Comprehensive Bibliometric Analysis Research Articles

Spiritual tourism development: a comprehensive synthesis for sustainable destination planning and growth

Purpose This paper aims to explore the dimensions of spiritual tourism development, examine its current status, effectiveness and scope and analyze the knowledge landscape in terms of theories, contexts and research methodologies. The study also seeks to guide future research on spiritual tourism development. Design/methodology/approach A systematic literature review (SLR) and bibliometric analysis were used using a framework-based approach. The theories, constructs, characteristics and methods (TCCM) framework guided the SLR, whereas VOS-Viewer facilitated comprehensive bibliometric analysis. Findings The study conducted a quantitative SLR, analyzing 80 research articles published between 2003 and 2023. Using the TCCM framework, the research identified crucial factors influencing the growth of spiritual tourist destinations, such as intrinsic motivation, destination physicality, tourist experience, spiritual activities and host community support. Research limitations/implications This study contributes to theoretical advancement in spiritual tourism, provides insights into the current research landscape, offers practical guidance for stakeholders and serves as a roadmap for future research endeavors. Originality/value This research enhances knowledge by thoroughly assessing prior research, addressing gaps and offering practical managerial insights for spiritual tourism development. The managerial implications outlined in the study offer practical insights for destination planning and promotion in the context of spiritual tourism.

Green supply chain management: a bibliometric analysis of global research trends and future directions

ABSTRACT This study presents a comprehensive bibliometric analysis of GreenSupply Chain Management (GSCM), examining its evolution andprospective directions across strategic, operational, and economicdimensions. Drawing upon organizational theory, stakeholder theory,operations management, environmental management, accounting, andeconomics, the study applies bibliometric techniques, including wordanalysis and network analysis, to discern significant researchtrends. It emphasizes the necessity of aligning strategic objectiveswith environmental sustainability and implementing operationalmeasures to achieve environmental goals while also analyzing theeconomic implications of sustainable practices. Furthermore, thestudy highlights the long-term financial advantages of thesepractices and the potential contributions of emerging technologies,such as blockchain, the Internet of Things, and ArtificialIntelligence, to the enhancement of GSCM.

A Decade in Blockchain: A Bibliometric Reflection on the Growth and Interdisciplinary Reach of a Disruptive Technology

This study seeks to deliver a comprehensive bibliometric analysis of blockchain research undertaken from 2013 to 2023. It seeks to map the field’s evolution, highlight emerging trends, and identify key contributors and thematic areas. Understanding these aspects is crucial for guiding future research and policymaking in the rapidly growing domain of blockchain technology. The study utilises a systematic bibliometric analysis approach and the Scopus database was used for collecting data. The analysis includes keyword trends, citation patterns, author productivity, and network analysis. The results reveal significant expansion and diversification in blockchain research, with 13,369 publications and 52,009 contributing authors. Key metrics include a total citation count of 266,483 and an average of 19.93 citations per paper, underscoring the field’s scholarly impact. The study identifies core research themes such as smart contracts, security, IoT integration, and emerging topics like AI and sustainability. The findings highlight the interdisciplinary nature of blockchain research and its global distribution, with notable contributions from China and the United States. The study’s reliance on selected databases and predefined keywords may exclude relevant grey literature and industry reports. Future research should integrate these sources for a more complete view. This study provides a panoramic view of blockchain research, offering valuable insights into its development, current state, and future directions. Identifying key trends, influential contributors, and emerging themes contributes to the academic discourse and supports strategic planning for researchers, practitioners, and policymakers engaged in blockchain technology.

Scientific production on robotic metabolic and bariatric surgery: a comprehensive bibliometric analysis on its current world status.

Robotic metabolic and bariatric surgery (RMBS) has emerged as an innovative approach in the treatment of severe obesity by combining the ergonomic precision of robotic technology and instrumentation with the established benefits of weight loss surgery. This study employs a bibliometric approach to identify local research trends and worldwide patterns in RMBS. The research methodology used "robotic" and "metabolic" or "bariatric surgery" to search Web of Science. Articles that were published prior to December 31st, 2023, were included. The analyses were developed using the Rayyan and Bibliometric, in R Studio. 265 articles from 51 different journals were included. Scientific production of RMBS experienced a significant annual growth rate of 21.96% from 2003 to 2023, resulting in an average of 12.6 papers published per year. A high correlation (R2 = 0.94) was found between the year and number of articles. The mean number of citations per document was 13.25. Approximately 90% of the journals were classified as zone 3, according to the Bradford categorization. International collaboration was identified in 10.57% of cases, with the University of California and the University of Illinois being the most common organizations. The countries with the highest number of corresponding authors, in descending order, were the United States of America, China, and Switzerland. Scientific production in RMBS has experienced sustained growth since the first original publications in 2003. While it has not yet reached the volume, impact, and international collaboration seen in studies related to non-robotic metabolic and bariatric surgery, RBMS holds potential that remains to be explored.

A bibliometric and visualization analysis of global trends and frontiers on macrophages in abdominal aortic aneurysms research.

Macrophages are key regulators of the inflammatory and innate immune responses. Researchers have shown that aberrant expression of macrophages contributes to the development of abdominal aortic aneurysms (AAA). However, a comprehensive bibliometric analysis exploring the research status and knowledge mapping of this area is lacking. This study aimed to explore the research status, knowledge mapping and hotspots of macrophages in AAA research from a bibliometric perspective. In this study, we retrieved articles published between 2000 and 2022 on macrophages associated with AAA research from the Web of Science Core Collection (WoSCC) database. The retrieved literature data were further analyzed using Citespace and VOSviewer software. A total of 918 qualified publications related to AAA-associated macrophages were retrieved. The number of publications in this field has been increasing annually. China and the United States were the 2 main drivers in this field, contributing to more than 64% of the publications. In addition, the US had the most publications, top institutions, and expert researchers, dominating in research on macrophages in AAA. The Harvard University was the most productive institution, with 60 publications. The journal with the most publications was Arteriosclerosis, Thrombosis, and Vascular Biology (86). Daugherty Alan was the most prolific author (28 publications) and he was also the most cited co- author. Furthermore, the exploration of established animal models, macrophage-related inflammatory-microenvironment, macrophage-related immune mechanism, clinical translation and molecular imaging research remained future research directions in this field. Our findings offered new insights for scholars in this field. They will help researchers explore new directions for their work.

Mapping the evolution and future directions of creative tourism: a comprehensive bibliometric analysis

ABSTRACT The main objective of this study is to deepen the understanding of the knowledge structure in the field of creative tourism and thereby enhance communication with advanced international theories and experiences. We utilized two visualization tools, VOSviewer and CiteSpace, to analyze 138 platform research papers from the Web of Science Core Collection, comprising 7050 references. Combining quantitative analysis (such as scientometric analysis, knowledge mapping, and keyword clustering) with content analysis (including thematic reading), this study primarily focuses on three aspects: firstly, revealing the basic characteristics of the literature, such as publication metrics, authors, and research institutions, to outline the foundational landscape of the field; secondly, identifying key research areas, content, and development trends to provide profound insights into the advancement of creative tourism and suggest directions for future research; thirdly, constructing a comprehensive knowledge framework to consolidate existing information and insights, facilitating a more structured and accessible understanding of creative tourism.

Competitive intelligence in tourism: charting future directions through bibliometric analysis

PurposeThis study explores the crucial role of competitive intelligence (CI) in the tourism sector’s strategic decision-making. CI has significantly transformed the tourism sector through new insights and sophistication in data analysis and strategic planning. The rise in tourism-related competition, due to new destinations, varied tourist preferences and sustainability emphasis, makes competitive intelligence essential for understanding future market trends and making informed strategic choices.Design/methodology/approachUtilising PRISMA techniques for bibliometric analysis, the study examines literature from 1998 to 2023 (WoS), focusing on service innovation, customer experience management and sustainable strategies. It presents an analysis of the evolution of CI in tourism, its impact, influential works and future research directions.FindingsFindings show that the multidisciplinary nature of CI in tourism is further evidenced by studies on quality cues, travellers’ information needs and the utilisation of big data. Future studies need to understand both global trends and regional specifics, as shown in investigations of spatial-temporal tourism dynamics.Originality/valueThis study represents a novel contribution to the field of tourism research by offering a comprehensive bibliometric analysis of CI literature from 1998 to 2023. It uniquely integrates service innovation, customer experience management and sustainable strategies within the context of CI, highlighting its multidisciplinary impacts and evolution. These insights collectively emphasise the need for future innovation and a comprehensive understanding of the global-local nexus to inform future tourism research and practice.

Unexplored topics in intrahepatic cholestasis of pregnancy: A review and bibliometric analysis.

To conduct a comprehensive bibliometric analysis of research published on intrahepatic cholestasis of pregnancy (ICP) and explore the related frontiers and critical issues concerning it, we searched the Web of Science Core Collection for ICP-related publications from the beginning of 2001 until August of 2023. CiteSpace and VOSviewer were utilized to evaluate the contribution and co-occurrence relationships of various countries and regions, institutes and so on to identify new frontiers and currently exciting topics. Our bibliometric analysis scrutinized 933 articles from 59 countries/regions. China has generated the largest number of publications (31.6% of the total), whereas Germany ranked first when it came to citations per publication. The Imperial College London ranked first with respect to publication output on ICP and betweenness centrality. The Journal of Maternal-Fetal & Neonatal Medicine was the journal with the highest plurality of papers. Authors such as Williamson, Beuers, Ulrich, and Shao were the most influential. Pregnancy, ursodeoxycholic acid, and ICP were principally noted in publications. Cluster analysis of the references that correlated with the 933 publications showed that they clustered into mortality, ABCB11, BSEP, MRP2, bile acid, and intrahepatic cholestasis. ICP is associated with adverse clinical outcomes for both the mother and fetus. This study provides a critical analysis of the current status and future research trends regarding ICP. It can serve as a useful reference, allowing researchers to conduct in-depth investigations into this promising field.

Academic Traces of Urban Furniture: A Bibliometric Perspective

Urban furniture, which increases the quality and aesthetics of urban life, has recently been the subject of academic studies. However, a bibliometric and visual analysis in this field has not been conducted in sufficient number. This paper presents a quantitative and descriptive study of 1,063 documents from the Web of Science database (1975-2022) using RStudio's 'Bibliometrix' package. Key bibliometric indicators include 887 documents, 619 references, 582 articles, 12.25 citations per document, 2,558 authors, 1,386 keywords, keywords of 2,968 authors, and a collaboration index of 16.8%. The study found higher scientific productivity in China and the USA. Research status, influential sources, countries, institutions, authors, keywords and data relationships were analysed. In particular, it was observed that academic interest increased after 2000 and focused on technology, environment and urban disciplines rather than architecture. The keywords (Author's Keywords and Keywords plus) vary, with a focus on the urban field of study and the health and environment field of study, but both keywords are increasing. The paper recommends increased interdisciplinary co-operation to broaden the scope of urban furniture research. This is one of the first comprehensive bibliometric and content analyses on urban furniture.

Blockchain Consensus Mechanisms: A Bibliometric Analysis (2014–2024) Using VOSviewer and R Bibliometrix

Blockchain consensus mechanisms play a critical role in ensuring the security, decentralization, and integrity of distributed networks. As blockchain technology expands beyond cryptocurrencies into broader applications such as supply chain management and healthcare, the importance of efficient and scalable consensus algorithms has grown significantly. This study provides a comprehensive bibliometric analysis of blockchain and consensus mechanism research from 2014 to 2024, using tools such as VOSviewer and R’s Bibliometrix package. The analysis traces the evolution from foundational mechanisms like Proof of ork (PoW) to more advanced models such as Proof of Stake (PoS) and Byzantine Fault Tolerance (BFT), with particular emphasis on Ethereum’s “The Merge” in 2022, which marked the historic shift from PoW to PoS. Key findings highlight emerging themes, including scalability, security, and the integration of blockchain with state-of-the-art technologies like artificial intelligence (AI), the Internet of Things (IoT), and energy trading. The study also identifies influential authors, institutions, and countries, emphasizing the collaborative and interdisciplinary nature of blockchain research. Through thematic analysis, this review uncovers the challenges and opportunities in decentralized systems, underscoring the need for continued innovation in consensus mechanisms to address efficiency, sustainability, scalability, and privacy concerns. These insights offer a valuable foundation for future research aimed at advancing blockchain technology across various industries.

The Integration of Land Restoration and Biodiversity Conservation Practices in Sustainable Food Systems of Africa: A Systematic Review

Land degradation poses a significant global challenge, adversely affecting soil quality and diminishing the productivity of arable land, which, in turn, impacts food production and ecosystem services. This degradation manifests in various forms, including soil compaction, salinity, nutrient depletion, loss of biodiversity, and contamination, ultimately rendering soil unproductive and exacerbating climate change. Given the challenges arising from conventional farming practices and climate change, there is an urgent necessity to develop agricultural systems that not only enhance agronomic efficiency but also improve environmental performance. This study focuses on addressing food security in Africa by investigating the role of land restoration and biodiversity in sustainable food systems through a comprehensive bibliometric analysis for documents between 2010 to 2023, identifying 64 relevant documents. The analysis reveals insights into the most-cited documents and thematic evolution, underscoring the significant contributions from Ethiopia and advocating for collaborative efforts among African nations. Key themes identified include “climate change”, “food security”, “biodiversity conservation”, and “agroecosystems”, all highlighting the importance of sustainable agricultural practices. The study anticipates a continued prioritization of agroecosystems, smart agriculture, and biodiversity conservation to tackle food security challenges in the face of climate change. Collaboration, investment in research, and practical initiatives emerge as essential components for achieving sustainable food security and mitigating climate change impacts in Africa. This research provides valuable insights into the current landscape and future trends regarding the contributions of land restoration and biodiversity to food systems in Africa, emphasizing the critical need for concerted efforts to address these pressing issues.

Exploring the Integration of Industry 4.0 Technologies in Agriculture: A Comprehensive Bibliometric Review

While it is essential to increase agricultural production to meet the needs of a growing global population, this task is becoming increasingly difficult due to the environmental challenges faced in recent decades. A promising solution to enhance the efficiency and sustainability of agricultural production is the integration of Industry 4.0 technologies, such as IoT, UAVs, AI, and Blockchain. However, despite their potential, there is a lack of comprehensive bibliometric analyses that cover the full range of these technologies in agriculture. This gap limits understanding of their integration and impact. This study aims to provide a holistic bibliometric analysis of the integration of Industry 4.0 technologies in agriculture, identifying key research trends and gaps. We analyzed relevant literature using the Scopus database and VOSviewer software (version 1.6.20, Centre for Science and Technology Studies, Leiden University, The Netherlands)and identified five major thematic clusters within Agriculture 4.0. These clusters were examined to understand the included technologies and their roles in promoting sustainable agricultural practices. The study also identified unexplored technologies that present opportunities for future research. This paper offers a comprehensive overview of the current research landscape in Agriculture 4.0, highlighting areas for innovation and development, and serves as a valuable resource for enhancing sustainable agricultural practices through technological integration.

A review of the knowledge structure and trends in research on the interlinkages between the rule of law and environmental sustainability

AbstractThe interplay between nature and human activities is important for both human well‐being and the health of our planet. The rule of law is central to maintaining harmony between environmental needs and human endeavors. Since the early 1990s, particularly after the Earth Summit in 1992, there has been an increased interest in the relationship between environmental sustainability and legal frameworks. This has led to a significant expansion in the field, encompassing a wide array of research. Despite the field's growth, there is still a lack of review papers that explore its knowledge structure and evolution. This study aims to conduct a comprehensive bibliometric analysis of the literature by employing the Visualization of Similarities (VOS) viewer software. We identify key thematic areas within the field, highlight influential authors and journals, and specify major contributing countries and institutions. The findings show that the initial focus was on limited themes, which later gave way to an acknowledgment of the multidimensional nature of the subject. Certain themes, such as environmental emissions and governance, retain prominence. Among the focal themes, sustainability, climate change, and democracy are particularly influential in shaping the field's trajectory. Despite this evolution, certain aspects of both concepts, such as waste and water management, fundamental rights and justice system, and the importance of socio‐economic factors, remain underrepresented. This study offers valuable insights into the linkage between the rule of law and environmental sustainability themes and the associated themes.

Bibliometric analysis of stone column research trends: A Web of Science perspective

Abstract Stone columns have garnered significant interest in geotechnical engineering as an effective ground improvement technique for enhancing the load-bearing capacity and mitigating settlement issues in soft soils. This study presents a comprehensive bibliometric analysis of scholarly literature on stone columns, utilizing data from the Web of Science database spanning from 1975 to 2023. The analysis aims to provide insights into publication trends, influential journals, key research institutions and authors, geographical distributions, and emerging themes in this domain. Through a systematic data curation process, 505 relevant publications were analyzed using Excel and VOSviewer software. The findings reveal a notable emphasis on geosynthetic encasements, load-settlement behavior, and soft soil reinforcement, with China being a major contributor. Over the past 48 years, the research has evolved from static loading to dynamic loading, sustainable structures, and artificial intelligence applications, as evidenced by the highly cited publications. This study maps the development, current state, and potential future directions of stone column research, serving as a valuable resource for researchers and practitioners in geotechnical engineering.

Exploring the frontiers: A comprehensive bibliometric analysis of robotics in science education

The present bibliometric review focuses on the 50 research articles indexed in Scopus Database in robotics science education (RSE) between the years 2012 and 2024. The analysis of publications shows the steady growth rates which is especially notable for 2021 thereby specifying the growing demand in the field. These are researchers from universities named The Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, The Kaunas University of Technology, and the NYU Tandon School of Engineering. The funding bodies that have greatly supported research work include National Science Foundation, CAS-TWAS Scholarships, and EPF Lausanne. The current study emphasizes that the topic of robotics in the learning process involves tendencies of the social sciences, engineering, computer science, psychology and other sciences. The United States leads in publication output, followed by countries like Greece, Turkey, and Lithuania, highlighting a global interest in leveraging robotics for educational innovation geographically. The location of the research studies points to the fact that, there is a need to reach out to various countries as a way of encouraging the use of robotics in the STEM curriculum. The following analysis offers insights into the current trends, risks, and opportunities of robotic innovations in education study and underlined the need for a continuous stakeholders’ discourse on the best use of robots in enhancing science learning. This bibliometric analysis emphasizes the dynamic growth, disciplinary integration, and international collaboration characterizing RSE, underscoring the importance of ongoing dialogue and cooperation to realize its transformative potential in STEM education.

Incidence of periprosthetic joint infection after primary total knee arthroplasty shows significant variation : a synthesis of meta-analysis and bibliometric analysis

Total Knee Arthroplasty (TKA) is a surgery that is commonly performed on older adults to improve their quality of life. However, the increasing use of knee joint prostheses has led to a rise in the incidence of Prosthetic Joint Infections (PJI) in patients after TKA. Different clinical studies have looked at the occurrence of PJI after TKA in different regions, but they have drawn varying conclusions. To better understand this topic, we conducted a meta-analysis and bibliometric study using data from multiple databases. Our research found that the estimated prevalence of PJI after TKA is approximately 1.08% across different regions, but there is still considerable variation. Additionally, our regression analysis of sub-groups shows significant differences in follow-up periods. Furthermore, our comprehensive bibliometric analysis identifies current research trends, “hotspots” related to TKA-related PJI, influential nations, organizations, and noteworthy publications. Our analysis provides valuable insights to guide future research in this area.

Evolution and Trends in Digital Wallet Research: A Bibliometric Analysis in Scopus and Web of Science

Digital wallets have become a driving force in the global economy, with 2.4 billion users worldwide in 2020, a figure projected to reach 3.6 billion by 2026. This study conducts an in-depth bibliometric analysis to evaluate the current state and future trends of digital wallet research using scientific databases such as Scopus and Web of Science. A scoping review methodology was applied, in which we analyzed 778 documents, following an eligibility process with the following search terms: “digital wallet”, “mobile wallet”, and “e-wallet”. Results show that India, the United States, and China are leading research efforts in this field. Key factors influencing the adoption of digital wallets include data security, ease of use, and integration with traditional payment systems. While much research has focused on technological innovation and adoption, significant gaps remain in areas such as blockchain integration and AI-driven solutions. This article provides the first comprehensive bibliometric analysis of digital wallets, offering crucial insights into emerging trends such as “blockchain”, “electronic commerce”, and “digital payments” and their role in shaping the future of financial technology.

Generative AI in Science Education: A Learning Revolution or a Threat to Academic Integrity? A Bibliometric Analysis

The integration of generative artificial intelligence (AI) in Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM) education presents transformative opportunities alongside significant challenges. This study investigates the dual impact of generative AI on STEM learning outcomes and academic integrity through a comprehensive bibliometric analysis employing co-citation, keyword analysis, and trend mapping. The results reveal that AI tools such as ChatGPT have revolutionized personalized learning by offering tailored feedback, enhancing critical thinking, and improving student engagement. However, these advancements are tempered by concerns over academic misconduct, particularly plagiarism, and the erosion of essential cognitive skills due to overreliance on AI-generated content. Ethical considerations remain critical, necessitating the development of robust policies and ethical frameworks to safeguard academic integrity. Beyond educational settings, the findings suggest broader applicability to professional training and skills development, as the benefits and challenges of AI extend beyond coursework. This research provides valuable insights for educators, policymakers, and researchers, advocating for a balanced approach to AI integration that maximizes its potential while preserving educational standards.

Challenges and opportunities in sensor-based fall prevention for older adults: a bibliometric review

PurposeThis bibliometric review examines the recent literature on sensor-based fall prevention for older adults. It analyzes publication trends, key researchers and institutions, major research themes, as well as gaps and opportunities in this field.Design/methodology/approachA comprehensive search was conducted in Scopus and Web of Science (WoS) databases for publications from 1990 to 2024. Bibliometric indicators including publication output, citation analysis and co-occurrence of keywords were used to map the research landscape. Network visualizations were employed to identify key thematic clusters.FindingsThe research on sensor-based fall prevention has grown rapidly, peaking in 2019. The USA, Australia and Canada lead this work, with universities and hospitals collaborating globally. Key themes include fall epidemiology, wearable sensors and AI for fall detection. Opportunities exist to better implement these sensor systems through large trials, user-centered design, hybrid sensors and advanced analytics.Research limitations/implicationsWhile comprehensive, the analysis focused primarily on publications indexed in Scopus and WoS, which may not capture all relevant literature. Future studies could expand the search to include other databases and conduct deeper analyses of highly influential studies.Practical implicationsThe review provides an evidence-informed roadmap to accelerate the translation of sensor innovations into scalable and sustainable fall prevention practices for vulnerable older adult populations.Originality/valueThis is the first comprehensive bibliometric analysis to map the research landscape of sensor-based fall prevention, identifying key trends, themes and opportunities to advance this critical domain addressing a major global public health challenge.

MAPPING THE LANDSCAPE OF CONTINUING EDUCATION RESEARCH IN ASIA: A BIBLIOMETRIC ANALYSIS OF SCOPUS-INDEXED PUBLICATIONS FROM 1972 TO 2023

Continuing education (CE) plays a crucial role in workforce development and economic growth across Asia, yet the landscape of CE research in the region has not been comprehensively mapped. A comprehensive bibliometric analysis of continuing education (CE) research in Asia from 1972 to 2023 was carried out, utilizing data from the Scopus database to map the evolving landscape of CE research in the region. Findings revealed a significant surge in research output since the late 1990s, with East Asian countries, particularly China, Hong Kong (China), and Taiwan (ROC), emerging as leaders in the field. The analysis uncovers several key patterns: institutional collaborations tend to cluster regionally, there's a noticeable generational gap in researcher’s networks, and the healthcare sector dominates CE research topics. Recent trends indicate a shift towards digital learning approaches and learner-centered methodologies. The study also highlights the need for increased cross-border collaborations and expansion of CE research beyond the healthcare sector. This research contributes to a deeper understanding of CE research trends in Asia and provides insights for future directions in the field. Keywords: Asia, bibliometric analysis, collaboration networks, continuing education, digital learning, healthcare education, lifelong learning, research trends, science mapping, Scopus database