5 but represents them as deeply endangered by the erosion of trouthe, the personal fidelity to one's oaths and pledges that alone makes such affiliations possible.Just as the Canterbury pilgrims Othes swore / With ful glad herte' to form a voluntary association where no bond previously existed (I.810f.), so the four messengers in Athelston spontaneously bind themselves:The idea of strangers joyfully forming ad hoc, voluntary, oath-based associations had a strong pull on the imaginations of Ricardian writers; another memorable example is the 'covenant' sworn between Gawain and his apparently newly met host to initiate their exchange of winnings, again accompanied by laughter, joy, and, as in The Canterbury Tales (I.819f.), a bargain-sealing drink.6 In narratives of the later fourteenth century, including both Sir Gawain and the Green Knight and The Canterbury Tales, these oath-based associations, so gaily entered into, can be subjected to considerable strain. In Athelston, the strain is especially severe: out of secret malice, one of the swearers immediately betrays his oath, and the consequences are calamitous, not just for the four sworn brothers, but for the whole nation.The perception that falsnesse posed a threat to the foundations of social life was widespread in late fourteenth-century England. In a well-known passage, Chaucer has the lordly Arveragus of his Franklin's Tale assert that 'Trouthe is the hyeste thyng that man may kepe' (V.1479), but one of the insurrectionist letters attributed to the radical priest John Ball had recently proclaimed it too late to 'kepe' a lost ideal: 'trewpe hat bene sette under a lokke, / And fal[s]nes regneth ...' Contemporary sermons quote verses that spread the same bad news: 'falsenes, I vnderstande, / haues clreuen trwvte of lande.'7 Widespread feelings of disillusionment and betrayal are hardly unique to this period, but the prevalence of this perception at this historical moment is especially interesting because trouthe in its traditional meaning was indeed being driven out of the land, if not by falsnesse, then by a semantic change with wide-ranging cultural implications. …
Read full abstract