Plastic wastes have caused serious environmental issues worldwide, and thus viable solutions for their replacement are now urgently needed. This work aimed to develop biocomposite materials based on polyethylene (PE) wastes as matrix reinforced with coconut fiber, without any additional chemical treatments, using extrusion and compression molding. The effects of polymer matrix type (high-density and low-density PE (HDPE and LDPE)) and fiber loading (5-15 wt%) on the mechanical properties and long-term water absorption behaviour of the materials were evaluated. Tensile strength results showed the optimum performance at 5 wt% fiber – of 16.6 MPa for the HDPE matrix and 7.3 MPa for the LDPE matrix, but flexural and impact strengths reduced with the fiber loading. An increasing trend of water absorption capacity was noted as a function of filler loading and of the water temperature during immersion, with a weight gain of up to 5%, following the trend: cold water > room temperature tap water > hot water. From the results, HDPE based biocomposites had better mechanical performance and lower water absorption capacity, compared with LDPE based biocomposites.