The Russo-Japanese War and the peace overture that followed it at Portsmouth's naval yard in New Hampshire in 1905 marked a turning point in world history, and it also reshaped the future course of the Asia Pacific region and the world at large. It is quite true that for many people in the world, the Portsmouth Peace Treaty is the story of the negotiations between Russia and Japan. But if one takes a hard look at the preparation for peacemaking in terms of mediation, it is not just the story of two nations. Rather it is the story of more than three nations. When it comes to the question of who hosted the peace conference or the peace making effort, no one argues that it was the Americans led by American President Theodore Roosevelt, as he hosted the treaty negotiations in such a way as to put the U.S.'s own stamp on the final outcome. This led us to believe that President Theodore Roosevelt acted successfully as a mediator to bring the Russian-Japanese conflict to an end. But in reality Roosevelt was faced with a number of predicaments. For example, when Roosevelt set about making the arrangements for the peace conference, as a mediator he was very apprehensive about the prospects for its success. The Tsar wanted to clarify his own thoughts and bring himself to a decision for peace. The Tsar's message, which Cassini brought to Roosevelt on June 6, 1905, indicated that Russia would not seek peace or mediation. Thus, Roosevelt was forced to seek to influence Russia through its European allies, as most of the trouble, as he doubtless expected, came from the Russian side. But the Russian Tsar Nicholas and some other European diplomats characterized Roosevelt's peace efforts as premature and indiscreet. Roosevelt avowed that he was speaking for the interests of the world as well as those of Russia. He did not want Russia driven off the Pacific slope, and this message convinced the Tsar. (Jusserand to Declasse, telegram, May 15, 1905, Documents diplomatique francais, 2d ser., 6:509-10; Roosevelt to Lodge, May 15, 1905, and Roosevelt to Meyer, May 24, 1905, Morison, Letters of Theodore Roosevelt, 4:1179-82, 1190-91.) For example, when Roosevelt hoped that the British government would join in the campaign to moderate Japan's demands, he was destined to be disappointed. When Roosevelt broached the subject to British Ambassador Durand, he received a cool and evasive response. The purpose of this research paper is not to scrutinize the document of the Portsmouth Peace Conference, nor does it cover the whole spectrum of the mediation efforts made by the American President Theodore Roosevelt. Rather this research paper deals with: 1) the course of the Russo-Japanese War; 2) the diplomatic action of the Japanese government after the declaration of war; and 3) how allies on both sides of the Russian and Japanese conflict (France and Germany allied with Russia, Great Britain allied with Japan) together with the United States, tried to take a number of steps to prepare a mediation role before the Portsmouth Peace Treaty.
Read full abstract