This paper focuses on the particle crushing mechanism of construction solid waste recycled aggregate (CWRA), particularly recycled concrete (RC) and recycled bricks (RB), using natural gravel (NG) as a control group. Compression tests, combined with the Weibull distribution, fractal dimension theory, and relative crushing rate, were conducted to investigate the crushing behavior of these materials under different loads. Results indicate that, under the same load, the crushing degree ranks from highest to lowest as RB, RC, and NG. The Weibull distribution effectively describes the crushing state, with “fragmentation” being the primary mode for most materials, while RC also exhibits “grinding.” As the load increases, the relative crushing rate rises for all materials but slows beyond a certain load threshold, indicating greater difficulty in further crushing. The study identifies a load threshold of 400 kN, beyond which changes in void fraction and relative crushing rates become less significant, particularly in stronger aggregates. Highlights Identified that mortar attached to the RC surface is the primary cause of the increased particle crushing below 0.6 mm. Introduced Weibull distribution parameters a and b to accurately characterize the crushing state of RA particles. Revealed the errors between fractal dimension-based evaluations and the actual crushing state of RC particles. Proposed a two-stage crushing mode for RC. Determined the critical threshold value for the variation of crushing degree with load level.