Direct detection of biotinylated proteins (DiDBiT) is a proteomic method that can enrich and detect newly synthesized proteins (NSPs) labeled with bio-orthogonal amino acids with 20-fold improved detectability compared to conventional methods. However, DiDBiT has currently been used to compare only two conditions per experiment. Here, we present DiDBiT-TMT, a method that can be used to quantify NSPs across many conditions and replicates in the same experiment by combining isobaric tandem mass tagging (TMT) with DiDBiT. We applied DiDBiT-TMT to brain slices to determine changes in the de novo proteome that occur after inducing chemical long-term potentiation (cLTP) or treatment with the neuromodulator norepinephrine. We successfully demonstrated DiDBiT-TMT's capacity to quantitatively compare up to 9 samples in parallel. We showed that there is a minimal overlap among NSPs that are differentially expressed in cLTP-treated organotypic brain slices, norepinephrine-treated organotypic brain slices, and organotypic slices undergoing combinatorial treatment with norepinephrine and cLTP. Our results point to the possible divergence of the molecular mechanisms underlying these treatments and showcase the applicability of DiDBiT-TMT for studying neurobiology.