Charge Detection Mass Spectrometry Research Articles

Dissociation of Macromolecules in Laser-Heated Droplets Monitored by CD-MS.

Charge detection mass spectrometry (CD-MS) is used to monitor the dissociation of large (300 kDa to 20 MDa) protein complexes in droplets heated with a 10.6 μm CO2 laser. In this approach, electrospray ionization (ESI) is used to produce charged droplets containing macromolecular complexes. As the droplets travel from the ESI capillary tip to the entrance of the CD-MS instrument, they pass through a variable-power laser field, where they are rapidly heated and dissociate to produce fragments. The approach is illustrated for three model systems: glutamate dehydrogenase (GDH), a 334 kDa hexameric protein complex, which dissociates into protein monomers, dimers, and tetramers; the ∼3 MDa T = 3, and ∼4 MDa T = 4 hepatitis B virus VLPs (virus-like particles) that produce a distribution of protein dimer clusters; and the ∼20 MDa T = 7 human papillomavirus VLP, which dissociates primarily into small capsid protein clusters that are not well-resolved by CD-MS. The fragments produced by in-droplet activation provide information that is useful for characterizing the structures of the intact antecedent complexes. A discussion of the advantages and current limitations of this approach is presented.

Genetically Engineered, Multichromophore Virus-Like Nanoparticles with Ultranarrow Distribution of Emission Intensity.

Variance in the properties of optical mesoscopic probes is often a limiting factor in applications. In the thermodynamic limit, the smaller the probe, the larger the relative variance. However, specific viral protein cages can assemble efficiently outside the bounds of statistical fluctuations at equilibrium through a process that is characterized by intrinsic quality-control and self-limiting capabilities. In this paper, an approach is described that leverages stoichiometric and structural accuracy in the murine polyoma virus capsid assembly to demonstrate bright, narrowly distributed fluorescence intensity from multichromophore particles that surpass state-of-the-art fluorescent nanosphere probes. Charge-detection mass spectrometry analysis demonstrated that proteins resulting from the fusion of superfolding green fluorescent protein (sfGFP) murine polyoma virus coat proteins self-assemble in vitro into virus-like particles that have similar stoichiometry as virus-like particles formed from wild-type virus coat proteins. Single-particle analysis by total internal reflection fluorescence microscopy provided evidence for a narrow fluorescence intensity that reflects stoichiometric accuracy of the construct.

Standardized workflow for multiplexed charge detection mass spectrometry on orbitrap analyzers.

Individual ion mass spectrometry (I2MS) is the Orbitrap-based extension of the niche mass spectrometry technique known as charge detection mass spectrometry (CDMS). While traditional CDMS analysis is performed on in-house-built instruments such as the electrostatic linear ion trap, I2MS extends CDMS analysis to Orbitrap analyzers, allowing charge detection analysis to be available to the scientific community at large. I2MS simultaneously measures the mass-to-charge ratios (m/z) and charges (z) of hundreds to thousands of individual ions within one acquisition event, creating a spectral output directly into the mass domain without the need for further spectral deconvolution. A mass distribution or 'profile' can be created for any desired sample regardless of composition or heterogeneity. To assist in reducing I2MS analysis to practice, we developed this workflow for data acquisition and subsequent data analysis, which includes (i) protein sample preparation, (ii) attenuation of ion signals to obtain individual ions, (iii) the creation of a charge-calibration curve from standard proteins with known charge states and finally (iv) producing a meaningful mass spectral output from a complex or unknown sample by using the STORIboard software. This protocol is suitable for users with prior experience in mass spectrometry and bioanalytical chemistry. First, the analysis of protein standards in native and denaturing mode is presented, setting the foundation for the analysis of complex mixtures that are intractable via traditional mass spectrometry techniques. Examples of complex mixtures included here demonstrate the relevant analysis of an intact human monoclonal antibody and its intricate glycosylation patterns.

Combining Fourier Transform Ion Mobility with Charge Detection Mass Spectrometry for the Analysis of Multimeric Protein Complexes.

Charge detection mass spectrometry (CDMS) allows direct mass measurement of heterogeneous samples by simultaneously determining the charge state and the mass-to-charge ratio (m/z) of individual ions, unlike conventional MS methods that use large ensembles of ions. CDMS typically requires long acquisition times and the collection of thousands of spectra, each containing tens to hundreds of ions, to generate sufficient ion statistics, making it difficult to interface with the time scales of online separation techniques such as ion mobility. Here, we demonstrate the application of Fourier transform multiplexing and drift tube ion mobility joined with Orbitrap-based CDMS for the analysis of multimeric protein complexes. Stepped frequency modulation was utilized to enable unambiguous frequency assignment during mobility sweeps and allow spectral averaging, which improves the accuracy and signal-to-noise of ion mobility spectra and CDMS measurements. Fourier transformation of the signal reveals the arrival times and collision cross sections of ions while simultaneously collecting charge information for thousands of individual ions. Combining Fourier transform multiplexing ion mobility and CDMS provides insight into each ion's size and mass while showcasing a potential solution to the duty cycle mismatch of online separation techniques in the single ion regime.

Understanding the Formation Dynamics and Physical Properties of Nanocapsules Using Charge Detection Mass Spectrometry.

Characterizing the size, structure, and composition of nanoparticles is vital in predicting and understanding their macroscopic properties. In this work, charge detection mass spectrometry (CDMS) was used to analyze nanocapsules (∼10-200 MDa) consisting of a liquid oleic acid core surrounded by a dense silica outer shell. CDMS is an emerging method for nanoparticle analysis that can rapidly measure the mass and charge of thousands of individual nanoparticles. We find that increasing the feed volume of the tetraethylorthosilicate (TEOS) precursor added to form the silica shell of the nanocapsules yielded both higher and broader nanocapsule mass distributions with differentiable densities. A two-dimensional mass versus charge analysis also revealed the formation of two distinct populations of nanocapsules. These two nanocapsule morphologies were also present in transmission electron microscopy (TEM) images and exhibited low-density spherical cores and crescent-shaped cores where the remainder of the core volume was "filled in" by more dense silica. Nanocapsule shell growth kinetics over a ∼48-h synthesis period were also monitored by sampling the reaction mixture at various times, quenching the sampled aliquots, and then characterizing these time-resolved samples by CDMS. The CDMS data reveal three distinct growth phases in nanocapsule formation; rapid initial nucleation, an "inverted" distribution of silica growth, and a final slow growth phase where the rate of mass increase and final nanocapsule masses are dictated by the initial TEOS feed volumes. CDMS-enabled understanding of the diverse nanocapsule sizes, morphologies, and growth dynamics will allow us to better predict nanocapsule properties while reducing the experimental burden in optimizing nanocapsules for real-world applications.

Advances in Single Particle Mass Analysis.

Single particle mass analysis methods allow the measurement and characterization of individual nanoparticles, viral particles, as well as biomolecules like protein aggregates and complexes. Several key benefits are associated with the ability to analyze individual particles rather than bulk samples, such as high sensitivity and low detection limits, and virtually unlimited dynamic range, as this figure of merit strictly depends on analysis time. However, data processing and interpretation of single particle data can be complex, often requiring advanced algorithms and machine learning approaches. In addition, particle ionization, transfer, and detection efficiency can be limiting factors for certain types of analytes. Ongoing developments in the field aim to address these challenges and expand the capabilities of single particle mass analysis techniques. Charge detection mass spectrometry is a single particle version of mass spectrometry in which the charge (z) is determine independently from m/z. Nano-electromechanical resonator mass analysis relies on changes in a nanoscale device's resonance frequency upon deposition of a particle to directly derive its inertial mass. Mass photometry uses interferometric video-microscopy to derive particle mass from the intensity of the scattered light. A common feature of these approaches is the acquisition of single particle data, which can be filtered and concatenated in the form of a particle mass distribution. In the present article, dedicated to our honored colleague Richard Cole, we cover the latest technological advances and applications of these single particle mass analysis approaches.

Charge Detection Mass Spectrometry for the Analysis of Atmospheric Dust on Mars

Charge Detection Mass Spectrometry for the Analysis of Atmospheric Dust on Mars

Multimass Analysis of Adeno-Associated Virus Vectors by Orbitrap-Based Charge Detection Mass Spectrometry.

Adeno-associated virus (AAV) vectors have attracted significant attention as the main platform for gene therapy. To ensure the safety and efficacy of AAV vectors when used as gene therapy drugs, it is essential to assess their critical quality attributes (CQAs). These CQAs include the genome packaging status, the size of the genome encapsidated within the AAV capsid, and the stoichiometry of viral proteins (VPs) that constitute the AAV capsids. Analytical methods have been established for evaluating CQAs, such as analytical ultracentrifugation, capillary gel electrophoresis with laser-induced fluorescence detection, and capillary gel electrophoresis using sodium dodecyl sulfate with UV detection. Here, we present a multimass analysis of AAV vectors using orbitrap-based charge detection mass spectrometry (CDMS), a single-ion mass spectrometry. Orbitrap-based CDMS facilitates the quantitative evaluation of the genome packaging status based on the mass distribution of empty and full particles. Additionally, we established a novel method to analyze the encapsidated genome directly without pretreatment, such as protein digestion or heat treatment, and to estimate the stoichiometric variation of VP for the capsid based on the mass distribution constituted by the single peak corresponding to AAV particles. Orbitrap-based CDMS is a distinctive method that allows multiple mass characterizations of AAV vectors with a small sample volume of 20 μL for 1013 cp/mL in a short time (30 min), and it holds the potential to become a new standard method in the assessment of CQAs for AAV vectors.

High-Throughput Single-Particle Characterization of Aggregation Pathways and the Effects of Inhibitors for Large (Megadalton) Protein Oligomers.

Protein aggregation is involved in many human diseases, but characterizing the sizes and shapes of intermediate oligomers (∼10-100 nm) that are important to the formation of macroscale aggregates like amyloid fibrils is a significant analytical challenge. Here, charge detection mass spectrometry (CDMS) is used to characterize individual conformational states of bovine serum albumin oligomers with up to ∼225 molecules (15 MDa). Elongated, partially folded, and globular conformational families for each oligomer can be readily distinguished based on the extent of charging. The abundances of individual conformers vary with changes in the monomer concentration or by adding aggregation inhibitors, such as SDS, heparin, or MgCl2. These results show the potential of CDMS for investigating intermediate oligomers in protein aggregation processes that are important for understanding aggregate formation and inhibition mechanisms and could accelerate formulation buffer development to prevent the aggregation of biotherapeutics.

Coupling Online Size Exclusion Chromatography with Charge Detection-Mass Spectrometry Using Hadamard Transform Multiplexing.

Charge detection mass spectrometry (CD-MS) is a powerful technique for the analysis of large, heterogeneous biomolecules. By directly measuring the charge states of individual ions, CD-MS can measure the masses from spectra where conventional deconvolution approaches fail due to the lack of isotopic resolution or distinguishable charge states. However, CD-MS is inherently slow because hundreds or thousands of spectra need to be collected to produce adequate ion statistics. The slower speed of CD-MS complicates efforts to couple it with online separation techniques, which limit the number of spectra that can be acquired during a chromatographic peak. Here, we present the application of Hadamard transform multiplexing to online size exclusion chromatography (SEC) coupled with Orbitrap CD-MS, with a goal of using SEC for separating complex mixtures prior to CD-MS analysis. We developed a microcontroller to deliver pulsed injections from a large sample loop onto a SEC for online CD-MS analysis. Data showed a series of peaks spaced according to the pseudorandom injection sequence, which were demultiplexed with a Hadamard transform algorithm. The demultiplexed data revealed improved CD-MS signals while preserving retention time information. This multiplexing approach provides a general solution to the inherent incompatibilities of online separations and CD-MS detection that will enable a range of applications.

UniChromCD for Demultiplexing Time-Resolved Charge Detection-Mass Spectrometry Data.

Charge detection mass spectrometry (CD-MS) enables characterization of large, heterogeneous analytes through the analysis of individual ion signals. Because hundreds to thousands of scans must be acquired to produce adequate ion statistics, CD-MS generally requires long analysis times. The slow acquisition speed of CD-MS complicates efforts to couple it with time-dispersive techniques, such as chromatography and ion mobility, because it is not always possible to acquire enough scans from a single sample injection to generate sufficient ion statistics. Multiplexing methods based on Hadamard and Fourier transforms offer an attractive solution to this problem by improving the duty cycle of the separation while preserving retention/drift time information. However, integrating multiplexing with CD-MS data processing is complex. Here, we present UniChromCD, a new module in the open-source UniDec package that incorporates CD-MS time-domain data processing with demultiplexing tools. Following a detailed description of the algorithm, we demonstrate its capabilities using two multiplexed CD-MS workflows: Hadamard-transform size-exclusion chromatography and Fourier-transform ion mobility. Overall, UniChromCD provides a user-friendly interface for analysis and visualization of time-resolved CD-MS data.

Protein Complex Heterogeneity and Topology Revealed by Electron Capture Charge Reduction and Surface Induced Dissociation.

We illustrate the utility of native mass spectrometry (nMS) combined with a fast, tunable gas-phase charge reduction, electron capture charge reduction (ECCR), for the characterization of protein complex topology and glycoprotein heterogeneity. ECCR efficiently reduces the charge states of tetradecameric GroEL, illustrating Orbitrap m/z measurements to greater than 100,000 m/z. For pentameric C-reactive protein and tetradecameric GroEL, our novel device combining ECCR with surface induced dissociation (SID) reduces the charge states and yields more topologically informative fragmentation. This is the first demonstration that ECCR yields more native-like SID fragmentation. ECCR also significantly improved mass and glycan heterogeneity measurements of heavily glycosylated SARS-CoV-2 spike protein trimer and thyroglobulin dimer. Protein glycosylation is important for structural and functional properties and plays essential roles in many biological processes. The immense heterogeneity in glycosylation sites and glycan structure poses significant analytical challenges that hinder a mechanistic understanding of the biological role of glycosylation. Without ECCR, average mass determination of glycoprotein complexes is available only through charge detection mass spectrometry or mass photometry. With narrow m/z selection windows followed by ECCR, multiple glycoform m/z values are apparent, providing quick global glycoform profiling and providing a future path for glycan localization on individual intact glycoforms.

Complementary Nanoparticle Characterization by Resistive-Pulse Sensing, Electron Microscopy, and Charge Detection Mass Spectrometry.

Nanotechnology has provided novel modalities for the delivery of therapeutic and diagnostic agents. In particular, nanoparticles (NPs) can be engineered at a low cost for drug loading and delivery. For example, silica NPs have proven useful as a controlled release platform for anti-inflammatory drugs. Despite the wide-ranging potential applications for NPs, robust characterization across all size ranges remains elusive. Electron microscopy (EM) is the conventional tool for measuring NP diameters. However, imitations in throughput and the inability to provide comprehensive information on physical properties, such as mass and density, without underlying assumptions, hinder a complete analysis. In addition, assessing sample heterogeneity, aggregation, or coalescence in solution by traditional EM analysis is not possible. Resistive-pulse sensing (RPS) provides a high throughput, solution-phase method for characterizing particle heterogeneity based on volume. Complementing these methods, charge detection mass spectrometry (CD-MS), a single particle technique, provides accurate mass information for heterogeneous samples including NPs. By combining EM, RPS and CD-MS, accurate volume, mass, and densities were obtained for silica NPs of various sizes. The results show that the density for 20 nm silica NPs is close to the density of fused silica (2.2 g/cm3). Larger silica NPs were found to have densities that were either smaller or larger, while also falling outside the range of densities usually found for silica colloids and NPs (1.9-2.3 g/cm3). Lower densities are attributed to pores (i.e., porous particles). For one sample, the mass distribution showed two components attributed to two populations of particles in the sample with different densities. The synergistic combination of EM, RPS, and CD-MS measurements outlined here for NP samples, allows much more extensive information to be obtained than from any of the techniques alone.

Charge Detection Mass Spectrometry Enables Molecular Characterization of Nucleic Acid Nanoparticles.

Nucleic acid nanoparticles (NANPs) are increasingly used in preclinical investigations as delivery vectors. Tools that can characterize assembly and assess quality will accelerate their development and clinical translation. Standard techniques used to characterize NANPs, like gel electrophoresis, lack the resolution for precise characterization. Here, we introduce the use of charge detection mass spectrometry (CD-MS) to characterize these materials. Using this technique, we determined the mass of NANPs varying in size, shape, and molecular mass, NANPs varying in production quality due to formulations lacking component oligonucleotides, and NANPs functionalized with protein and nucleic acid-based secondary molecules. Based on these demonstrations, CD-MS is a promising tool to precisely characterize NANPs, enabling more precise assessments of the manufacturing and processing of these materials.

Realization of Higher Resolution Charge Detection Mass Spectrometry.

Charge detection mass spectrometry (CD-MS) allows mass distributions to be measured for heterogeneous samples that cannot be analyzed by conventional MS. With CD-MS, the m/z and charge are measured for individual ions using a detection cylinder embedded in an electrostatic linear ion trap (ELIT). Imprecision in both the m/z and charge measurements contribute to the mass resolution. However, if the charge can be measured with a precision of <0.2 e the charge state can be assigned with a low error rate and the mass resolving power only depends on the m/z resolution. Prior to this work, the best resolving power demonstrated experimentally for CD-MS was 700. Here we demonstrate a resolving power of >14,600, 20-times higher than the previous best. Trajectory simulations were used to optimize the geometry and electrostatic potentials of the ELIT. We found conditions where the energy dependence of the oscillation frequency becomes parabolic, and then operated with a nominal ion energy at the minimum of the parabola. The 14,600 resolving power was obtained with a beam collimator before the ELIT. With the collimator removed, the resolving power of the optimized ELIT is 7300, which is still an order of magnitude higher than the previous best. The resolving power was demonstrated by resolving the isotope distributions for peptides and proteins. High resolution CD-MS measurements were then used to resolve the glycans on a monoclonal antibody and applied to the analysis of hepatitis B virus capsids. The results indicate that procedures for adduct removal need to be improved for the full benefit of the higher resolving power to be realized for higher mass species. However, these results represent a key step toward using CD-MS to analyze very complex protein mixtures where charge states are not well resolved in the m/z spectrum because of congestion from numerous overlapping peaks.

Automated Immunoprecipitation, Sample Preparation, and Individual Ion Mass Spectrometry Platform for Proteoforms.

Charge detection mass spectrometry (CDMS) is a well-established technique that provides direct mass spectral outputs regardless of analyte heterogeneity or molecular weight. Over the past few years, it has been demonstrated that CDMS can be multiplexed on Orbitrap analyzers utilizing an integrated approach termed individual ion mass spectrometry (I2MS). To further increase adaptability, robustness, and throughput of this technique, here, we present a method that utilizes numerous integrated equipment components including a Kingfisher system, SampleStream platform, and Q Exactive mass spectrometer to provide a fully automated workflow for immunoprecipitation, sample preparation, injection, and subsequent I2MS acquisition. This automated workflow has been applied to a cohort of 58 test subjects to determine individualized patient antibody responses to SARS-CoV-2 antigens. Results from a range of serum donors include 37 subject I2MS spectra that contained a positive COVID-19 antibody response and 21 I2MS spectra that contained a negative COVID-19 antibody response. This high-throughput automated I2MS workflow can currently process over 100 samples per week and is general for making immunoprecipitation-MS workflows achieve proteoform resolution.

Charge Detection Mass Spectrometry Reveals Favored Structures in the Assembly of Virus-Like Particles: Polymorphism in Norovirus GI.1.

The main capsid protein (CP) of norovirus, the leading cause of gastroenteritis, is expected to self-assemble into virus-like particles with the same structure as the wild-type virus, a capsid with 180 CPs in a T = 3 icosahedron. Using charge detection mass spectrometry (CD-MS), we find that the norovirus GI.1 variant is structurally promiscuous, forming a wide variety of well-defined structures, some that are icosahedral capsids and others that are not. The structures that are present evolve with time and vary with solution conditions. The presence of icosahedral T = 3 and T = 4 capsids (240 CPs) under some conditions was confirmed by cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM). The cryo-EM studies also confirmed the presence of an unexpected prolate geometry based on an elongated T = 4 capsid with 300 CPs. In addition, CD-MS measurements indicate the presence of well-defined peaks with masses corresponding to 420, 480, 600, and 700 CPs. The peak corresponding to 420 CPs is probably due to an icosahedral T = 7 capsid, but this could not be confirmed by cryo-EM. It is possible that the T = 7 particles are too fragile to survive vitrification. There are no mass peaks associated with the T = 9 and T = 12 icosahedra with 540 and 720 CPs. The larger structures with 480, 600, and 700 CPs are not icosahedral; however, their measured charges suggest that they are hollow shells. The use of CD-MS to monitor virus-like particles assembly may have important applications in vaccine development and quality control.

Charge Detection Mass Spectrometry Reveals Conformational Heterogeneity in Megadalton-Sized Monoclonal Antibody Aggregates.

Aggregation of protein-based therapeutics can occur during development, production, or storage and can lead to loss of efficacy and potential toxicity. Native mass spectrometry of a covalently linked pentameric monoclonal antibody complex with a mass of ∼800 kDa reveals several distinct conformations, smaller complexes, and abundant higher-order aggregates of the pentameric species. Charge detection mass spectrometry (CDMS) reveals individual oligomers up to the pentamer mAb trimer (15 individual mAb molecules; ∼2.4 MDa) whereas intermediate aggregates composed of 6-9 mAb molecules and aggregates larger than the pentameric dimer (1.6 MDa) were not detected/resolved by standard mass spectrometry, size exclusion chromatography (SEC), capillary electrophoresis (CE-SDS), or by mass photometry. Conventional quadrupole time-of-flight mass spectrometry (QTOF MS), mass photometry, SEC, and CE-SDS did not resolve partially or more fully unfolded conformations of each oligomer that were readily identified using CDMS by their significantly higher extents of charging. Trends in the charge-state distributions of individual oligomers provides detailed insight into how the structures of compact and elongated mAb aggregates change as a function of aggregate size. These results demonstrate the advantages of CDMS for obtaining accurate masses and information about the conformations of large antibody aggregates despite extensive overlapping m/z values. These results open up the ability to investigate structural changes that occur in small, soluble oligomers during the earliest stages of aggregation for antibodies or other proteins.

Thermal Remodeling of Human HDL Particles Reveals Diverse Subspecies.

High-density lipoproteins (HDL) are micelle-like particles consisting of a core of triglycerides and cholesteryl esters surrounded by a shell of phospholipid, cholesterol, and apolipoproteins. HDL is considered "good" cholesterol, and its concentration in plasma is used clinically in assessing cardiovascular health. However, these particles vary in structure, composition, and therefore function, and thus can be resolved into subpopulations, some of which have specific cardioprotective properties. Mass measurements of HDL by charge detection mass spectrometry (CD-MS) previously revealed seven distinct subpopulations which could be delineated by mass and charge [Lutomski, C. A. et al. Anal. Chem. 2018]. Here, we investigate the thermal stabilities of these subpopulations; upon heating, the particles within each subpopulation undergo structural rearrangements with distinct transition temperatures. In addition, we find evidence for many new families of structures within each subpopulation; at least 15 subspecies of HDL are resolved. These subspecies vary in size, charge, and thermal stability. While this suggests that these new subspecies have unique molecular compositions, we cannot rule out the possibility that we have found evidence for new structural forms within the known subpopulations. The ability to resolve new subspecies of HDL particles may be important in understanding and delineating the role of unique particles in cardiovascular health and disease.

Protein complex heterogeneity and topology revealed by electron capture charge reduction and surface induced dissociation.

We illustrate the utility of native mass spectrometry (nMS) combined with a fast, tunable gas-phase charge reduction, electron capture charge reduction (ECCR), for the characterization of protein complex topology and glycoprotein heterogeneity. ECCR efficiently reduces the charge states of tetradecameric GroEL, illustrating Orbitrap m/z measurements to greater than 100,000 m/z. For pentameric C-reactive protein and tetradecameric GroEL, our novel device combining ECCR with surface induced dissociation (SID) reduces the charge states and yields more topologically informative fragmentation. This is the first demonstration that ECCR yields more native-like SID fragmentation. ECCR also significantly improved mass and glycan heterogeneity measurements of heavily glycosylated SARS-CoV-2 spike protein trimer and thyroglobulin dimer. Protein glycosylation is important for structural and functional properties and plays essential roles in many biological processes. The immense heterogeneity in glycosylation sites and glycan structure poses significant analytical challenges that hinder a mechanistic understanding of the biological role of glycosylation. Without ECCR, average mass determination of glycoprotein complexes is available only through charge detection mass spectrometry or mass photometry. With narrow m/z selection windows followed by ECCR, multiple glycoform m/z values are apparent, providing quick global glycoform profiling and providing a future path for glycan localization on individual intact glycoforms.