Tetrel (Si, Ge, Sn) clathrates are host-guest structures that display novel electrochemical reactions with Li and Na due to their unique cage structure. One area of interest for Tetrel clathrates is the possibility of topotactic Li/Na insertion into the clathrate framework due to the open cage structure. The type II clathrate Na24-x(Si,Ge)136 is unique because the structure can be obtained without guest atoms in the clathrate framework. Figure 1 shows a crystal model schematic of the two unique polyhedral cages that comprise the type II Si clathrate structure: the dodecahedra (Si20, grey) and the hexakaidecahedra (Si28, blue). The structure usually forms with Na guest atoms (yellow) in the center of these cages, but when heated (300 – 500 °C ) under vacuum, the Na atoms diffuse and evaporate out of the structure resulting in a guest free clathrate, Si136.1 Once Na is removed the structure, Li intercalation into the vacant cages becomes possible.2 During the lithiation of the guest-free type II Si clathrate (Na1Si136), there is plateau at 0.30 V vs Li/Li+ which corresponds to Li intercalation into the vacant cages of the clathrate structure.2,3 With synchrotron powder X-ray diffraction, we confirm that Li intercalation is occurring in a topotactic fashion into the framework and identify the Li positions in the two types of cages. In the Si20 cage, Li is found near the center of the cages with a slightly split position, while Li in the Si28 cage is found very off-center, coordinated off the hexagonal faces. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations corroborate the Li positions in both cages. Next, we demonstrate that by using a voltage cutoff of 0.26 V, reversible Li insertion is possible as evidenced by the reproducible voltage profile. Due to the very low volume expansion (0.23 %) and reasonable capacity and voltage (230 mAh/g at 0.30 V), the type II Si clathrate has possible applications as an anode for Li-ion rechargeable batteries.In contrast to the room temperature intercalation of Li, we find that electrochemical deintercalation of Na from the type II structure requires high temperatures (350-450 °C) and overpotentials to achieve. We demonstrate electrochemical desodiation using a novel high temperature approach using a Na beta-alumina solid electrolyte.4 By using DFT to calculate the migration barriers for Na and Li, we demonstrate that the large differences between Li and Na intercalation originates from the much higher migration barriers for Na (1.0 - 2.0 eV) in the type II structure when compared to Li (0.2 eV). Based on these results, design rules for intercalation into Tetrel frameworks will be discussed and other promising open Tetrel frameworks highlighted. Figure 1: Crystal model schematic of the two types of polyhedral in the type II Si clathrate structure: the dodecahedra (grey) and the hexakaidecahedra (blue). Si atoms are orange and Na atoms are yellow. References (1) Krishna, L.; Baranowski, L. L.; Martinez, A. D.; Koh, C. A.; Taylor, P. C.; Tamboli, A. C.; Toberer, E. S. Efficient Route to Phase Selective Synthesis of Type II Silicon Clathrates with Low Sodium Occupancy. CrystEngComm 2014, 16, 3940–3949.(2) Langer, T.; Dupke, S.; Trill, H.; Passerini, S.; Eckert, H.; Pöttgen, R.; Winter, M. Electrochemical Lithiation of Silicon Clathrate-II. J. Electrochem. Soc. 2012, 159, A1318–A1322.(3) Dopilka, A.; Weller, J. M.; Ovchinnikov, A.; Childs, A.; Bobev, S.; Peng, X.; Chan, C. K. Structural Origin of Reversible Li Insertion in Guest‐Free, Type II Silicon Clathrates. Adv. Energy Sustain. Res. 2021, 2000114.(4) Dopilka, A.; Childs, A.; Bobev, S.; Chan, C. K. Solid-State Electrochemical Synthesis of Silicon Clathrates Using a Sodium-Sulfur Battery Inspired Approach. J. Electrochem. Soc. 2021, 168, 020516. Figure 1
Read full abstract