In this study, the macroscopic mechanical behavior was characterized for poled and unpoled polycrystalline (1−x)(Na1/2Bi1/2)TiO3-xBaTiO3 (NBT-xBT) for compositions across the morphotropic phase boundary (MPB). Due to a field-induced ferroelectric phase transformation, NBT-xBT compositions near the MPB (x = 6–7 mol%) showed a significant decrease in the coercive stress for electrically poled samples. The apparent difference in mechanical behavior is suggested to be due to an irreversible electric-field-induced transformation to long-range ferroelectric order in the poled samples. The results indicate a significant difference in the critical stresses for the relaxor-ferroelectric transition and ferroelastic domain wall motion, which can have important effects on applications for lead-free ferroelectrics. To further illustrate this, a method was developed to electrically depole NBT-xBT at room temperature, resulting in an unpoled NBT-xBT material with long-range ferroelectric order. Mechanical testing revealed analogous macroscopic ferroelastic behavior to the poled samples, despite the lack of a piezoelectric response.