Coincidence Spectroscopy Research Articles

Photoelectron Photoion Coincidence Spectroscopy of Biradicals.

The electronic structure of biradicals is characterized by the presence of two unpaired electrons in degenerate or near-degenerate molecular orbitals. In particular, some of the most relevant species are highly reactive, difficult to generate cleanly and can only be studied in the gas phase or in matrices. Unveiling their electronic structure is, however, of paramount interest to understand their chemistry. Photoelectron photoion coincidence (PEPICO) spectroscopy is an excellent approach to explore the electronic states of biradicals, because it enables a direct correlation between the detected ions and electrons. This permits to extract unique vibrationally resolved photoion mass-selected threshold photoelectron spectra (ms-TPES) to obtain insight in the electronic structure of both the neutral and the cation. In this review we highlight most recent advances on the spectroscopy of biradicals and biradicaloids, utilizing PEPICO spectroscopy and vacuum ultraviolet (VUV) synchrotron radiation.

Metastability and fragmentation of the OCS3+ states produced by S 2p double Auger decay.

The metastability and the dissociation processes of the OCS3+ states produced by the S 2p double Auger decay of OCS are investigated by multi-electron-ion coincidence spectroscopy using a magnetic bottle electron spectrometer. The spectra of the OCS3+ states filtered for the production of individual ions are derived by four-fold (or five-fold) coincidence among three electrons and a product ion (or two ions). The ground OCS3+ state is confirmed to be metastable in the 10 µs regime. The OCS3+ states relevant to the individual channels of two- and three-body dissociations are clarified.

Cover Feature: Bonding in Low‐Coordinated Organoarsenic and Organoantimony Compounds: A Threshold Photoelectron Spectroscopic Investigation (Chem. Eur. J. 35/2023)

Biradical formation vs. π-bonding: The low-valent, highly reactive pnictogen compounds PnCH3 (Pn=As, Sb) have been generated in situ by controlled homolysis of Pn(CH3)3 in the gas phase and investigated by photoelectron–photoion coincidence spectroscopy. This allowed us to establish trends in nature's strategy to stabilize low-valent pnictogen species either by tautomerization with concomitant multiple bond formation (HPn=CH2) or by biradical formation (Pn−CH3). The graphic illustrates the energetic steps separating the isomers of these fundamentally important group 15 compounds. More information can be found in the Research Article by C. Lichtenberg, P. Hemberger, I. Fischer and co-workers (DOI: 10.1002/chem.202300637).

Bonding in Low-Coordinated Organoarsenic and Organoantimony Compounds: A Threshold Photoelectron Spectroscopic Investigation.

Methyl and methylene compounds of arsenic and antimony have been studied by photoelectron photoion coincidence spectroscopy to investigate their relative stability. While for As both HAs=CH2 , As-CH3 and the methylene compound As=CH2 are identified in the spectrum, the only Sb compound observed is Sb-CH3 . Thus, there is a step in the main group 15 between As and Sb, regarding the relative stability of the methyl compounds. Ionisation energies, vibrational frequencies and spin-orbit splittings were determined for the methyl compound from photoion mass-selected photoelectron spectra. Although the spectroscopic results for organoantimony resemble those for the previously investigated bismuth compounds, EPR spectroscopic experiments indicate a far lower tendency for methyl transfer for Sb(CH3 )3 compared to Bi(CH3 )3 . This study concludes investigations on low-valent organopnictogen compounds.

Search for the interatomic Auger effect in Nitrous Oxide

The interatomic Auger effect following O 1s ionization in N2O has been experimentally investigated using multi-electron coincidence spectroscopy. The expected transition energies have been established by comparison to the measured N 1s−1v−1 core-valence double ionization energies. We describe a procedure to eliminate the background of two competing processes contributing spectroscopic signatures to the same energy range, namely double Auger decay of the O 1s vacancy and direct single-photon double ionization into the N 1s−1v−1 states. While the interatomic Auger transitions could not be successfully isolated, we provide an upper boundary of the transition probability of 0.07% with respect to the dominant single Auger decay after O 1s ionization.

Photoionization Dynamics and Proton Transfer within the Adenine-Thymine Nucleobase Pair

Studying the stability of hydrogen-bonded nucleobase pairs, at the heart of the genetic code, is of utmost importance for an in-depth understanding of basic mechanisms of life and biomolecular evolution. We present here a VUV single photon ionization dynamic study of the nucleobase pair adenine-thymine (AT), revealing its ionization and dissociative ionization thresholds via double imaging electron/ion coincidence spectroscopy. The experimental data, consisting of cluster mass-resolved threshold photoelectron spectra and photon energy-dependent ion kinetic energy release distributions, allow the unambiguous distinction of the dissociation of AT into protonated adenine AH+ and a dehydrogenated thymine radical T(-H) from dissociative ionization processes of other nucleobase clusters. Comparison to high-level ab initio calculations indicates that our experimental observations can be explained by a single hydrogen-bonded conformer present in our molecular beam and allows the estimation of an upper limit of the barrier of the proton transfer in the ionized AT pair.

Photoelectron spectroscopy and dissociative photoionization of fulminic acid, HCNO.

We report a joint experimental and computational study of the photoelectron spectroscopy and the dissociative photoionization of fulminic acid, HCNO. The molecule is of interest to astrochemistry and astrobiology as a potential precursor of prebiotic molecules. Synchrotron radiation was used as the photon source. Dispersive photoelectron spectra were recorded from 10 to 22eV, covering four band systems in the HCNO cation, and an ionization energy of 10.83eV was determined. Transitions into the Renner-Teller distorted X+2Π state of the cation were simulated using wavepacket dynamics based on a vibronic coupling Hamiltonian. Very good agreement between experiment and theory is obtained. While the first excited state of the cation shows only a broad and unstructured spectrum, the next two higher states exhibit a well-resolved vibrational progression. Transitions into the excited electronic states of HCNO+ were not simulated due to the large number of electronic states that contribute to these transitions. Nevertheless, a qualitative assignment is given, based on the character of the orbitals involved in the transitions. The dissociative photoionization was investigated by photoelectron-photoion coincidence spectroscopy. The breakdown diagram shows evidence for isomerization from HCNO+ to HNCO+ on the cationic potential energy surface. Zero Kelvin appearance energies for the daughter ions HCO+ and NCO+ have been derived.

X-ray induced electron and ion fragmentation dynamics in IBr.

Characterization of the inner-shell decay processes in molecules containing heavy elements is key to understanding x-ray damage of molecules and materials and for medical applications with Auger-electron-emitting radionuclides. The 1s hole states of heavy atoms can be produced by absorption of tunable x rays and the resulting vacancy decays characterized by recording emitted photons, electrons, and ions. The 1s hole states in heavy elements have large x-ray fluorescence yields that transfer the hole to intermediate electron shells that then decay by sequential Auger-electron transitions that increase the ion's charge state until the final state is reached. In molecules, the charge is spread across the atomic sites, resulting in dissociation to energetic atomic ions. We have used x-ray/ion coincidence spectroscopy to measure charge states and energies of Iq+ and Brq'+ atomic ions following 1s ionization at the I and Br K-edges of IBr. We present the charge states and kinetic energies of the two correlated fragment ions associated with core-excited states produced during the various steps of the cascades. To understand the dynamics leading to the ion data, we develop a computational model that combines Monte-Carlo/Molecular-Dynamics (MC/MD) simulations with a classical over-the-barrier model to track inner-shell cascades and redistribution of electrons in valence orbitals and nuclear motion of fragments.

Operando Photoelectron Photoion Coincidence Spectroscopy to Detect Short-lived Intermediates in Catalysis.

Understanding the reaction mechanism is critical yet challenging in heterogeneous catalysis. Reactive intermediates, e.g., radicals and ketenes, are short-lived and often evade detection. In this review, we summarize recent developments with operando photoelectron photoion coincidence (PEPICO) spectroscopy as a versatile tool capable of detecting elusive intermediates. PEPICO combines the advantages of mass spectrometry and the isomer-selectivity of threshold photoelectron spectroscopy. Recent applications of PEPICO in understanding catalyst synthesis and catalytic reaction mechanisms involving gaseous and surface-confined radical and ketene chemistry will be summarized.

SO2 Photodissociation at 193 nm Directly Forms S(3P) + O2(3Σg-): Implications for the Archean Atmosphere on Earth.

It is well-documented that photodissociation of SO2 at λ = 193 nm produces O(3Pj) + SO X(3Σ-). We provide experimental evidence of a new product channel from one-photon absorption producing S(3Pj) + O2 X(3Σg-) in 2-4% yield. We probe the reactant and all products with time-resolved photoelectron photoion coincidence spectroscopy. High-level ab initio calculations suggest that the new product channel can only occur on the ground-state potential energy surface through internal conversion from the excited state, followed by isomerization to a transient SOO intermediate. Classical trajectories on the ground-state potential energy surface with random initial conditions qualitatively reproduce the experimental yields. This unexpected photodissociation pathway may help reconcile discrepancies in sulfur mass-independent fractionation mechanisms in Earth's geologic history, which shape our understanding of the Archean atmosphere and the Great Oxygenation Event in Earth's evolution.

Unraveling Radical and Oxygenate Routes in the Oxidative Dehydrogenation of Propane over Boron Nitride.

Oxidative dehydrogenation of propane (ODHP) is an emerging technology to meet the global propylene demand with boron nitride (BN) catalysts likely to play a pivotal role. It is widely accepted that gas-phase chemistry plays a fundamental role in the BN-catalyzed ODHP. However, the mechanism remains elusive because short-lived intermediates are difficult to capture. We detect short-lived free radicals (CH3•, C3H5•) and reactive oxygenates, C2-4 ketenes and C2-3 enols, in ODHP over BN by operando synchrotron photoelectron photoion coincidence spectroscopy. In addition to a surface-catalyzed channel, we identify a gas-phase H-acceptor radical- and H-donor oxygenate-driven route, leading to olefin production. In this route, partially oxidized enols propagate into the gas phase, followed by dehydrogenation (and methylation) to form ketenes and finally yield olefins by decarbonylation. Quantum chemical calculations predict the >BO dangling site to be the source of free radicals in the process. More importantly, the easy desorption of oxygenates from the catalyst surface is key to prevent deep oxidation to CO2.

A direct liquid sampling interface for photoelectron photoion coincidence spectroscopy.

We introduce an effective and flexible high vacuum interface to probe the liquid phase with photoelectron photoion coincidence (liq-PEPICO) spectroscopy at the vacuum ultraviolet (VUV) beamline of the Swiss Light Source. The interface comprises a high-temperature sheath gas-driven vaporizer, which initially produces aerosols. The particles evaporate and form a molecular beam, which is skimmed and ionized by VUV radiation. The molecular beam is characterized using ion velocity map imaging, and the vaporization parameters of the liq-PEPICO source have been optimized to improve the detection sensitivity. Time-of-flight mass spectra and photoion mass-selected threshold photoelectron spectra (ms-TPES) were recorded for an ethanolic solution of 4-propylguaiacol, vanillin, and 4-hydroxybenzaldehyde (1 g/l of each). The ground state ms-TPES band of vanillin reproduces the reference, room-temperature spectrum well. The ms-TPES for 4-propylguaiacol and 4-hydroxybenzaldehyde are reported for the first time. Vertical ionization energies obtained by equation-of-motion calculations reproduce the photoelectron spectral features. We also investigated the aldol condensation dynamics of benzaldehyde with acetone using liq-PEPICO. Our direct sampling approach, thus, enables probing reactions at ambient pressure during classical synthesis procedures and microfluidic chip devices.

Capturing transient core-to-core resonances in Kr in intense extreme-ultraviolet laser fields by electron-ion coincidence spectroscopy

Resonances between core-hole states have been long hypothesized to understand dynamics of atoms and molecules exposed to intense XFEL pulses, but evaded clear identification due to their transient nature. The authors report clear evidence of core-to-core resonances by electron-ion coincidence spectroscopy on Kr atoms and elucidate the importance in nonlinear electronic responses of matter to high-frequency laser fields.

Forming Bonds While Breaking Old Ones: Isomer-Dependent Formation of H3O+ from Aminobenzoic Acid During X-ray-Induced Fragmentation.

Intramolecular hydrogen transfer, a reaction where donor and acceptor sites of a hydrogen atom are part of the same molecule, is a ubiquitous reaction in biochemistry and organic synthesis. In this work, we report hydronium ion (H3O+) production from aminobenzoic acid (ABA) after core-level ionization with soft X-ray synchrotron radiation. The formation of H3O+ during the fragmentation requires that at least two hydrogen atoms migrate to one of the oxygen atoms within the molecule. The comparison of two structural isomers, ortho- and meta-ABA, revealed that the production of H3O+ depends strongly on the structure of the molecule, the ortho-isomer being much more prone to produce H3O+. The isomer-dependency suggests that the amine group acts as a donor in the hydrogen transfer process. In the case of ortho-ABA, detailed H3O+ production pathways were investigated using photoelectron-photoion-photoion coincidence (PEPIPICO) spectroscopy. It was found that H3O+ can result from a direct two-body dissociation but also from sequential fragmentation processes.

Isomer-Dependent Threshold Photoelectron Spectroscopy and Dissociative Photoionization Mechanism of Anisaldehyde.

We studied the threshold photoionization and dissociative ionization of para-, meta-, and ortho-anisaldehyde by photoelectron photoion coincidence spectroscopy in the 8.20-19.00 eV photon energy range. Vertical ionization energies by equation of motion-ionization potential-coupled cluster singles and doubles (EOM-IP-CCSD) calculations reproduce the photoelectron spectral features in all three isomers. The dissociative photoionization (DPI) pathways of para- and meta-anisaldehyde are similar and differ markedly from those of ortho-anisaldehyde. In the para and meta isomers, the lowest-energy DPI channel corresponds to hydrogen atom loss to form the C8H7O2+ fragment at m/z 135, which undergoes sequential dissociation processes at higher energies, such as carbon monoxide loss to C7H7O+ (m/z 107) and further, sequential CH3, CH2O, and CH2CO losses to produce C6H4O+ (m/z 92), C6H5+ (m/z 77), and C5H5+ (m/z 65), respectively. Carbon monoxide loss from the parent ions, yielding C7H8O+ (m/z 108), is a subordinate dissociation channel parallel to H atom loss. At higher energies, it also gives rise to sequential formaldehyde (CH2O) loss to produce C6H6+ (m/z 78). In the ortho-anisaldehyde cation, the vicinity of the aldehyde and methoxy groups opens up low-energy hydrogen-transfer processes, which allow for seven fragmentation channels to compete effectively with the H- and CO-loss channels. Thus, the fragmentation mechanism changes considerably, thanks to the steric interaction of the substituents. Functional group interactions, in particular H transfer pathways, must therefore be considered when predicting the isomer-specific unimolecular decomposition mechanism of cationic and neutral species, as well as mass spectra for isomers.

Pyrolysis of Trifluoroacetic Acid and Trifluoroacetic Anhydride Studied with Mass Spectrometry and Synchrotron Radiation: Decomposition and Free Radical Formation

AbstractThe remediation strategies for accumulated polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) are a subject of great concern in environmental science. In this study, the thermal decomposition of trifluoroacetic acid (TFA) and trifluoroacetic anhydride (TFAN), taken as models of PFAS, were explored. Imaging photoelectron photoion coincidence (iPEPICO) spectroscopy was used to detect pyrolysis products from room temperature to 1000 °C under dilute conditions. The observed pyrolysis products of each molecule were CO, CO2, CF2, and CF2O (and CF3 for TFAN), with some species reflecting unimolecular rearrangement prior to dissociation. Electronic structure calculations using density functional theory and the SVECV‐F12 composite method were employed to evaluate the energy of the different decomposition channels. The results show the advantage of exploring the pyrolysis under dilute conditions to catch the first stages of unimolecular dissociation of these molecules for the first time.

Probing the pyrolysis of ethyl formate in the dilute gas phase by synchrotron radiation and theory.

The thermal decomposition of the atmospheric constituent ethyl formate was studied by coupling flash pyrolysis with imaging photoelectron photoion coincidence (iPEPICO) spectroscopy using synchrotron vacuum ultraviolet (VUV) radiation at the Swiss Light Source (SLS). iPEPICO allows photoion mass-selected threshold photoelectron spectra (ms-TPES) to be obtained for pyrolysis products. By threshold photoionization and ion imaging, parent ions of neutral pyrolysis products and dissociative photoionization products could be distinguished, and multiple spectral carriers could be identified in several ms-TPES. The TPES and mass-selected TPES for ethyl formate are reported for the first time and appear to correspond to ionization of the lowest energy conformer having a cis (eclipsed) configuration of the O=C(H)-O-C(H2 )-CH3 and trans (staggered) configuration of the O=C(H)-O-C(H2 )-CH3 dihedral angles. We observed the following ethyl formate pyrolysis products: CH3 CH2 OH, CH3 CHO, C2 H6 , C2 H4 , HC(O)OH, CH2 O, CO2 , and CO, with HC(O)OH and C2 H4 pyrolyzing further, forming CO + H2 O and C2 H2 + H2 . The reaction paths and energetics leading to these products, together with the products of two homolytic bond cleavage reactions, CH3 CH2 O + CHO and CH3 CH2 + HC(O)O, were studied computationally at the M06-2X-GD3/aug-cc-pVTZ and SVECV-f12 levels of theory, complemented by further theoretical methods for comparison. The calculated reaction pathways were used to derive Arrhenius parameters for each reaction. The reaction rate constants and branching ratios are discussed in terms of the residence time and newly suggest carbon monoxide as a competitive primary fragmentation product at high temperatures.

Threshold photoelectron spectroscopy and dissociative photoionization of benzonitrile.

The threshold photoionization and dissociative ionization of benzonitrile (C6H5CN) were studied using double imaging photoelectron photoion coincidence (i2PEPICO) spectroscopy at the Vacuum Ultraviolet (VUV) beamline of the Swiss Light Source (SLS). The threshold photoelectron spectrum was recorded from 9.6 to 12.7 eV and Franck-Condon simulations of ionization into the ionic ground state, X̃+, as well as the B̃+ and C̃+ states were performed to assign the observed vibronic structures. The adiabatic ionization energies of the X̃+, B̃+ and C̃+ states are determined to be (9.72 ± 0.02), (11.85 ± 0.03) and, tentatively, (12.07 ± 0.04) eV, respectively. Threshold ionization mass spectra were recorded from 13.75 to 19.75 eV and the breakdown diagram was constructed by plotting the fractional abundances of the parent ion and ionic dissociation products as a function of photon energy. The seven lowest energy dissociative photoionization channels of benzonitrile were found to yield CN˙ + c-C6H5+, HCN + C6H4˙+, C2H4 + HC5N˙+, HC3N + C4H4˙+, H2C3N˙ + C4H3+, CH2CHCN + C4H2˙+ and H2C4N˙ + c-C3H3+. HCN loss from the benzonitrile cation is the dominant dissociation channel from the dissociation onset of up to 18.1 eV and CH2CHCN loss becomes dominant from 18.1 eV and up. We present extensive potential energy surface calculations on the C6H5CN˙+ surface to rationalize the detected products. The breakdown diagram and time-of-flight mass spectra are fitted using a Rice-Ramsperger-Kassel-Marcus statistical model. Anchoring the fit to the CBS-QB3 result (3.42 eV) for the barrier to HCN loss, we obtained experimental dissociation barriers for the products of 4.30 eV (CN loss), 5.53 eV (C2H4 loss), 4.33 eV (HC3N loss), 5.15 eV (H2C3N loss), 4.93 eV (CH2CHCN loss) and 4.41 eV (H2C4N loss). We compare our work to studies of the electron-induced dissociative ionization of benzonitrile and isoelectronic phenylacetylene (C8H6), as well as the VUV-induced dissociation of protonated benzonitrile (C6H5CNH+). Also, we discuss the potential role of barrierless association reactions found for some of the identified fragments as a source of benzonitrile(˙+) in interstellar chemistry and in Titan's atmosphere.

Doubly ionized OCS bond rearrangement upon fragmentation - experiment and theory.

The dissociation of OCS2+ ions formed by photoionization of the neutral molecule at 40.81 eV is examined using threefold and fourfold electron-ion coincidence spectroscopy combined with high level quantum chemical calculations on isomeric structures and their potential energy surfaces. The dominant dissociation channel of [OCS]2+ is charge separation forming CO+ + S+ ion pairs, found here to be formed with low intensity at a lower-energy onset and with a correspondingly smaller kinetic energy release than in the more intense higher energy channel previously reported. We explain the formation of CO+ + S+ ion pairs at low as well as higher ionization energies by the existence of two predissociation channels, one involving a newly identified COS2+ metastable state. We conclude that the dominant CO+ + S+ channel with 5.2 eV kinetic energy release is reached upon OCS2+ → COS2+ isomerization, whereas the smaller kinetic energy release (of ∼4 eV) results from the direct fragmentation of OCS2+ (X3Σ-) ions. Dissociation of the COS2+ isomer also explains the existence of the minor C+ + SO+ ion pair channel. We suggest that isomerization prior to dissociation may be a widespread mechanism in dications and more generally in multiply charged ion dissociations.

Probing Anion-Molecule Complexes of Atmospheric Relevance Using Anion Photoelectron Detachment Spectroscopy.

Bimolecular reaction and collision complexes that drive atmospheric chemistry and contribute to the absorption of solar radiation are fleeting and therefore inherently challenging to study experimentally. Furthermore, primary anions in the troposphere are short lived because of a complicated web of reactions and complex formation they undergo, making details of their early fate elusive. In this perspective, the experimental approach of photodetaching mass-selected anion-molecule complexes or complex anions, which prepares neutrals in various vibronic states, is surveyed. Specifically, the application of anion photoelectron spectroscopy along with photoelectron-photofragment coincidence spectroscopy toward the study of collision complexes, complex anions in which a partial covalent bond is formed, and radical bimolecular reaction complexes, with relevance in tropospheric chemistry, will be highlighted.