DNA-templated silver clusters are chromophores in which the nucleobases encode the cluster spectra and brightness. We describe the coordination environments of two nearly identical Ag106+ clusters that form with 18-nucleotide strands CCCCA CCCCT CCCX TTTT, with X = guanosine and inosine. For the first time, femtosecond time-resolved infrared (TRIR) spectroscopy with visible excitation and mid-infrared probing is used to correlate the response of nucleobase vibrational modes to electronic excitation of the metal cluster. A rich pattern of transient TRIR peaks in the 1400-1720 cm-1 range decays synchronously with the visible emission. Specific infrared signatures associated with the single guanosine/inosine along with a subset of cytidines, but not the thymidines, are observed. These fingerprints suggest that the network of bonds between a silver cluster adduct and its polydentate DNA ligands can be deciphered to rationally tune the coordination and thus spectra of molecular silver chromophores.