The activity of crystalline contact insecticides relies on the extraction of surface molecules by insect tarsi upon contact. Most crystals are inherently anisotropic, and surface molecules on symmetry independent faces are expected to have different free energies. The facet-dependent bioavailability and associated efficacy of insect lethality have not been investigated, however. We discriminate the bioactivity of various facets of single crystals of DDT (1,1,1-trichloro-2,2-bis(4-chlorophenyl)ethane), a well-known contact insecticide. Our findings reveal facet-dependent lethality differences of nearly 75% among four crystallographically unique facets. Furthermore, computations reveal that the respective lethalities of the facets are strongly correlated with the detachment energies of molecules from the crystal surfaces. This facet-dependent lethality suggests a pathway to enhance the efficacy of known contact insecticides through crystal habit control.