Reviewed by: The Normans in the Mediterranean ed. by Emily A. Winkler and Liam Fitzgerald Lindsay Diggelmann Winkler, Emily A., and Liam Fitzgerald, eds, The Normans in the Mediterranean (Medieval Identities: Socio-Cultural Spaces, 9), Turnhout, Brepols, 2021; hardback; pp. 268; 11 b/w, 5 colour illustrations; R.R.P. €75.00; ISBN 9782503590578. Examinations of Norman activity in Italy and the wider Mediterranean region are numerous, but this volume of essays has much to add to our understanding of the effect of the northerners' arrival in the south. From their first appearance as [End Page 176] missionaries and pilgrims in the early eleventh century, through to the creation of Roger II's multicultural kingdom in the twelfth, Norman immigrants and their descendants conquered, reshaped, and amalgamated with the existing Latin, Greek, and Islamic societies in Italy and Sicily. The introduction provides a useful thematic overview, placing the narrowly focused individual essays within the broader context of scholarship on the Mediterranean going back to Braudel. The general aim is to provide micro-studies, often dealing with evidence at the local or personal level, which can balance the well-known 'grand narrative' of Norman expansion. Above all, the editors and authors are keen to demonstrate how the changing circumstances brought by new Norman ruling powers affected prevailing social conditions. Essays are grouped into three parts with individual contributions loosely connected around the themes of 'Motivations', 'Implications', and 'Perceptions'. While the subjects and sources are diverse, there is a pleasing coherence to the collection, perhaps more than is often the case in volumes of this nature. Part I on 'Motivations and Strategies' opens with Matthew Bennett's survey of the current state of the field and key narrative sources for the idea of normanitas and Norman relations with those peoples they encountered in Italy. Aurélie Thomas looks at marriage strategies, discerning variance in the success of Norman newcomers in marrying into established powerful families. Differing outcomes, she argues, can be linked to the differing inheritance practices of Italian elites, thus placing agency in the decisions on whether to pursue dynastic alliances back on to local families, rather than seeing it all rest with ambitious Norman lords. In the final chapter of the section, Lucas Villegas-Aristizábal broadens our horizons by examining Norman incursions into Iberia up until the time of the Third Crusade. Themes of Norman expansion and ambition played out equally in Iberia, although geographically distant from the areas looked at by other contributions, adding a valuable comparative element to the collection. Five chapters in Part II deal with social realities and the 'Implications of Conquest' in the wake of the Normans' arrival in Italy. Architectural, archaeological, and documentary evidence sits alongside investigation of the more familiar narrative sources. Sandro Carocci argues for the importance of 'micro-lordships', suggesting that these were much more influential in determining the outcome of local affairs compared with the efforts of the great territorial lords. Graham Loud uses charter evidence to establish the role of Norman kin groups in the nobility of southern Italy between 1085 and 1127, a period for which the narrative sources are extremely sparse. By focusing on the specific example of Salerno, Maddalena Vaccaro shows how a deliberate ecclesiastical building programme could promote Norman integration into a city they now ruled. Theresa Jäckh also undertakes the case study of a single city, Roger II's capital Palermo in Sicily, to question the nature of the transition from Islamic to Norman rule. Using Latin texts and Arabic documents, Jäckh contests the consensus view that the city's importance had significantly weakened under Islamic authority in the [End Page 177] period before the Normans' conquest of the island. Finally in Part II, Nicole Mölk examines material evidence from a hilltop village in Sicily which suggests the possibility of Christian and Muslim communities living side by side. Despite this positive conclusion, the archaeological record also indicates the difficulties which ordinary members of Sicilian society faced in their day-to-day lives. Two excellent essays on 'Perceptions and Memories' round out the collection in the shorter Part III. Matt King discusses Roger II's temporary conquest of Africa (roughly equivalent...
Read full abstract