Reviewed by: Opening Day: The Story of Jackie Robinson’s First Season Steve Treder Jonathan Eig. Opening Day: The Story of Jackie Robinson’s First Season. New York: Simon & Schuster, 2007. 323 pp. Cloth, $26.00. This is a truly great era in which to be a baseball fan. I know, there are plenty of downsides to today's baseball experience. There's the overhyped, oversaturated media coverage; there's the insipid, loud music blaring from ballpark speakers; there's interleague play and the designated hitter; there's too much Joe Buck and Thom Brenneman and too little Jon Miller and Vin Scully; there's the ugly, self-righteous, and spectacularly hypocritical steroids scandal; and, of course, there's Bud Selig. [End Page 121] I know all that. But against all that we have the upsides too. We have players from multiple continents performing at a skill level never matched in history; we have the near-extinction of artificial turf; we have resurgent and prosperous Minor League ball; we have SABR and baseball-reference.com and NINE; and we have an ever-expanding library of great baseball writing, being richly nourished by the work of Jonathan Eig. I think the upsides have it. It used to be the case that popular baseball biographies and histories were written only by "baseball writers," that is, newspaper beat scribes who earned enough seniority and following to snag a book contract. Not that some of these writers and their books weren't first rate, but the candid fact is that most weren't: the great majority of biographies and histories produced by this category of writers were on the shallow side, tending to fawn on their subjects, betraying more of a fan's passion than a scholar's insight. But recent years have provided us with something new. In the 1990s, the late David Halberstam, the hugely famous Pulitzer Prize–winning journalist and author, turned his attention to the subject of baseball in two histories, Summer of '49 and October 1964. In 2006 David Maraniss, a Washington Post editor and highly regarded political reporter (indeed, a Pulitzer winner himself), a biographer of both Bill Clinton and Al Gore, produced Clemente: The Passion and Grace of Baseball's Last Hero, the first worthy biography of Roberto Clemente. All three were popular successes. None was a great book: I found them to be more ambitious in scope than fulfilling in execution. But the fact is that all three were ambitious in scope, certainly more so than the typical, traditional sports book; though flawed in some respects, they were intellectually serious works, transcending the established limits of the genre. Enter Jonathan Eig: the former executive editor of Chicago magazine and a senior writer for the Wall Street Journal, he isn't a "baseball writer" either. Eig ventured into the baseball field in 2005 with his biography of Lou Gehrig, Luckiest Man. That was a terrific piece of scholarship and writing: one might have thought there was nothing new to learn about the legendary "Iron Horse," but through unprecedented access to Gehrig's personal correspondence, Eig taught us a great deal. Eig has followed up that triumph with another. Here again we have a subject that might be seen as played-out: just what hasn't been written about Jackie Robinson? But again Eig has picked up a hard nut and cracked it open with exquisite skill. Essentially, Eig has revealed secrets about this towering figure that were hiding in plain sight. Rather than a full-fledged Robinson biography or a sweeping examination of his place within the broader Civil Rights/U.S. history realms, Eig focuses on the events of the 1947 baseball season itself. [End Page 122] It was, after all, those precise events that unfolded from April through October in 1947—and most critically, those that transpired in the spring, in the first tense and uncertain days of Robinson's introduction to the Major Leagues—upon which hinged all the rest of Robinson's amazing and far-reaching contribution to baseball, to the United States, and to, as Roger Kahn put it in The Boys of Summer, "all the family of man." And for those...
Read full abstract