Bacterial DNA Ligase Research Articles

Identification of Novel Inhibitors of Escherichia coli DNA Ligase (LigA).

Present in all organisms, DNA ligases catalyse the formation of a phosphodiester bond between a 3′ hydroxyl and a 5′ phosphate, a reaction that is essential for maintaining genome integrity during replication and repair. Eubacterial DNA ligases use NAD+ as a cofactor and possess low sequence and structural homology relative to eukaryotic DNA ligases which use ATP as a cofactor. These key differences enable specific targeting of bacterial DNA ligases as an antibacterial strategy. In this study, four small molecule accessible sites within functionally important regions of Escherichia coli ligase (EC-LigA) were identified using in silico methods. Molecular docking was then used to screen for small molecules predicted to bind to these sites. Eight candidate inhibitors were then screened for inhibitory activity in an in vitro ligase assay. Five of these (geneticin, chlorhexidine, glutathione (reduced), imidazolidinyl urea and 2-(aminomethyl)imidazole) showed dose-dependent inhibition of EC-LigA with half maximal inhibitory concentrations (IC50) in the micromolar to millimolar range (11–2600 µM). Two (geneticin and chlorhexidine) were predicted to bind to a region of EC-LigA that has not been directly investigated previously, raising the possibility that there may be amino acids within this region that are important for EC-LigA activity or that the function of essential residues proximal to this region are impacted by inhibitor interactions with this region. We anticipate that the identified small molecule binding sites and inhibitors could be pursued as part of an antibacterial strategy targeting bacterial DNA ligases.

Antimicrobial Activity of Substituted Benzopentathiepin-6-amines

A number of substituted benzopentathiepin-6-amines and their analogues without a polysulfur ring were synthesized and evaluated in vitro for antimicrobial activity against a panel of reference bacterial and fungal strains. Trifluoroacetamide 14 demonstrated high antibacterial activity against Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA strain) with a MIC of 4 μg/mL, which was four-fold higher than the activity of a reference drug amoxicillin. This compound was also most active against the Candida albicans fungus (MIC of 1 μg ml-1), whereas amide 17 containing a morpholine substituent was most active against the Cryptococcus neoformans fungus (MIC of 2 μg ml-1). These compounds have no hemolytic activity and are low cytotoxic. Replacement of the pentathiepine ring with 1,3-dithiolan-2-one or 1,3-dithiolane moieties leads to loss of antimicrobial activity. Based on the QSAR analysis and molecular docking data, bacterial DNA ligase might be one of the targets for the antibacterial activity of substituted benzopentathiepin-6-amines against S. aureus.

Structures of ATP-bound DNA ligase D in a closed domain conformation reveal a network of amino acid and metal contacts to the ATP phosphates

DNA ligases are the sine qua non of genome integrity and essential for DNA replication and repair in all organisms. DNA ligases join 3'-OH and 5'-PO4 ends via a series of three nucleotidyl transfer steps. In step 1, ligase reacts with ATP or NAD+ to form a covalent ligase-(lysyl-Nζ)-AMP intermediate and release pyrophosphate (PPi) or nicotinamide mononucleotide. In step 2, AMP is transferred from ligase-adenylate to the 5'-PO4 DNA end to form a DNA-adenylate intermediate (AppDNA). In step 3, ligase catalyzes attack by a DNA 3'-OH on the DNA-adenylate to seal the two ends via a phosphodiester bond and release AMP. Eukaryal, archaeal, and many bacterial and viral DNA ligases are ATP-dependent. The catalytic core of ATP-dependent DNA ligases consists of an N-terminal nucleotidyltransferase domain fused to a C-terminal OB domain. Here we report crystal structures at 1.4-1.8 Å resolution of Mycobacterium tuberculosis LigD, an ATP-dependent DNA ligase dedicated to nonhomologous end joining, in complexes with ATP that highlight large movements of the OB domain (∼50 Å), from a closed conformation in the ATP complex to an open conformation in the covalent ligase-AMP intermediate. The LigD·ATP structures revealed a network of amino acid contacts to the ATP phosphates that stabilize the transition state and orient the PPi leaving group. A complex with ATP and magnesium suggested a two-metal mechanism of lysine adenylylation driven by a catalytic Mg2+ that engages the ATP α phosphate and a second metal that bridges the ATP β and γ phosphates.

SiRNA Delivery Using a Cationic-Lipid-Based Highly Selective Human DNA Ligase I Inhibitor.

The present article illustrates the serendipitous discovery of a cationic-lipid-based human DNA ligase (hLig) I inhibitor and the development of siRNA delivering, a hLigI-targeted cationic-lipid-based nonviral vector. We have tested a small in-house library of structurally similar cationic lipo-anisamides for antiligase activity, and amongst tested, N-dodecyl-N-(2-(4-methoxybenzamido)ethyl)-N-methyldodecan-1-ammonium iodide (C12M) selectively and efficiently inhibited the enzyme activity of hLigI, compared to other human ligases (hLigIIIβ and hLigIV/XRCC4) and bacterial T4 DNA ligase. Furthermore, upon hydration with equimolar cholesterol, C12M produced antiligase cationic liposomes, which transfected survivin siRNA and showed significant inhibition of tumor growth.

Analysis of the distribution and evolution of the ATP-dependent DNA ligases of bacteria delineates a distinct phylogenetic group 'Lig E'.

Prior to the discovery of a minimal ATP-dependent DNA ligase in Haemophilus influenzae, bacteria were thought to only possess a NAD-dependent ligase, which was involved in sealing of Okazaki fragments. We now know that a diverse range of bacterial species possess up to six of these accessory bacterial ATP-dependent DNA ligases (b-ADLs), which vary in size and enzymatic domain associations. Here we compare the domain structure of different types of b-ADLs and investigate their distribution among the bacterial domain to describe possible evolutionary trajectories that gave rise to the sequence and structural diversity of these enzymes. Previous biochemical and genetic analyses have delineated three main classes of these enzymes: Lig B, Lig C and Lig D, which appear to have descended from a common ancestor within the bacterial domain. In the present study, we delineate a fourth group of b-ADLs, Lig E, which possesses a number of unique features at the primary and tertiary structural levels. The biochemical characteristics, domain structure and inferred extracellular location sets this group apart from the other b-ADLs. The results presented here indicate that the Lig E type ligases were horizontally transferred into bacteria in a separate event from other b-ADLs possibly from a bacteriophage.

Base-modified NAD and AMP derivatives and their activity against bacterial DNA ligases.

We report the chemical synthesis and conformational analysis of a collection of 2-, 6- and 8-substituted derivatives of β-NAD(+) and AMP, and their biochemical evaluation against NAD(+)-dependent DNA ligases from Escherichia coli and Mycobacterium tuberculosis. Bacterial DNA ligases are validated anti-microbial targets, and new strategies for their inhibition are therefore of considerable scientific and practical interest. Our study includes several pairs of β-NAD(+) and AMP derivatives with the same substitution pattern at the adenine base. This has enabled the first direct comparison of co-substrate and inhibitor behaviour against bacterial DNA ligases. Our results suggest that an additional substituent in position 6 or 8 of the adenine base in β-NAD(+) is detrimental for activity as either co-substrate or inhibitor. In contrast, substituents in position 2 are not only tolerated, but appear to give rise to a new mode of inhibition, which targets the conformational changes these DNA ligases undergo during catalysis. Using a molecular modelling approach, we highlight that these findings have important implications for our understanding of ligase mechanism and inhibition, and may provide a promising starting point for the rational design of a new class of inhibitors against NAD(+)-dependent DNA ligases.

Tricyclic dihydrobenzoxazepine and tetracyclic indole derivatives can specifically target bacterial DNA ligases and can distinguish them from human DNA ligase I.

DNA ligases are critical components for DNA metabolism in all organisms. NAD(+)-dependent DNA ligases (LigA) found exclusively in bacteria and certain entomopoxviruses are drawing increasing attention as therapeutic targets as they differ in their cofactor requirement from ATP-dependent eukaryotic homologs. Due to the similarities in the cofactor binding sites of the two classes of DNA ligases, it is necessary to find determinants that can distinguish between them for the exploitation of LigA as an anti-bacterial target. In the present endeavour, we have synthesized and evaluated a series of tricyclic dihydrobenzoxazepine and tetracyclic indole derivatives for their ability to distinguish between bacterial and human DNA ligases. The in vivo inhibition assays that employed LigA deficient E. coli GR501 and S. typhimurium LT2 bacterial strains, rescued by ATP-dependent T4 DNA ligase or Mycobacterium tuberculosis NAD(+)-dependent DNA ligase (Mtb LigA), respectively, showed that the compounds can specifically inhibit bacterial LigA. The in vitro enzyme inhibition assays using purified MtbLigA, human DNA ligase I & T4 DNA ligase showed specific inhibition of MtbLigA at low micromolar range. Our results demonstrate that tricyclic dihydrobenzoxazepine and tetracyclic indole derivatives can distinguish between bacterial and human DNA ligases by ∼5-folds. In silico docking and enzyme inhibition assays identified that the compounds bind to the cofactor binding site and compete with the cofactor. Ethidium bromide displacement and gel-shift assays showed that the inhibitors do not exhibit any unwanted general interactions with the substrate DNA. These results set the stage for the detailed exploration of this compound class for development as antibacterials.

Enzyme-adenylate structure of a bacterial ATP-dependent DNA ligase with a minimized DNA-binding surface.

DNA ligases are a structurally diverse class of enzymes which share a common catalytic core and seal breaks in the phosphodiester backbone of double-stranded DNA via an adenylated intermediate. Here, the structure and activity of a recombinantly produced ATP-dependent DNA ligase from the bacterium Psychromonas sp. strain SP041 is described. This minimal-type ligase, like its close homologues, is able to ligate singly nicked double-stranded DNA with high efficiency and to join cohesive-ended and blunt-ended substrates to a more limited extent. The 1.65 Å resolution crystal structure of the enzyme-adenylate complex reveals no unstructured loops or segments, and suggests that this enzyme binds the DNA without requiring full encirclement of the DNA duplex. This is in contrast to previously characterized minimal DNA ligases from viruses, which use flexible loop regions for DNA interaction. The Psychromonas sp. enzyme is the first structure available for the minimal type of bacterial DNA ligases and is the smallest DNA ligase to be crystallized to date.

Fragment-based discovery of 6-azaindazoles as inhibitors of bacterial DNA ligase.

Herein we describe the application of fragment-based drug design to bacterial DNA ligase. X-ray crystallography was used to guide structure-based optimization of a fragment-screening hit to give novel, nanomolar, AMP-competitive inhibitors. The lead compound 13 showed antibacterial activity across a range of pathogens. Data to demonstrate mode of action was provided using a strain of S. aureus, engineered to overexpress DNA ligase.

Characterization of Mycobacterium smegmatis PolD2 and PolD1 as RNA/DNA Polymerases Homologous to the POL Domain of Bacterial DNA Ligase D

Mycobacteria exploit nonhomologous end-joining (NHEJ) to repair DNA double-strand breaks. The core NHEJ machinery comprises the homodimeric DNA end-binding protein Ku and DNA ligase D (LigD), a modular enzyme composed of a C-terminal ATP-dependent ligase domain (LIG), a central 3'-phosphoesterase domain (PE), and an N-terminal polymerase domain (POL). LigD POL is proficient at adding templated and nontemplated deoxynucleotides and ribonucleotides to DNA ends in vitro and is the catalyst in vivo of unfaithful NHEJ events involving nontemplated single-nucleotide additions to blunt DSB ends. Here, we identify two mycobacterial proteins, PolD1 and PolD2, as stand-alone homologues of the LigD POL domain. Biochemical characterization of PolD1 and PolD2 shows that they resemble LigD POL in their monomeric quaternary structures, their ability to add templated and nontemplated nucleotides to primer-templates and blunt ends, and their preference for rNTPs versus dNTPs. Deletion of polD1, polD2, or both from a Mycobacterium smegmatis strain carrying an inactivating mutation in LigD POL failed to reveal a role for PolD1 or PolD2 in templated nucleotide additions during NHEJ of 5'-overhang DSBs or in clastogen resistance. Whereas our results document the existence and characteristics of new stand-alone members of the LigD POL family of RNA/DNA polymerases, they imply that other polymerases can perform fill-in synthesis during mycobacterial NHEJ.

Chromosome demise in the wake of ligase‐deficient replication

Bacterial DNA ligases, NAD⁺-dependent enzymes, are distinct from eukaryotic ATP-dependent ligases, representing promising targets for broad-spectrum antimicrobials. Yet, the chromosomal consequences of ligase-deficient DNA replication, during which Okazaki fragments accumulate, are still unclear. Using ligA251(Ts), the strongest ligase mutant of Escherichia coli, we studied ligase-deficient DNA replication by genetic and physical approaches. Here we show that replication without ligase kills after a short resistance period. We found that double-strand break repair via RecA, RecBCD, RuvABC and RecG explains the transient resistance, whereas irreparable chromosomal fragmentation explains subsequent cell death. Remarkably, death is mostly prevented by elimination of linear DNA degradation activity of ExoV, suggesting that non-allelic double-strand breaks behind replication forks precipitate DNA degradation that enlarge them into allelic double-strand gaps. Marker frequency profiling of synchronized replication reveals stalling of ligase-deficient forks with subsequent degradation of the DNA synthesized without ligase. The mechanism that converts unsealed nicks behind replication forks first into repairable double-strand breaks and then into irreparable double-strand gaps may be behind lethality of any DNA damaging treatment.

Structure Guided Understanding of NAD+ Recognition in Bacterial DNA Ligases

NAD(+)-dependent DNA ligases (LigA) are essential bacterial enzymes that catalyze phosphodiester bond formation during DNA replication and repair processes. Phosphodiester bond formation proceeds through a 3-step reaction mechanism. In the first step, the LigA adenylation domain interacts with NAD(+) to form a covalent enzyme-AMP complex. Although it is well established that the specificity for binding of NAD(+) resides within the adenylation domain, the precise recognition elements for the initial binding event remain unclear. We report here the structure of the adenylation domain from Haemophilus influenzae LigA. This structure is a first snapshot of a LigA-AMP intermediate with NAD(+) bound to domain 1a in its open conformation. The binding affinities of NAD(+) for adenylated and nonadenylated forms of the H. influenzae LigA adenylation domain were similar. The combined crystallographic and NAD(+)-binding data suggest that the initial recognition of NAD(+) is via the NMN binding region in domain 1a of LigA.

Virtual screening of specific chemical compounds by exploring E.coli NAD+-dependent DNA ligase as a target for antibacterial drug discovery

Unique substrate specificity compared with ATP-dependent human DNA ligases recommends E.coli NAD(+)-ligases as potential targets. A plausible strategy is to identify the structural components of bacterial DNA ligase that interact with NAD(+) and then to isolate small molecules that recognize these components and thereby block the binding of NAD(+) to the ligase. This work describes a molecular modeling approach to detect the 3D structure of NAD(+)-dependent DNA ligase in E. coli whose partial structure was determined by wet lab experiments and rest structure was left as such on the road for repairment. We applied protein-drug docking approach to detect the binding affinity of this enzyme with Quinacrine and some of its virtual derivatives. In silico docking results predict that the virtual derivative of Quinacrine (C21H26ClN3O2) has greater binding affinity than Quinacrine. Drug likeness value of 0.833 was observed for this derivative without showing any toxicity risk.

Structure of the adenylation domain of NAD+-dependent DNA ligase fromStaphylococcus aureus

DNA ligase catalyzes phosphodiester-bond formation between immediately adjacent 5'-phosphate and 3'-hydroxyl groups in double-stranded DNA and plays a central role in many cellular and biochemical processes, including DNA replication, repair and recombination. Bacterial NAD(+)-dependent DNA ligases have been extensively characterized as potential antibacterial targets because of their essentiality and their structural distinction from human ATP-dependent DNA ligases. The high-resolution structure of the adenylation domain of Staphylococcus aureus NAD(+)-dependent DNA ligase establishes the conserved domain architecture with other bacterial adenylation domains. Two apo crystal structures revealed that the active site possesses the preformed NAD(+)-binding pocket and the 'C2 tunnel' lined with hydrophobic residues: Leu80, Phe224, Leu287, Phe295 and Trp302. The C2 tunnel is unique to bacterial DNA ligases and the Leu80 side chain at the mouth of the tunnel points inside the tunnel and forms a narrow funnel in the S. aureus DNA ligase structure. Taken together with other DNA ligase structures, the S. aureus DNA ligase structure provides a basis for a more integrated understanding of substrate recognition and catalysis and will be also be of help in the development of small-molecule inhibitors.

Microbial NAD metabolism: lessons from comparative genomics.

NAD is a coenzyme for redox reactions and a substrate of NAD-consuming enzymes, including ADP-ribose transferases, Sir2-related protein lysine deacetylases, and bacterial DNA ligases. Microorganisms that synthesize NAD from as few as one to as many as five of the six identified biosynthetic precursors have been identified. De novo NAD synthesis from aspartate or tryptophan is neither universal nor strictly aerobic. Salvage NAD synthesis from nicotinamide, nicotinic acid, nicotinamide riboside, and nicotinic acid riboside occurs via modules of different genes. Nicotinamide salvage genes nadV and pncA, found in distinct bacteria, appear to have spread throughout the tree of life via horizontal gene transfer. Biochemical, genetic, and genomic analyses have advanced to the point at which the precursors and pathways utilized by a microorganism can be predicted. Challenges remain in dissecting regulation of pathways.

DNA Ligases: Progress and Prospects

DNA ligases seal 5'-PO4 and 3'-OH polynucleotide ends via three nucleotidyl transfer steps involving ligase-adenylate and DNA-adenylate intermediates. DNA ligases are essential guardians of genomic integrity, and ligase dysfunction underlies human genetic disease syndromes. Crystal structures of DNA ligases bound to nucleotide and nucleic acid substrates have illuminated how ligase reaction chemistry is catalyzed, how ligases recognize damaged DNA ends, and how protein domain movements and active-site remodeling are used to choreograph the end-joining pathway. Although a shared feature of DNA ligases is their envelopment of the nicked duplex as a C-shaped protein clamp, they accomplish this feat by using remarkably different accessory structural modules and domain topologies. As structural, biochemical, and phylogenetic insights coalesce, we can expect advances on several fronts, including (i) pharmacological targeting of ligases for antibacterial and anticancer therapies and (ii) the discovery and design of new strand-sealing enzymes with unique substrate specificities.

DNA ligases from thermophilic bacteria enhance PCR amplification of long DNA sequences

Bacterial NAD-dependent Taq and Tth DNA ligases are capable of significantly increasing the yield of long PCR products when the amplification is carried out using bacterial family A DNA polymerases, e.g. Taq or Tth DNA polymerases, or with enzymatic blends containing these polymerases. We also show that Taq and Tth DNA ligases improve the results of PCR in the absence of NAD and therefore in the absence of DNA ligase activity. These observations suggest that bacterial DNA ligases can interact with these DNA polymerases, presumably as accessory proteins, thereby enhancing the efficiency of DNA polymerization.

Identification and characterization of an inhibitor specific to bacterial NAD+‐dependent DNA ligases

DNA ligases are the enzymes essential for DNA replication, repair and recombination in all organisms. The bacterial DNA ligases involved in DNA replication require NAD(+) for activity, but eukaryotic and viral DNA ligases require ATP. Because of their essential nature, unique structures and widespread existence in nature, bacterial DNA ligases represent a class of valuable targets for identifying novel and selective antibacterial agents. In this study, we cloned and expressed the ligA gene from Streptococcus pneumoniae, and characterized this ligA-encoded NAD(+)-dependent DNA ligase. We then screened small molecule chemical libraries using a biochemical assay and identified a new small molecule with a structure of 2,4-diamino-7-dimethylamino-pyrimido[4,5-d]pyrimidine. We show that this small molecule is a specific inhibitor of bacterial NAD(+)-dependent DNA ligases. Biochemical studies show that this molecule inhibits NAD(+)-dependent DNA ligases, but not ATP-dependent enzymes. The molecule inhibits NAD(+)-dependent DNA ligases competitively with respect to NAD(+) and specifically inhibits enzyme adenylation, but not DNA adenylation or ligation. Labeling studies establish that this molecule inhibits the incorporation of thymidine into DNA and that overexpression of DNA ligase in the cell abolishes this inhibition. Finally, microbiological studies show that this molecule exhibits a broad spectrum of antibacterial activity. Together, this study shows that this small molecule inhibitor identified is specific to bacterial NAD(+)-dependent DNA ligases, exhibits a broad spectrum of antibacterial activities, and has the potential to be developed into an antibacterial agent.

Bacterial Nonhomologous End Joining Ligases Preferentially Seal Breaks with a 3′-OH Monoribonucleotide

Many bacterial species have a nonhomologous end joining system of DNA repair driven by dedicated DNA ligases (LigD and LigC). LigD is a multifunctional enzyme composed of a ligase domain fused to two other catalytic modules: a polymerase that preferentially adds ribonucleotides to double-strand break ends and a phosphoesterase that trims 3'-oligoribonucleotide tracts until only a single 3'-ribonucleotide remains. LigD and LigC have a feeble capacity to seal 3'-OH/5'-PO(4) DNA nicks. Here, we report that nick sealing by LigD and LigC enzymes is stimulated by the presence of a single ribonucleotide at the broken 3'-OH end. The ribonucleotide effect on LigD and LigC is specific for the 3'-terminal nucleotide and is either diminished or abolished when additional vicinal ribonucleotides are present. No such 3'-ribonucleotide effect is observed for bacterial LigA or Chlorella virus ligase. We found that in vitro repair of a double-strand break by Pseudomonas LigD requires the polymerase module and results in incorporation of an alkali-labile ribonucleotide at the repair junction. These results illuminate an underlying logic for the domain organization of LigD, whereby the polymerase and phosphoesterase domains can heal the broken 3'-end to generate the monoribonucleotide terminus favored by the nonhomologous end joining ligases.

Mutational Analysis of Bacterial NAD<sup>+</sup>-dependent DNA Ligase: Role of Motif IV in Ligation Catalysis

The bacterial DNA ligase as a multiple domain protein is involved in DNA replication, repair and recombination. Its catalysis of ligation can be divided into three steps. To delineate the roles of amino acid residues in motif IV in ligation catalysis, site-directed mutants were constructed in a bacterial NAD+-dependent DNA ligase from Thermus sp. TAK16D. It was shown that four conserved residues (D286, G287, V289 and K291) in motif IV had significant roles on the overall ligation. Under single turnover conditions, the observed apparent rates of D286E, G287A, V289I and K291R mutants were clearly reduced compared with that of WT ligase on both match and mismatch nicked substrates. The effects of D286E mutation on overall ligation may not only be ascribed to the third step. The G287A mutation has a major effect on the second step. The effects of V289I and K291R mutation on overall ligation are not on the third step, perhaps other aspects, such as conformation change of ligase protein in ligation catalysis, are involved. Moreover, the amino acid substitutions of above four residues were more sensitive on mismatch nicked substrate, indicating an enhanced ligation fidelity.