Cation exchange membranes (CEMs) are an ion exchange polymer which selectively shuttles cations through their structure. CEMs are used for a wide range of electrically driven processes, including electrolysis, fuel cells, and electrodialysis. Historically, fluorinated polymers have been used as CEMs, with the most prevalent being Chemours’ Nafion polymer. These materials and their synthesis can produce harmful, long-lived environmental toxins that may provide challenges to scaling to meet material demand. Therefore, significant research is being directed towards finding non-fluorinated CEMs with similar functionality. One promising candidate has been sulfonated poly-ether-ether-ketone (SPEEK), which has similar ion exchange capabilities as Nafion, while being low cost and non-fluorinated.In electrochemical reactors, the effect of different cations in electrolyte solutions has shown high importance for overall conductivity and can affect reaction selectivity, activity, and durability. The cations which move through the CEM (mobile ions) can interact with the fixed sulfonate functional groups on the polymer backbone. While there is significant research on mobile ion effects on the performance of Nafion1, far less work has been done in this area with SPEEK2. Additionally, there are no direct comparisons between Nafion and any non-fluorinated polymer on how the polymer backbone affects these mobile ion interactions.One method to study CEM-ion interactions is with Raman Spectroscopy, which uses a monochromatic light to initiate and observe Raman scattering from matter. While Raman spectra have been obtained for Nafion, we have not found Raman spectra of SPEEK in the presence of different electrolyte compositions. Here, we use Raman spectroscopy paired with water uptake and conductivity measurements to compare the differences of how a variety of mobile cations (H+, NH4+, Li+, Na+, K+, Rs+, Cs+, Mg2+, Ca2+, Sr2+) interact with the fixed sulfonate functional groups found in Nafion and SPEEK. We report that the two polymers show differences in the strength of the interactions between the mobile ions and fixed groups, which leads to changes in physical properties, including water uptake and conductivity. With these findings, more informed decisions of the applications of fluorinated vs non-fluorinated polymers for various electrochemical purposes can be made.Key
Read full abstract