Resource partitioning plays an important role in supporting species coexistence. In a coastal upwelling ecosystem two weakfish species, Cynoscion guatucupa and C. jamaicensis co-occur and are key commercial species. The present study aimed to provide a comprehensive assessment of the feeding ecology of both species, including to; (i) quantitatively assess diet, (ii) evaluate ontogenetic and seasonal diet variations, and (iii) estimate dietary overlap in the context of competition or resource partitioning, using an integrated approach combining stomach content (SCA) and stable isotope analyses (SIA). Our results revealed that both C. guatucupa and C. jamaicensis prey mainly on pelagic fish and shrimp with ontogenetic and seasonal changes in diet detected. Weakfishes consume a large proportion of similar prey throughout the year and high isotopic niche overlap confirmed the SCA results. Despite the similar use of food resources by both species, the availability and abundance of prey promoted by seasonal upwellings and the possible spatial segregation between C. guatucupa and C. jamaicensis may promote their co-occurrence in an upwelling ecosystem. Due to their commercial value and fisheries importance in the southwestern Atlantic, these results contribute insights to support sustainable fisheries management.