Abstract Although intense tropical cyclones (TCs) are considered to be axisymmetric vortices, observations reveal that they are often highly asymmetric. Better understanding of the underlying asymmetric dynamics is a critical step toward advancing TC intensity forecasting. In this paper, we revisit the mechanisms behind one of the most frequent asymmetric patterns: the deformation of the core into an elliptical shape. Previously, elliptical eyewalls were primarily thought to be an outcome of barotropic instability, a mechanism that involves the coupling and mutual growth of counterpropagating vortex Rossby (VR) waves. These results were largely based on simplified numerical models that filter out inertia–gravity (IG) waves. Consideration of IG waves introduces the possibility of an additional instability mechanism, one that involves a VR wave that spontaneously emits a spiral IG wave into the environment. We provide evidence that elliptical eyewalls, which may form within a three-dimensional primitive-equation nonlinear model that supports both instability types, can solely originate by the mechanism of spontaneous radiative imbalance. These evidences are supported by a number of nonlinear simulations, supplemental linear eigenmode analysis, and a linear simulation. The potential role of a multimechanistic instability is also briefly addressed.