Concentrated Solar Power Research Articles

A Review of Solar and Wind Energy Resource Projection Based on the Earth System Model

Many countries around the world are rapidly advancing sustainable development (SD) through the exploitation of clean energy sources such as solar and wind energy, which are becoming the core of the sustainable energy transition. In recent years, the continuous advancement of Earth system models (ESMs) has facilitated numerous studies utilizing them to predict long-term and large-scale meteorological elements, consequently enabling forecasts of wind and solar energy. These forecasts provide critical guidance for formulating national renewable energy policies. Nevertheless, the current literature on ESMs predicting wind and solar energy lacks sufficient integration. Hence, to comprehend the focal points and future research prospects, we conducted this systematic review, employing four academic search tools to comprehensively analyze the relevant literature from the past five years. We summarized the general analytical process and compared the content and conclusions of the literature. The study reveals that future photovoltaic (PV) potential for electricity generation may increase in certain regions but decrease in others, while the global potential for concentrated solar power (CSP) may diminish, influenced by diverse factors and displaying significant regional disparities. In addition, wind resource trends vary in different regions, and forecasts exhibit considerable uncertainty. Therefore, many studies have corrected wind speeds prior to predicting wind energy. Subsequent research endeavors should concentrate on optimizing ESMs, investigating the impacts of technological innovation, and enhancing the prediction and analysis of extreme weather events.

Summary Paper: An Initial Heliostat Supply Chain Analysis

This paper summarizes the prior analysis, key findings, and recommendations from the published report titled “Initial Heliostat Supply Chain Analysis” [1]. Globally, the growing demand for concentrating solar power (CSP) technologies, primarily for electricity generation plants has been met with supply chains primarily composed of plentiful commodity materials such as steel, aluminum, and glass. Often the commodity materials can be sourced in the domestic market where power plant will be constructed. Although specialty components are required for CSP solar fields —including mirror panels used for heliostat applications—these specialty components constitute about 30-50% of total system installed costs [2]. Only a few companies and countries, including the United States, have developed the capacity to supply such specialty components. The U.S. heliostat supply chain at present is comprised of few companies (e.g., CSP developers), component suppliers, and is its infancy.
 By 2035, with current and aggressive solar photovoltaic (PV) capacity expansions, there is the potential for 500,000–1,500,000 direct and indirect jobs in the areas of manufacturing, installation and development, and operations and maintenance (O&M) [3]. Utilizing the CSP capacity estimations the recent NREL report [4], the construction of 39 gigawatts (GW) of CSP (assuming mainly power tower) in the U.S. could lead to approximately 195,000 manufacturing, construction, and O&M jobs. This does not include the longer-term jobs and economic impact (e.g., taxes from plant operations staff) from operating the plants once constructed. It is recommended that further CSP component and system supply chain analysis and modelling be undertaken.

Towards CSP technology modeling in power system expansion planning

Power systems with a high level of renewable energy penetration face challenges due to the inherent properties of some renewable energy sources, such as their variability and uncertainty. These systems require reliable technologies capable of handling large ramps and flexibility needs. Concentrating Solar Power (CSP) has been identified as one solution, which has been researched and implemented in several countries. This paper presents a novel analysis and evaluation of the impacts of choosing an inadequate representation of CSP technology in power system planning tools. The current state of CSP in power system expansion planning in the literature is examined, providing a classification for the modeling of investment and operation of CSP plants. Based on a proposed analysis framework, different models and configurations for CSP plants are evaluated and applied to a 5-bus test system. One of the key findings is that the selected model highly impacts the computational effort (150% more processing time), the quality of the planning decision (14% more overall costs), and the total emissions (up to 52% more emissions). A storage-based model proves to be the most suitable option, considering the operation and investment costs, as well as computational burden. The selected model achieves a 1% error compared to the results obtained with a reference model, while also requiring 40% less computation effort. The proposed framework can be applied to other power system structures by choosing the best suited CSP modeling.

Design of reactive particle fluidized bed heat exchangers for gas–solid thermochemical energy storage

Concentrated solar power (CSP) systems integrated with a supercritical carbon dioxide (sCO2) Brayton power cycle are regarded as the primary future direction for CSP technologies. Calcium-based particles can be a suitable storage medium to achieve high temperatures exceeding 750 ℃. However, there have been few studies on reactive particle/sCO2 heat exchangers (HXs) to drive high-performance power cycles with high energy storage efficiencies. In this paper, the mechanisms by which chemically reactive particles release energy in a fluidized bed (FB) heat exchanger has been investigated to evaluate the performance of thermochemical storage systems. A 1-MWt thermal duty fluidized bed heat exchanger with sCO2 as the working fluid operating at 988 K was designed in different configurations, featuring single stage and multistage counter-flow HXs. A detailed shell and tube model combining the chemical reaction kinetics and the heat transfer between the fluidized particle and sCO2 FB HX design was developed. A comparison of sensible and chemical heat materials shows that thermochemical energy storage is advantageous due to the relatively short tube length and slow particle mass flow rate. The tube length and particle mass flow rate are reduced by 3.5 and 11.5 times, respectively. The average chemical conversion is 97.30 % for a one-stage heat exchanger, which is lower than the 99.95 % conversion achieved by the two-stage heat exchanger. Additionally, a sensitivity analysis was carried out to understand the impacts of key operating parameters on the process performance. These findings provide insights into the operational stability and efficiency of the system, contributing to the development of advanced heat exchangers for thermochemical energy storage applications.

New frontiers in thermal energy storage: An experimental analysis of thermophysical properties and thermal stability of a novel ternary chloride molten salt

It has been always a daunting task to develop thermal systems with a wide range of thermochemical properties and high stability. It presents a significant challenge, especially when aiming to utilize them for heat storage and transfer applications. In this regard, the thermal characteristics and thermal stability behaviour of molten salt mixture as a heat transfer fluid (HTF) at high temperatures were explored. A novel ternary eutectic salt mixture (base mixture) made of cuprous chloride (CuCl), potassium chloride (KCl) and sodium chloride (NaCl) was investigated as HTF for thermal energy storage (TES) system with a range up to 653 °C in a concentrated solar power (CSP) plant. To extend the temperature span and stability, the effect of an additive was investigated. Different compositions were studied in detail concerning the properties and stability regarding the additive. The molten salt with 7 % CaCl2 additive improved thermal stability and operating temperature from 653 °C to 700 °C. The transport characteristics and thermal stability of the eutectic mixture with and without the additive were measured by high-temperature thermal analyzers. The results indicated that the melting temperature decreased and the average specific heat capacity considerably increased with the addition of CaCl2 additive compared to the ternary chloride base mixture. As the temperature increased, the eutectic salt mixture exhibited a reduction in viscosity and density. The viscosity and density of the salt mixture with and without the additive were almost uniform at 700 °C. The average thermal conductivity of the ternary salt mixture with and without additives was 0.72 W/(m°C) which is much more than that of Solar and Hitec salts. In a 100 h experiment of long-period isothermal stability, the eutectic salt mixture showed less than 4 % weight loss at 700 °C. It was defined as the highest operating temperature at which the eutectic salt mixture remained stable. The stability and recyclability of the salt mixture were confirmed through the short-period stability test. The effect of the CaCl2 additive on thermal stability of base salt mixture was analyzed by X-ray Diffraction (XRD) and X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (XPS) techniques. According to the results, this novel eutectic salt mixture had outstanding thermal stability up to 700 °C and could be employed as a viable TES material in CSP plants.

Heat Transfer Performance Tests of a Circular-Fin Sodium-to-Air Heat Exchanger for Sodium-Cooled Fast Reactors

Shell and tube-type crossflow heat exchangers with circular fins are widely used in various industries, including nuclear power plants. This study focuses on the sodium-to-air heat exchanger, which is one of the key safety features in sodium-cooled fast reactors. Tube alignment inside the heat exchanger is important because it directly determines the performance. Although heat exchangers are generally designed to have staggered tube alignment, inevitable inline-aligned zones exist. Therefore, this paper proposes a hybrid tube alignment modeling approach that considers both staggered and inline tube heat transfer phenomena. The results of the hybrid model calculations are verified and validated with liquid sodium experiments. The hybrid approach to the tube arrangement reduced the temperature deviation between experimental and calculated values to a difference of 4.55% and 7.38% for both sodium and air sides, respectively, while for the heat transfer, the difference was 15.12% and 9.06% for sodium and air sides, respectively. The results of this study can also be used as a basis for the safety evaluation of nuclear reactors and licensing processes for sodium-cooled fast reactors. In addition, this study is limited not only to sodium heat exchangers but also to any serpentine tube arrangement or crossflow heat exchanger under high-temperature systems, such as concentrated solar power and thermal energy storage industries.

An open-loop control algorithm for improved tracking in a heliostat

The growing energy demand and its relation to climate change have driven the search for sustainable alternatives, such as concentrated solar energy. In this context, heliostats play a crucial role by reflecting and concentrating solar light onto a receiver. However, traditional control approaches based on geographical data have limitations. This study introduces an autonomous control system for heliostats that eliminates the need for preloaded geographical data. The approach is based on communication between the heliostat and the solar tracker, with two configuration modes: map calibration and automatic. Centralized and autonomous heliostats are distinguished, with the latter being the focus of the study. Autonomous heliostats have their own control system and can make decisions regarding positioning and safety. The methodology involves a mathematical algorithm that calculates the optimal rotation and tilt of the heliostat to redirect light toward a target. Simulation and physical prototype testing validate a remarkable consistency between simulated and experimental data. A key result is the surprising similarity of 97.9% between the obtained data, validating the algorithm's effectiveness. This study provides a robust approach for designing autonomous heliostat control systems, integrating simulation and experimentation. These results support the algorithm's precision and ability to direct solar radiation effectively. Expanding towards autonomous control and complete heliostat system evaluation facilitates the path toward more efficient and sustainable concentrated solar energy.

Thermodynamic Analysis of a Cogeneration System Combined with Heat, Cold, and Electricity Based on the Supercritical CO2 Power Cycle

The supercritical CO2 power cycle driven by solar as a new generation of solar thermal power generation technology has drawn significant attention worldwide. In this paper, a cogeneration system derived from a supercritical CO2 recompression Brayton cycle is proposed, by considering the recovery of waste heat from the turbine outlet. The absorption refrigeration cycle is powered by the medium-temperature waste heat from the turbine outlet, while the low-temperature waste heat is employed for heating, achieving the cascaded utilization of the heat from the turbine outlet. As for the proposed combined cooling, heating, and power (CCHP) system, a dynamic model was built and verified in MATLAB R2021b/Simulink. Under design conditions, values for the energy utilization factor (EUF) and exergy efficiency of the cogeneration system were obtained. Moreover, the thermodynamic performances of the system were investigated in variable cooling/heating load and irradiation conditions. Compared with the reference system, it is indicated that the energy utilization factor (EUF) and exergy efficiency are 84.7% and 64.8%, which are improved by 11.5% and 10.3%. The proposed supercritical CO2 CCHP system offers an effective solution for the efficient utilization of solar energy.

Renewable Horizons: Solar Power and Dairy Industry in India

Renewable energy is energy obtained from sources that are essentially inexhaustible such as wind power, solar power, geothermal energy, tidal power, bio-energy and hydropower. It is also known as non-conventional energy. Harnessing renewable energy offers numerous environmental benefits, including mitigating climate change, reducing air pollution, conserving natural resources, and enhancing energy security by diversifying energy sources. Solar resources are available in every country and both Solar Photovoltaic (SPV) and Concentrating Solar Power (CSP) technologies can be used to convert solar resource into electricity. SPV can use both direct and diffuse sunlight to generate power, while CSP relies on direct sunlight, restricting its deployment to areas with high Direct Normal Irradiance (DNI). Mandatory demand supported with higher subsidies for green technologies will positively attracts dairies towards use of solar energy. In many villages, power cut hinders the reception of milk from milk producers as electronic weighing system and milk testing instruments require uninterrupted power supply. solar-powered dairy operations offer resilience against power outages and fluctuating energy costs, empowering farmers with greater control over their operations. As the Indian dairy industry embraces solar power, it not only secures a greener future but also fosters economic growth and energy access in rural communities, marking a significant stride towards sustainability and self-sufficiency.

Impact of molten salts composition on the corrosion behavior of NiMoCr and CoNiCrAl coatings on L-PBF 316L stainless steel for CSP plants

The high-temperature corrosion performance of NiMoCr and CoNiCrAl coatings produced by high velocity oxy-fuel (HVOF) on laser powder bed fusion (L-PBF) 316L stainless steel substate has been evaluated in presence of three different molten salts used as thermal energy storage (TES) materials for concentrated solar power (CSP) plants. The coatings have an excellent oxidation resistance at 700 °C, showing a percentage of affected thickness lower than 2 %, due to the formation of a protective layer of Cr2O3 and Al2O3 in both NiMoCr and CoNiCrAl coatings, respectively. The carbonates-based molten salt accelerates the corrosion of the NiMoCr coating, affecting around 43 % of the coating thickness, due to the formation of chromates and the high depletion of Mo in the coating. In contrast, the effective protection shown by the CoNiCrAl coating is explained because the grown LiAlO2 after the lithiation process has a high capacity to act as a strong diffusion barrier for metal ions and inhibited the formation of chromates. In the presence of two different ZnCl2 and MgCl2-rich molten salts, the CoNiCrAl coating behaved worse than NiMoCr coating due to the breakage of the (Al,Cr)-rich oxide layer as a consequence of an active oxidation mechanism and due to the formation of voids along the entire thickness, which were identified in 100 % of the coating thickness. The superior corrosion resistance of the NiMoCr coating in presence of the chloride rich molten salts was attributed to the presence of Mo, which fixed the Cr and inhibited the diffusion of oxygen.

Erosion behaviour of low-pressure cold-sprayed Ni coatings for concentrating solar power receivers

Nickel-based coatings provide outstanding wear and erosion resistance making them particularly suitable for several applications, from aerospace and naval to automotive, energy, and electrical. Cold spray (CS) is encountering a growing interest as a promising technology to deposit thick and dense coatings for components used in energy power generation systems, such as the concentrating solar power (CSP) plants. In this article, nickel coating was deposited onto steel substrates by using a low-pressure CS. The erosion behaviour of the coating was evaluated by a solid particle impact test at two different impact angles. The coating erosion rate was 10 × 10−4 at a 60° impact angle, showing a combination of ploughing and cutting mechanisms.

Heat storage and release characteristics of a prototype CaCO3/CaO thermochemical energy storage system based on a novel fluidized bed solar reactor

CaCO3/CaO thermochemical energy storage (TCES) system has a high heat storage density (1780 kJ/kg) along with high heat storage and release temperature (650–850 °C), which can be applied to concentrated solar power (CSP) technology utilizing CO2 Brayton cycles to improve power generation efficiency. There are several problems to be urgently resolved in current CaCO3/CaO solar calciners, such as poor heat and mass transfer and low thermochemical efficiency. This paper proposed a prototype CaCO3/CaO TCES system based on a novel fluidized bed solar reactor, which has a serrated arc surface in alignment with the direction of the incident solar rays to receive concentrated solar energy. The natural limestone particles were used as the reactive particles. The effects of operating modes (intermittent/continuous), initial mass of reactive particles, and initial carbonation temperature Tcar,initial on the heat storage and release characteristics of the TCES system were experimentally explored. During the carbonation reaction stage, the effective carbonation degrees in the continuous mode were generally higher than in the intermittent mode under the experimental conditions and declined at a slower rate. The reactive particles were recovered from the reactor for microstructural characterization after completing the experiments, high-temperature particle agglomeration and pore structure clogging were directly responsible for the decrease of the effective carbonation degree. In the continuous mode, the average thermochemical and total thermal efficiencies of 24.7 % and 53.5 % were obtained in the 1st calcination reaction, respectively, which represents significant advantages over other CaCO3/CaO solar calciners. The novel fluidized bed reactor demonstrated excellent fluidization in the experiments and did not exhibit mechanical deformation after multiple experiments under non-uniform concentrated radiation provided by an 84 kWe high-flux solar simulator. Overall, this paper provides a successful gas-solid reactor design to be coupled with CSP technology.

A high-temperature solar selective absorber based on one-dimensional multilayer nanostructures

Selective absorbers play a crucial role in harvesting solar energy and realizing effective solar-thermal energy conversion in concentrated solar power systems and thermophotovoltaic systems. This study focuses on obtaining a high-temperature solar selective absorber which can well balance its thermal performance as well as structural complexity. Based on this, a selective absorber with simple one-dimensional multilayer nanostructures is designed to adapt to the high-temperature operation environments. The obtained absorber exhibits a total solar absorptance of 0.9504 to the AM1.5 solar radiation. Taking into account the infrared radiation loss, the solar-thermal efficiency of the absorber is found to be 91.2% under 1000 suns at 1273 K, and the total emittance is 0.1504 at the corresponding temperature. The absorber shows high insensitivity to both incident polarization angles and wide-angle incidence. Analysis of impedance and electromagnetic field distribution indicates that the selective absorption performance of the absorber is attributed to its impedance matching properties, resulting from the coupling effect of surface plasmon polaritons and magnetic polaritons.

Dynamic Corrosion of Carbonate Salt for 3rd Generation CSP Plants

Eutectic ternary carbonate salt is one of the candidates for 3rd generation concentrated solar power (CSP) plants. Gen3 CSP targets higher operation temperatures, which strengthens the corrosivity issues associated to molten salts. Although there are corrosion studies for this carbonate salt in static conditions, the effect of salt flow is not fully understood. In this work, corrosion experiments under static and dynamic conditions are compared for SS310 subjected to ternary carbonate salt at 600ºC.
 The corrosion layer formed during static and dynamic tests were completely characterized by means of SEM-EDX and XRD (surface and cross-section). The corrosion products deposited in the salt during the experiment were analyzed by ICP-OES.
 The tests performed under dynamic conditions demonstrated an increase spallation of the corrosion layer. This spallation produced a thinner scale and exposed the Cr containing phase to the molten salt, fostering its dissolution. These results confirmed the significant effect of dynamic conditions on the corrosivity of eutectic ternary carbonate salt and the importance of assessing them in the design of 3rd generation CSP plants.

Modelling of Solar Thermal Electricity Plants in the POSYTYF Research Project for an Extensive Integration of Renewable Energy Sources

This article presents a simplified simulation model of a concentrated solar thermal power plant developed in the framework of the European research project POSYTYF (POwering SYstem flexibiliTY in the Future through RES). Increasing the share of Renewable Energy Sources (RES) in modern power grids is of critical importance for the transformation of the energy markets worldwide. However, the stability of the grid and the limited participation in ancillary services of RES limit their use, especially when high penetration is expected from them. A solution to overcome these issues is to increase the share of so-called dispatchable RES (hydropower, biomass, concentrating solar thermal power). The main objective of the POSYTYF project is to group several renewable and non-renewable energy sources into a Dynamic Virtual Power Plant (DVPP). The simplified simulation model of a parabolic-trough solar thermal power plant developed consists of sub-models for the solar field, thermal energy storage system and power block and it has been validated with real DNI profiles and production data of a commercial STE plant in Spain. The differences between the simulation and real data of daily net production for the days analysed are lower than 1%. Parts of this paper were published as journal article “Using time-windowed solar radiation profiles to assess the daily uncertainty of solar thermal electricity production forecasts”, Journal of Cleaner Production, Volume 379, Part 2, 2022. Mario Biencinto, Lourdes González, Loreto Valenzuela (https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2022.134821).

Solar radiation modification challenges decarbonization with renewable solar energy

Abstract. Solar radiation modification (SRM) is increasingly being discussed as a potential tool to reduce global and regional temperatures to buy time for conventional carbon mitigation measures to take effect. However, most simulations to date assume SRM to be an additive component to the climate change toolbox, without any physical coupling between mitigation and SRM. In this study we analyze one aspect of this coupling: how renewable energy (RE) capacity, and therefore decarbonization rates, may be affected under SRM deployment by modification of photovoltaic (PV) and concentrated solar power (CSP) production potential. Simulated 1 h output from the Earth system model CNRM-ESM2-1 for scenario-based experiments is used for the assessment. The SRM scenario uses stratospheric aerosol injections (SAIs) to approximately lower global mean temperature from the high-emission scenario SSP585 baseline to the moderate-emission scenario SSP245. We find that by the end of the century, most regions experience an increased number of low PV and CSP energy weeks per year under SAI compared to SSP245. Compared to SSP585, while the increase in low energy weeks under SAI is still dominant on a global scale, certain areas may benefit from SAI and see fewer low PV or CSP energy weeks. A substantial part of the decrease in potential with SAI compared to the SSP scenarios is compensated for by optically thinner upper-tropospheric clouds under SAI, which allow more radiation to penetrate towards the surface. The largest relative reductions in PV potential are seen in the Northern and Southern Hemisphere midlatitudes. Our study suggests that using SAI to reduce high-end global warming to moderate global warming could pose increased challenges for meeting energy demand with solar renewable resources.

Assessing worldwide future potentials of renewable electricity generation: Installable capacity, full load hours and costs

Several studies calculate the potential of renewable energies throughout the world. However, these studies vary in the underlying assumptions and do not consider several technologies within a uniform methodology, which affects comparability. In this paper, we calculate the worldwide potentials of ground-mounted photovoltaic (PV), concentrated solar power (CSP), and wind onshore and offshore on a 6.5 by 6.5 km grid. The results consist of installable capacity, generated electricity, and specific cost of electricity generation. Our methodology combines high-resolution data for land uses, slope, and hourly weather data with a thorough analysis of different factors for wind power, like hub heights and rotor diameters, and solar power plants, like tilt angle, and temperature-related loss of efficiency. The results show that the summed-up potential capacity of ground-mounted PV surpasses the amount of CSP, wind onshore and offshore combined with 450 TW. Given the cost-potential curve, ground-mounted PV reaches 560,000 TWh at costs below 20 €/MWh, which is twice the projected worldwide primary energy supply of the World Energy Outlook 2022 for the year 2050 with 205,557 TWh. The calculated results can function as input factors for energy system models, which are an important tool to analyse the energy transition.

A Metastructure Based on Amorphous Carbon for High Efficiency and Selective Solar Absorption.

Efficient solar thermal conversion is crucial for renewable clean energy technologies such as solar thermal power generation, solar thermophotovoltaic and seawater desalination. To maximize solar energy conversion efficiency, a solar selective absorber with tailored absorption properties designed for solar applications is indispensable. In this study, we propose a broadband selective absorber based on amorphous carbon (a-C) metamaterials that achieves high absorption in the ultraviolet (UV), visible (Vis) and near-infrared (NIR) spectral ranges. Additionally, through metal doping, the optical properties of carbon matrix materials can be modulated. We introduce Ti@a-C thin film into the nanostructure to enhance light absorption across most of the solar spectrum, particularly in the NIR wavelength band, which is essential for improving energy utilization. The impressive solar absorptivity and photothermal conversion efficiency reach 97.8% and 95.6%, respectively. Notably, these superior performances are well-maintained even at large incident angles with different polarized states. These findings open new avenues for the application of a-C matrix materials, especially in fields related to solar energy harvesting.

Model-Based Predictive Control of a Solar Reactor

The present paper deals with the modelling and control of a solar reactor designed to produce syngas, by exploiting concentrated solar power. A model of the reactor based on the thermodynamic equilibrium is developed. Two model-based predictive control strategies are proposed: the first strategy (MPC strategy 1) aims to maintain the reactor's temperature at its nominal value whereas the second strategy (MPC strategy 2) aims to maintain the reactor's temperature at its nominal value, while maximizing the use of solar energy. Finally, these strategies are compared to a reference strategy, which is based on a combination of a rule-based controller and an adaptive PID controller with optimized gains. The robustness of the MPC controller to forecast errors is also studied by testing different DNI forecasting models. Parts of this paper were published as journal articleKarout, Y.; Curcio, A.; Eynard, J.; Thil, S.; Rodat, S.; Abanades, S.; Vuillerme, V.; Grieu, S. Model-Based Predictive Control of a Solar Hybrid Thermochemical Reactor for High-Temperature Steam Gasification of Biomass. Clean Technol. 2023, 5, 329-351. https://doi.org/10.3390/cleantechnol5010018

Design of heliostat field based on ray tracing

In the tower solar thermal power generation system, the optical efficiency of mirror field is the primary factor that determines the power generation efficiency of the whole system. Given the size and installation height of heliostat, in order to meet the requirements of rated Power 60MW, the parameters of heliostat field are designed and the model of tower solar thermal power generation system is established. Considering the cosine loss, shadow occlusion loss and truncation efficiency, and knowing that these three points are closely related to the position of the Sun, a method of ray tracing is proposed to calculate the sunshine accurately, the optimum parameters of helioscope field were determined by simulation. The simulation results show that the average thermal power output per unit mirror area can be increased by reducing the shadow occlusion between the heliostats.