In the present study, the usability of semiempirical quantum mechanical methods for calculating bond dissociation energy (BDE) was investigated systematically. Density functional theory (DFT) methods with the B3LYP and B97-1 functionals were used for comparison. We introduced a new test set for BDE, called BDE200, which covers a wide range of compounds including large aromatic compounds. The use of BDE200 test set revealed that the accuracy of the methods studied was ordered from best to worst as: B97-1 > B3LYP > rPM6 >> PM7 > PM6 > AM1 > PM3. In addition to the improved accuracy of rPM6 for predicting BDE, it was found that rPM6 can provide a quantitative correlation between BDE values and reactivity. The rPM6 calculated activation enthalpies for C–H hydroxylation catalysed by the compound I of cytochrome P450 were proportional to the calculated and experimental C–H BDE values, in line with the results of previous DFT studies. We believe that rPM6 can help develop a database, for instance, for the determination of site of metabolism.
Read full abstract