Computer-aided Synthesis Planning Research Articles

Computer-Aided Synthesis Planning (CASP) and Machine Learning: Optimizing Chemical Reaction Conditions.

Computer-aided synthesis planning (CASP) has garnered increasing attention in light of recent advancements in machine learning models. While the focus is on reverse synthesis or forward outcome prediction, optimizing reaction conditions remains a significant challenge. For datasets with multiple variables, the choice of descriptors and models is pivotal. This selection dictates the effective extraction of conditional features and the achievement of higher prediction accuracy. This review delineates the origins of data in conditional optimization, the criteria for descriptor selection, the response models, and the metrics for outcome evaluation, aiming to acquaint readers with the latest research trends and facilitate more informed research in this domain.

Molecular complexity as a driving force for the advancement of organic synthesis.

The generation of molecular complexity is a primary goal in the field of synthetic chemistry. In the context of retrosynthetic analysis, the concept of molecular complexity is central to identifying productive disconnections and the development of efficient total syntheses. However, this field-defining concept is frequently invoked on an intuitive basis without precise definition or appreciation of its subtleties. Methods for quantifying molecular complexity could prove useful for characterizing the state of synthesis in a more rigorous, reliable and reproducible fashion. As a first step to evaluating the importance of these methods to the state of the field, here we present our perspective on the development of molecular complexity quantification and its implications for chemical synthesis. The extension and application of these methods beyond computer-aided synthesis planning and medicinal chemistry to the traditional practice of 'complex molecule' synthesis could have the potential to unearth new opportunities and more efficient approaches for synthesis.

Reaction rebalancing: a novel approach to curating reaction databases

PurposeReaction databases are a key resource for a wide variety of applications in computational chemistry and biochemistry, including Computer-aided Synthesis Planning (CASP) and the large-scale analysis of metabolic networks. The full potential of these resources can only be realized if datasets are accurate and complete. Missing co-reactants and co-products, i.e., unbalanced reactions, however, are the rule rather than the exception. The curation and correction of such incomplete entries is thus an urgent need.MethodsThe SynRBL framework addresses this issue with a dual-strategy: a rule-based method for non-carbon compounds, using atomic symbols and counts for prediction, alongside a Maximum Common Subgraph (MCS)-based technique for carbon compounds, aimed at aligning reactants and products to infer missing entities.ResultsThe rule-based method exceeded 99% accuracy, while MCS-based accuracy varied from 81.19 to 99.33%, depending on reaction properties. Furthermore, an applicability domain and a machine learning scoring function were devised to quantify prediction confidence. The overall efficacy of this framework was delineated through its success rate and accuracy metrics, which spanned from 89.83 to 99.75% and 90.85 to 99.05%, respectively.ConclusionThe SynRBL framework offers a novel solution for recalibrating chemical reactions, significantly enhancing reaction completeness. With rigorous validation, it achieved groundbreaking accuracy in reaction rebalancing. This sets the stage for future improvement in particular of atom-atom mapping techniques as well as of downstream tasks such as automated synthesis planning.Scientific ContributionSynRBL features a novel computational approach to correcting unbalanced entries in chemical reaction databases. By combining heuristic rules for inferring non-carbon compounds and common subgraph searches to address carbon unbalance, SynRBL successfully addresses most instances of this problem, which affects the majority of data in most large-scale resources. Compared to alternative solutions, SynRBL achieves a dramatic increase in both success rate and accurary, and provides the first freely available open source solution for this problem.

Finding Relevant Retrosynthetic Disconnections for Stereocontrolled Reactions.

Machine learning-driven computer-aided synthesis planning (CASP) tools have become important tools for idea generation in the design of complex molecule synthesis but do not adequately address the stereochemical features of the target compounds. A novel approach to automated extraction of templates used in CASP that includes stereochemical information included in the US Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) and an internal AstraZeneca database containing reactions from Reaxys, Pistachio, and AstraZeneca electronic lab notebooks is implemented in the freely available AiZynthFinder software. Three hundred sixty-seven templates covering reagent- and substrate-controlled as well as stereospecific reactions were extracted from the USPTO, while 20,724 templates were from the AstraZeneca database. The performance of these templates in multistep CASP is evaluated for 936 targets from the ChEMBL database and an in-house selection of 791 AZ designs. The potential and limitations are discussed for four case studies from ChEMBL and examples of FDA-approved drugs.

Challenging Complexity with Simplicity: Rethinking the Role of Single-Step Models in Computer-Aided Synthesis Planning.

Computer-assisted synthesis planning has become increasingly important in drug discovery. While deep-learning models have shown remarkable progress in achieving high accuracies for single-step retrosynthetic predictions, their performances in retrosynthetic route planning need to be checked. This study compares the intricate single-step models with a straightforward template enumeration approach for retrosynthetic route planning on a real-world drug molecule data set. Despite the superior single-step accuracy of advanced models, the template enumeration method with a heuristic-based retrosynthesis knowledge score was found to surpass them in efficiency in searching the reaction space, achieving a higher or comparable solve rate within the same time frame. This counterintuitive result underscores the importance of efficiency and retrosynthesis knowledge in retrosynthesis route planning and suggests that future research should incorporate a simple template enumeration as a benchmark. It also suggests that this simple yet effective strategy should be considered alongside more complex models to better cater to the practical needs of computer-assisted synthesis planning in drug discovery.

Retrosynthesis Zero: Self-Improving Global Synthesis Planning Using Reinforcement Learning.

The field of computer-aided synthesis planning (CASP) has witnessed significant growth in recent years. Still, many CASP programs rely on large data sets to train neural networks, resulting in limitations due to the data quality and prior knowledge from chemists. In response, we propose Retrosynthesis Zero (ReSynZ), a reaction template-based method that combines Monte Carlo Tree Search with reinforcement learning inspired by AlphaGo Zero. Unlike other single-step reaction template-based CASP methods, ReSynZ takes complete synthesis paths for complex molecules, determined by reaction rules, as input for training the neural network. ReSynZ enables neural networks trained with relatively small reaction data sets (tens of thousands of data) to generate multiple synthesis pathways for a target molecule and suggest possible reaction conditions. On multiple data sets of molecular retrosynthesis, ReSynZ demonstrates excellent predictive performance compared to existing algorithms. The advantages, such as self-improving model features, flexible reward settings, the potential to surpass human limitations in chemical synthesis route planning, and others, make ReSynZ a valuable tool in chemical synthesis design.

Completing and Balancing Database Excerpted Chemical Reactions with a Hybrid Mechanistic-Machine Learning Approach.

Computer-aided synthesis planning (CASP) development of reaction routes requires an understanding of complete reaction structures. However, most reactions in the current databases are missing reaction coparticipants. Although reaction prediction and atom mapping tools can predict major reaction participants and trace atom rearrangements in reactions, they fail to identify the missing molecules to complete reactions. This is because these approaches are data-driven models trained on the current reaction databases, which comprise incomplete reactions. In this work, a workflow was developed to tackle the reaction completion challenge. This includes a heuristic-based method to identify balanced reactions from reaction databases and complete some imbalanced reactions by adding candidate molecules. A machine learning masked language model (MLM) was trained to learn from simplified molecular input line entry system (SMILES) sentences of these completed reactions. The model predicted missing molecules for the incomplete reactions, a workflow analogous to predicting missing words in sentences. The model is promising for the prediction of small- and middle-sized missing molecules in incomplete reaction records. The workflow combining both the heuristic and machine learning methods completed more than half of the entire reaction space.

Rxn-INSIGHT: fast chemical reaction analysis using bond-electron matrices

The challenge of devising pathways for organic synthesis remains a central issue in the field of medicinal chemistry. Over the span of six decades, computer-aided synthesis planning has given rise to a plethora of potent tools for formulating synthetic routes. Nevertheless, a significant expert task still looms: determining the appropriate solvent, catalyst, and reagents when provided with a set of reactants to achieve and optimize the desired product for a specific step in the synthesis process. Typically, chemists identify key functional groups and rings that exert crucial influences at the reaction center, classify reactions into categories, and may assign them names. This research introduces Rxn-INSIGHT, an open-source algorithm based on the bond-electron matrix approach, with the purpose of automating this endeavor. Rxn-INSIGHT not only streamlines the process but also facilitates extensive querying of reaction databases, effectively replicating the thought processes of an organic chemist. The core functions of the algorithm encompass the classification and naming of reactions, extraction of functional groups, rings, and scaffolds from the involved chemical entities. The provision of reaction condition recommendations based on the similarity and prevalence of reactions eventually arises as a side application. The performance of our rule-based model has been rigorously assessed against a carefully curated benchmark dataset, exhibiting an accuracy rate exceeding 90% in reaction classification and surpassing 95% in reaction naming. Notably, it has been discerned that a pivotal factor in selecting analogous reactions lies in the analysis of ring structures participating in the reactions. An examination of ring structures within the USPTO chemical reaction database reveals that with just 35 unique rings, a remarkable 75% of all rings found in nearly 1 million products can be encompassed. Furthermore, Rxn-INSIGHT is proficient in suggesting appropriate choices for solvents, catalysts, and reagents in entirely novel reactions, all within the span of a second, utilizing nothing more than an everyday laptop.

Chemoenzymatic multistep retrosynthesis with transformer loops.

Integrating enzymatic reactions into computer-aided synthesis planning (CASP) should help devise more selective, economical, and greener synthetic routes. Herein we report the triple-transformer loop algorithm with biocatalysis (TTLAB) as a new CASP tool for chemo-enzymatic multistep retrosynthesis. Single-step retrosyntheses are performed using two triple transformer loops (TTL), one trained with chemical reactions from the US Patent Office (USPTO-TTL), the second one obtained by multitask transfer learning combining the USPTO dataset with preparative biotransformations from the literature (ENZR-TTL). Each TTL performs single-step retrosynthesis independently by tagging potential reactive sites in the product, predicting for each site possible starting materials (T1) and reagents or enzymes (T2), and validating the predictions via a forward transformer (T3). TTLAB combines predictions from both TTLs to explore multistep sequences using a heuristic best-first tree search and propose short routes from commercial building blocks including enantioselective biocatalytic steps. TTLAB can be used to assist chemoenzymatic route design.

Data Sharing in Chemistry: Lessons Learned and a Case for Mandating Structured Reaction Data.

The past decade has seen a number of impressive developments in predictive chemistry and reaction informatics driven by machine learning applications to computer-aided synthesis planning. While many of these developments have been made even with relatively small, bespoke data sets, in order to advance the role of AI in the field at scale, there must be significant improvements in the reporting of reaction data. Currently, the majority of publicly available data is reported in an unstructured format and heavily imbalanced toward high-yielding reactions, which influences the types of models that can be successfully trained. In this Perspective, we analyze several data curation and sharing initiatives that have seen success in chemistry and molecular biology. We discuss several factors that have contributed to their success and how we can take lessons from these case studies and apply them to reaction data. Finally, we spotlight the Open Reaction Database and summarize key actions the community can take toward making reaction data more findable, accessible, interoperable, and reusable (FAIR), including the use of mandates from funding agencies and publishers.

Retrosynthesis prediction using an end-to-end graph generative architecture for molecular graph editing

Retrosynthesis planning, the process of identifying a set of available reactions to synthesize the target molecules, remains a major challenge in organic synthesis. Recently, computer-aided synthesis planning has gained renewed interest and various retrosynthesis prediction algorithms based on deep learning have been proposed. However, most existing methods are limited to the applicability and interpretability of model predictions, and further improvement of predictive accuracy to a more practical level is still required. In this work, inspired by the arrow-pushing formalism in chemical reaction mechanisms, we present an end-to-end architecture for retrosynthesis prediction called Graph2Edits. Specifically, Graph2Edits is based on graph neural network to predict the edits of the product graph in an auto-regressive manner, and sequentially generates transformation intermediates and final reactants according to the predicted edits sequence. This strategy combines the two-stage processes of semi-template-based methods into one-pot learning, improving the applicability in some complicated reactions, and also making its predictions more interpretable. Evaluated on the standard benchmark dataset USPTO-50k, our model achieves the state-of-the-art performance for semi-template-based retrosynthesis with a promising 55.1% top-1 accuracy.

Multistep retrosynthesis combining a disconnection aware triple transformer loop with a route penalty score guided tree search.

Computer-aided synthesis planning (CASP) aims to automatically learn organic reactivity from literature and perform retrosynthesis of unseen molecules. CASP systems must learn reactions sufficiently precisely to propose realistic disconnections, while avoiding overfitting to leave room for diverse options, and explore possible routes such as to allow short synthetic sequences to emerge. Herein we report an open-source CASP tool proposing original solutions to both challenges. First, we use a triple transformer loop (TTL) predicting starting materials (T1), reagents (T2), and products (T3) to explore various disconnection sites defined by combining systematic, template-based, and transformer-based tagging procedures. Second, we integrate TTL into a multistep tree search algorithm (TTLA) prioritizing sequences using a route penalty score (RPScore) considering the number of steps, their confidence score, and the simplicity of all intermediates along the route. Our approach favours short synthetic routes to commercial starting materials, as exemplified by retrosynthetic analyses of recently approved drugs.

Application of artificial intelligence and big data technology in synthesis planning

<p indent="0mm">With the development of cheminformatics and artifitial intelligence (AI) technologies, several computer aided synthesis planning (CASP) techniques have emerged. In early years, CASP were mainly expert systems that relied on human-defined rules. Recently, data-driven AI models have been employed in retrosynthese analysis, and a few CASP tools have already been applied in the routine work of sythesis experiments. This review has three components, the cheminfomatics technologies that can represent and store chemical information, single-step retrosynthesis models and the related algorithms, and multi-step strategies for synthesis planning. Finally, the more mature retrosynthesis design platform and model evaluation method are introduced. With this, we can systematically understand retrosynthesis models and the challenges to be solved.

Using Active Learning to Develop Machine Learning Models for Reaction Yield Prediction.

Computer aided synthesis planning, suggesting synthetic routes for molecules of interest, is a rapidly growing field. The machine learning methods used are often dependent on access to large datasets for training, but finite experimental budgets limit how much data can be obtained from experiments. This suggests the use of schemes for data collection such as active learning, which identifies the data points of highest impact for model accuracy, and which has been used in recent studies with success. However, little has been done to explore the robustness of the methods predicting reaction yield when used together with active learning to reduce the amount of experimental data needed for training. This study aims to investigate the influence of machine learning algorithms and the number of initial data points on reaction yield prediction for two public high-throughput experimentation datasets. Our results show that active learning based on output margin reached a pre-defined AUROC faster than random sampling on both datasets. Analysis of feature importance of the trained machine learning models suggests active learning had a larger influence on the model accuracy when only a few features were important for the model prediction.

Bayesian Optimization of Computer-Proposed Multistep Synthetic Routes on an Automated Robotic Flow Platform.

Computer-aided synthesis planning (CASP) tools can propose retrosynthetic pathways and forward reaction conditions for the synthesis of organic compounds, but the limited availability of context-specific data currently necessitates experimental development to fully specify process details. We plan and optimize a CASP-proposed and human-refined multistep synthesis route toward an exemplary small molecule, sonidegib, on a modular, robotic flow synthesis platform with integrated process analytical technology (PAT) for data-rich experimentation. Human insights address catalyst deactivation and improve yield by strategic choices of order of addition. Multi-objective Bayesian optimization identifies optimal values for categorical and continuous process variables in the multistep route involving 3 reactions (including heterogeneous hydrogenation) and 1 separation. The platform’s modularity, robotic reconfigurability, and flexibility for convergent synthesis are shown to be essential for allowing variation of downstream residence time in multistep flow processes and controlling the order of addition to minimize undesired reactivity. Overall, the work demonstrates how automation, machine learning, and robotics enhance manual experimentation through assistance with idea generation, experimental design, execution, and optimization.

Automatic Extraction of Reaction Templates for Synthesis Prediction

Several tools for the computational planning of synthetic routes have been developed over the last 60 years. Traditionally these have been built on manually or automatically extracted reaction rules or templates obtained from a deep knowledge of organic chemistry in the case of the former, and reaction databases for the latter. Herein we give an introductory overview to the process of automatically extracting reaction templates, starting from methods for reaction centre identification, through to their use in computer aided synthesis planning and the de novo design of compounds.

AI-Driven Synthetic Route Design Incorporated with Retrosynthesis Knowledge.

Computer-aided synthesis planning (CASP) aims to assist chemists in performing retrosynthetic analysis for which they utilize their experiments, intuition, and knowledge. Recent breakthroughs in machine learning (ML) techniques, including deep neural networks, have significantly improved data-driven synthetic route designs without human intervention. However, learning chemical knowledge by ML for practical synthesis planning has not yet been adequately achieved and remains a challenging problem. In this study, we developed a data-driven CASP application integrated with various portions of retrosynthesis knowledge called “ReTReK” that introduces the knowledge as adjustable parameters into the evaluation of promising search directions. The experimental results showed that ReTReK successfully searched synthetic routes based on the specified retrosynthesis knowledge, indicating that the synthetic routes searched with the knowledge were preferred to those without the knowledge. The concept of integrating retrosynthesis knowledge as adjustable parameters into a data-driven CASP application is expected to enhance the performance of both existing data-driven CASP applications and those under development.

Applications of Artificial Intelligence in Drug Design: Opportunities and Challenges.

Artificial intelligence (AI) has undergone rapid development in recent years and has been successfully applied to real-world problems such as drug design. In this chapter, we review recent applications of AI to problems in drug design including virtual screening, computer-aided synthesis planning, and de novo molecule generation, with a focus on the limitations of the application of AI therein and opportunities for improvement. Furthermore, we discuss the broader challenges imposed by AI in translating theoretical practice to real-world drug design; including quantifying prediction uncertainty and explaining model behavior.

The Open Reaction Database.

Chemical reaction data in journal articles, patents, and even electronic laboratory notebooks are currently stored in various formats, often unstructured, which presents a significant barrier to downstream applications, including the training of machine-learning models. We present the Open Reaction Database (ORD), an open-access schema and infrastructure for structuring and sharing organic reaction data, including a centralized data repository. The ORD schema supports conventional and emerging technologies, from benchtop reactions to automated high-throughput experiments and flow chemistry. The data, schema, supporting code, and web-based user interfaces are all publicly available on GitHub. Our vision is that a consistent data representation and infrastructure to support data sharing will enable downstream applications that will greatly improve the state of the art with respect to computer-aided synthesis planning, reaction prediction, and other predictive chemistry tasks.

Back Cover

Development of computer‐aided synthesis planning (CASP) systems in the past fifty years is introduced in this review, along with their system architecture, working principle and performance of retrosynthetic analysis. Prompted by modern algorithm, CASP system is optimistically anticipated to design green, efficient and economic synthetic routes toward target molecules in the future for chemists. More details are discussed in the article by Liu et al. on page 3127–3143.image