Natural Rubber (NR) from Hevea brasiliensis tree is an important commercial commodity worldwide. In general, many Hevea cultivars are vulnerable to abnormal leaf fall (ALF) disease caused by Phytophthora spp., which can lead to considerable reduction in crop production. Chemical control of ALF by spraying mineral oil-based copper fungicides is the conventional approach which is harmful to the ecosystem. Development of ALF tolerant varieties of Hevea through conventional breeding is the major objectives of this study. We evaluated the primary agronomy traits and ALF tolerance level of the newly developed Hevea clones using in vitro leaf disc bioassay as well as field screening for disease incidence consecutively for three years. Variation in disease infestation was observed among genotypes. Based on field screening, the clones which showed better field tolerance against ALF than the parental clones were selected. Clone 683 was identified as one of the most desirable genotypes which had vigorous growth as well as high crop yield in addition to ALF tolerance. The study also confirms the reliability of in vitro leaf disc bioassay technique for screening against ALF across genotypes for its inherent variability. This technique is rapid and easier and can be completed within 96 hours. This approach could reduce the burden of screening larger breeding population to a manageable size to enhance the efficiency of selection in ALF disease resistance breeding programs. Selected fast growing, high yielding ALF tolerant clones, could be further evaluated in on farm trials for recommending to the growers in the traditional region of rubber growing tracts.