Feminist Studies 47, no. 3. © 2021 by Feminist Studies, Inc. 599 Sushmita Chatterjee and Kiran Asher Animal Sightings and Citings under COVID Capitalism: Beyond Liberal Sentimentalism Conversations, news, and social media accounts about COVID are saturated with stories about animals: accounts of “wild” animals emerging and seen in cities around the world, an increase in the number of bird watchers, an astronomical rise in webcam views of wildlife, videos of zoo animals walking through their exhibition halls or through art museums and galleries. Animals are also getting adopted and fostered at an unprecedented rate, and pets appear on virtual meetings as never before. Since the World Health Organization’s (WHO) official announcement of the coronavirus pandemic in March 2020, news reports related to meat are differently but equally prevalent: the disappearance of chicken and other meat from grocery shelves; the rapid spread of the virus and death among workers in meat-packing industries; the closure of slaughterhouses leading to hogs, cows, and other animals raised for food being “euthanized”; and claims about COVID emerging from the meat of exotic animals sold in Asian “wet” markets. These “citings,” or references to the animal as food, threat, pests, and resources, are not usually seen within the same frame as animal sightings. We argue, however, that around the world animal sightings and citings sit significantly alongside each other. We juxtapose representations of animal sightings and citings to read how capitalism works at this historical moment or at the COVID conjuncture. This relational methodology fuels our inquiry. 600 Sushmita Chatterjee and Kiran Asher Popular and mainstream media accounts represent animal sightings as the pandemic’s “silver lining,” as “nature” coming back into streets and spaces emptied of humans by quarantine. Coverage of “wild” animals in urban areas and temporary reduction in carbon emissions lead to speculations on whether these are signs of hope for a healthier planet (among the sickness of COVID) and for a potential reversal of the environmental damage of global warming and climate change.1 More time with pets and connections with nonhuman kin enabled by greater leisure time or forced isolation are seen as possibilities that we can suture the sense of alienation (with each other and the natural world) that modernity engenders.2 Stories about animals in slaughterhouses and in farms, fields, and factories raised as part of the industrial production of food do not occupy the same representational space in news or popular accounts; even less do citings about the scarcity of meat in stores and work and death in meat processing plants occur alongside narratives of animal sightings. We contend, however, that the two are closely connected. In this paper, we explore seen and celebrated animal lives (in sightings ) and unseen and unmourned animal deaths (in citings) in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic, foregrounding their linkages. We juxtapose the wonder of living with and viewing animals with the obliteration of animals that become “dead meat” to argue that the former can evoke sentimentalism and awe only when considered in a separate register from the latter. This splitting not only renders animal death invisible, but also conceals the labor of dead and living animals. We describe and analyze this stark contradiction, which fundamentally structures and substantiates capitalist political economy. Commentaries abound about how the COVID pandemic is a moment of crisis that brings the contradictions 1. Kaylee Brzezinski, “The Surprising Climate Change Benefits of Coronavirus ,” One Tree Planted, March 17, 2020, https://onetreeplanted.org/blogs /stories/climate-change-benefits-coronavirus; “The Urban Wild: Animals Take to the Streets amid Lockdown–In Pictures,” Guardian, April 22, 2020, https://www.theguardian.com/world/gallery/2020/apr/22/animals-roamingstreets -coronavirus-lockdown-photos. 2. Lisa Walden “Pet Owners Have a Lot to Thank Their Animals for during Lockdown,” Country Living, June 6, 2020, https://www.countryliving.com /uk/wildlife/pets/a32764266/pets-boosting-owner-motivation-lockdown; Connie Wang, “The Pure Positivity of a Quarantine Dog,” Refinery29, March 26, 2020, https://www.refinery29.com/en-us/2020/03/9607659/adopt-rescuedog -coronavirus-quarantine. Sushmita Chatterjee and Kiran Asher 601 of capitalism’s working into sharper relief. 3 In this essay, we sketch the tandem workings of sightings and citings of...