Catch-and-release angling is an oft-practiced conservation tool whereby fish are, either as a result of harvest regulations or conservation ethic on the part of the angler, released after capture. Central to this practice is the assumption that release fish survive after capture, however a large body of work has shown that post-release physiological disturbances and mortality can occur, particularly for fish subjected to long handling times out of the water. It is also known that different species may respond differently to the process of capture and handling, however many popular gamefish have not been studied in this context. To address this, we conducted a study on channel catfish Ictalurus punctatus angled from a lake in southern Illinois, USA. Fifty-eight channel catfish were angled using conventional techniques and either treated as a control or subjected to one of four different combinations of holding (0.5 or 4 h) and air exposure (0 or 5 min) time. Catfish were assessed for Reflex Action Mortality Predictors (RAMP) with blood biopsy providing measures of glucose, lactate, hematocrit, alkaline phosphatase activity, and lactate dehydrogenase activity. Results showed that catfish subjected to long air exposure were more likely to show reflex impairment within 0.5 h of capture, however recovery typically occurred by 4 h. Air exposure had no impact on any blood metric in this study, and no post-capture mortality occurred. These results indicate that channel catfish are relatively robust to catch-and-release, however the presence of short-term impairment leads us to recommend that air exposure times be minimized in order to achieve best outcomes for this species.