Transhiatal esophagectomy without thoracotomy has been performed in 143 patients: 43 with benign disease and 100 with carcinomas at various levels of the esophagus (31 cervicothoracic, five upper third, 33 middle third, and 31 distal third). Esophageal resection and reconstruction were performed in a single stage in 138 patients, and the esophageal substitute was positioned in the posterior mediastinum in the original esophageal bed in 134 patients. Stomach was used to replace the esophagus in 128 patients (93%) and colon in 10 patients. The operative mortality has been 8%, the causes of death being myocardial infarction (three), respiratory insufficiency (three), innominate artery rupture (two), sepsis from mediastinal or retroperitoneal abscess (two), and pulmonary embolus (one). No death was the direct result of the technique of esophagectomy. Complications included intraoperative pneumothorax (51%), transient hoarseness (37%), anastomotic leak (12%), chylothorax (3%), and tracheal laceration (1%). Average intraoperative blood loss for the entire group has been 1,150 ml, 1,800 ml for those requiring concomitant laryngectomy and 900 ml for those undergoing esophagectomy without laryngectomy. Of 63 patients surviving resection of intrathoracic esophageal carcinomas, 86% were discharged, able to swallow, within 3 weeks of operation. Distant lymph node metastases or local tumor invasion precluded a curative resection in 70% of our patients with carcinoma, and the overall average duration of survival has been only 12.5 months. However, of 15 surviving patients with intrathoracic esophageal carcinoma who had “curative” resections, 10 are alive and tumor free from 8 to 60 months (average 31 months) postoperatively. A thoracic incision is seldom required to resect the esophagus for either benign or malignant disease. Transhiatal esophagectomy without thoracotomy is a safe, well-tolerated operation, the “hazards” of which can be minimized by careful technique and experience.
Read full abstract