A novel, portable, disposable, affordable, and environmentally friendly paper-based analytical device (PAD) was designed for on-site determination of carmine and carminic acid. This platform utilized paper test strips with a chitosan coating as an adsorption layer, which was characterized using scanning electron microscope, energy-dispersive X-ray analysis, and water contact angle measurement. Carmine and carminic acid could be efficiently adsorbed on chitosan-coated paper test strips, producing distinct colors that could be captured using a smartphone camera without the need for an elution step. Notably, by utilizing the Hue component of the HSL model, it was possible to differentiate between carmine and carminic acid, confirming their presence in a sample. Furthermore, the color saturation intensity changed in a concentration-dependent manner, allowing for the determination of carmine and carminic acid concentrations in the ranges of 200–800 μg/mL and 20–100 μg/mL, respectively. Additionally, the created test strip could be used to measure the percentage of carminic acid in the presence of carmine. The developed PAD enabled the quantification of carmine in various food samples without the need for reagents or complex equipment. The environmental impact of this method was found to be positive based on assessments using GAPI and AGREE tools.