During a heart attack, ischemia causes losses of billions of cells; this is especially concerning given the minimal regenerative capability of cardiomyocytes (CMs). Heart remuscularization utilizing stem cells has improved cardiac outcomes despite little cell engraftment, thereby shifting focus to cell-free therapies. Consequently, we chose induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs) given their pluripotent nature, efficacy in previous studies, and easy obtainability from minimally invasive techniques. Nonetheless, using iPSC secretome-based therapies for treating injured CMs in a clinical setting is ill-understood. We hypothesized that the iPSC secretome, regardless of donor health, would improve cardiovascular outcomes in the CM model of ischemia–reperfusion (IR) injury. Episomal-generated iPSCs from healthy and dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) donors, passaged 6–10 times, underwent 24 h incubation in serum-free media. Protein content of the secretome was analyzed by mass spectroscopy and used to treat AC16 immortalized CMs during 5 h reperfusion following 24 h of hypoxia. IPSC-derived secretome content, independent of donor health status, had elevated expression of proteins involved in cell survival pathways. In IR conditions, iPSC-derived secretome increased cell survival as measured by metabolic activity (p < 0.05), cell viability (p < 0.001), and maladaptive cellular remodelling (p = 0.052). Healthy donor-derived secretome contained increased expression of proteins related to calcium contractility compared to DCM donors. Congruently, only healthy donor-derived secretomes improved CM intracellular calcium concentrations (p < 0.01). Heretofore, secretome studies mainly investigated differences relating to cell type rather than donor health. Our work suggests that healthy donors provide more efficacious iPSC-derived secretome compared to DCM donors in the context of IR injury in human CMs. These findings illustrate that the regenerative potential of the iPSC secretome varies due to donor-specific differences.