Atomic Force Microscopy-based Single-molecule Force Spectroscopy Research Articles

Cardiac desmosomal adhesion relies on ideal-, slip- and catch bonds

The cardiac muscle consists of individual cardiomyocytes that are mechanically linked by desmosomes. Desmosomal adhesion is mediated by densely packed and organized cadherins which, in presence of Ca2+, stretch out their extracellular domains (EC) and dimerize with opposing binding partners by exchanging an N-terminal tryptophan. The strand-swap binding motif of cardiac cadherins like desmocollin 2 (Dsc2) (and desmoglein2 alike) is highly specific but of low affinity with average bond lifetimes in the range of approximately 0.3 s. Notably, despite this comparatively weak interaction, desmosomes mediate a stable, tensile-resistant bond. In addition, force mediated dissociation of strand-swap dimers exhibit a reduced bond lifetime as external forces increase (slip bond). Using atomic force microscopy based single molecule force spectroscopy (AFM-SMFS), we demonstrate that Dsc2 has two further binding modes that, in addition to strand-swap dimers, most likely play a significant role in the integrity of the cardiac muscle. At short interaction times, the Dsc2 monomers associate only loosely, as can be seen from short-lived force-independent bonds. These ideal bonds are a precursor state and probably stabilize the formation of the self-inhibiting strand-swap dimer. The addition of tryptophan in the measurement buffer acts as a competitive inhibitor, preventing the N-terminal strand exchange. Here, Dsc2 dimerizes as X-dimer which clearly shows a tri-phasic slip-catch-slip type of dissociation. Within the force-mediated transition (catch) regime, Dsc2 dimers switch between a rather brittle low force and a strengthened high force adhesion state. As a result, we can assume that desmosomal adhesion is mediated not only by strand-swap dimers (slip) but also by their precursor states (ideal bond) and force-activated X-dimers (catch bond).

S373P Mutation Stabilizes the Receptor-Binding Domain of the Spike Protein in Omicron and Promotes Binding.

A cluster of several newly occurring mutations on Omicron is found at the β-core region of the spike protein's receptor-binding domain (RBD), where mutation rarely happened before. Notably, the binding of SARS-CoV-2 to human receptor ACE2 via RBD happens in a dynamic airway environment, where mechanical force caused by coughing or sneezing occurs. Thus, we used atomic force microscopy-based single-molecule force spectroscopy (AFM-SMFS) to measure the stability of RBDs and found that the mechanical stability of Omicron RBD increased by ∼20% compared with the wild type. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations revealed that Omicron RBD showed more hydrogen bonds in the β-core region due to the closing of the α-helical motif caused primarily by the S373P mutation. In addition to a higher unfolding force, we showed a higher dissociation force between Omicron RBD and ACE2. This work reveals the mechanically stabilizing effect of the conserved mutation S373P for Omicron and the possible evolution trend of the β-core region of RBD.

Effect of the Competing Ligand on Ni-NTA/Histag Strength Revealed by Click Chemistry-Based Force Spectroscopy.

The specific interaction between Ni-nitrilotriacetic acid and the six-histidine tag may be one of the most important coordination bonds utilized in biological research because of its wide application for recombinant protein purification. The complex stability is critical for target protein binding. Thus, measurement of the mechanical stability of the system was attempted soon after the invention of atomic force microscopy-based single-molecule force spectroscopy (AFM-SMFS) two decades ago. Moreover, the competing ligand imidazole and protons are the two critical factors for target protein elution. However, the mechanochemistry between the system and the imidazole/proton has not been determined. Here, an AFM-SMFS system using strain-promoted alkyne-azide cycloaddition and Cu-free click chemistry was used to characterize the system. Consequently, the destabilizing effect of the imidazole and proton on the interaction was revealed quantitatively, leading to a 3-fold increase in the bond dissociation rate.

PH-Dependent PdS3 Site in α3DIV Revealed by Single-Molecule Force Spectroscopy.

Lead is a toxic metal harmful to human beings because of its long history and wide use in human society. The interaction of lead with proteins is one of the most common ways it exerts toxicity. Due to its thiophilic property, lead targets thiol-rich proteins with high affinity and forms stable Pb-S bonds, which may replace the originally bound metal ion and incapacitate the protein/enzyme. Thus, the knowledge of the Pb-S bonds in proteins is important. To study Pb-S bonds, we chose a de novo designed protein α3DIV, able to bind Pb(II) via its three cysteines, as the model protein. Using atomic force microscopy-based single-molecule force spectroscopy (AFM-SMFS), we proved the formation of a triangular pyramidal PbS3 site in α3DIV by detecting specific Pb-S bond rupture signals, including the previously undetected Pb-S(Cys67) bond. Moreover, the pH-dependent weakening of Pb-S bond strength was revealed and quantified, leading to the dissociation of the PbS3 site at pH 4.5.

Increasing the Mechanical Stability of Polymer-Gold Interfacial Connection: A Parallel Covalent Strategy.

Thiol-gold (S-Au) chemistry has been widely used in coating and functionalizing gold surfaces because it is robust and highly efficient. However, recent studies have shown that the S-Au-based self-assembled monolayers can lead to significant instability under external mechanical loading (e.g., in a swelled polymer film). Such instability limits further applications of S-Au chemistry-based functional materials. Here, we report a surface-modifying procedure based on a parallel covalent strategy. By employing dendritic macromolecules as a "middle layer" between the gold surface and polymer, the interfacial connecting strength increased by at least 350% as revealed by atomic force microscopy-based single molecule force spectroscopy (AFM-SMFS). The ultimate cleavage structure is confirmed to be an amide bond by control SMFS experiments, fluorescent microscopy, and dynamic force spectroscopy. This study/concept paves the way to prepare stable stimuli-responsive polymer brushes on solid surfaces and study mechanophores with high force stability.

Discrimination between cyclic-nucleotides by cyclic-nucleotide gated ion channels.

Cyclic-nucleotide-gated (CNG) ion channels play important roles throughout the entire nervous system, particularly in the signal transduction of the retina and olfactory system. They are regulated by the cyclic nucleotides cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP) and cyclic guanosine monophosphate (cGMP). These two chemically very similar molecules bind to a specialized intracellular domain called the cyclic nucleotide-binding domain (CNBD). CNG channels are key in translating the chemical signal of the second messenger molecules cAMP and cGMP into an electrical response by inducing a conformational change in the CNBD that modulates the opening of the channel gate in the pore domain allowing the flow of ions across cell membranes. Functional measurements have shown that, in SthK (a prokaryotic homolog with high sequence and structural similarities to CNG channels), cGMP barely leads to pore opening while cAMP activates the channel. Here we address the question of how the CNBD can finely discriminate between the two chemically and structurally very similar ligands. Using a combination of atomic force microscopy-based single-molecule force spectroscopy (AFM-SMFS), and force probe molecular dynamics simulations, we elucidate, quantitatively and at the atomic level, the mechanism of CNBD ligand discrimination in SthK. We find that cAMP binds to the SthK CNBD with a slightly stronger affinity than cGMP, and can access a deep-bound state that is inaccessible to cGMP. We propose that the deep binding of cAMP is the discriminatory state that is essential for cAMP-dependent channel activation. We identify crucial residues and dynamic hydrogen bonding patterns within the binding pocket that give rise to this discrimination.

Setting Up a Bio-AFM to Study Protein Misfolding in Neurodegenerative Diseases.

The clinical pathology of neurodegenerative diseases suggests that earlier onset and progression are related to the accumulation of protein aggregates due to misfolding. A prominent way to extract useful information regarding single-molecule studies of protein misfolding at the nanoscale is by capturing the unbinding molecular forces through forced mechanical tension generated and monitored by an atomic force microscopy-based single-molecule force spectroscopy (AFM-SMFS). This AFM-driven process results in an amount of data in the form of force versus molecular extension plots (force-distance curves), the statistical analysis of which can provide insights into the underlying energy landscape and assess a number of characteristic elastic and kinetic molecular parameters of the investigated sample. This chapter outlines the setup of a bio-AFM-based SMFS technique for single-molecule probing. The infrastructure used as a reference for this presentation is the Bruker ForceRobot300.

Probing nanomechanical interactions of SARS-CoV-2 variants Omicron and XBB with common surfaces.

The emergence of SARS-CoV-2 variants has further raised concerns about viral transmission. A fundamental understanding of the intermolecular interactions between the coronavirus and different surfaces is needed to address the transmission of SARS-CoV-2 through respiratory droplet-contaminated surfaces or fomites. The receptor-binding domain (RBD) of the spike protein is a key target for the adhesion of SARS-CoV-2 on the surface. To understand the effect of mutations on adhesion, atomic force microscopy-based single-molecule force spectroscopy (AFM-SMFS) was used to quantify the interactions between wild-type, Omicron, and XBB with several surfaces. The measurement revealed that RBD exhibits relatively higher forces on paper and gold surfaces, with the average force being 1.5 times greater compared to that on plastic surface. In addition, the force elevation on paper and gold surfaces for the variants can reach ∼28% relative to the wild type. These findings enhance our understanding of the nanomechanical interactions of the virus on common surfaces.

Interdomain Linker Effect on the Mechanical Stability of Ig Domains in Titin

Titin is the largest protein in humans, composed of more than one hundred immunoglobulin (Ig) domains, and plays a critical role in muscle’s passive elasticity. Thus, the molecular design of this giant polyprotein is responsible for its mechanical function. Interestingly, most of these Ig domains are connected directly with very few interdomain residues/linker, which suggests such a design is necessary for its mechanical stability. To understand this design, we chose six representative Ig domains in titin and added nine glycine residues (9G) as an artificial interdomain linker between these Ig domains. We measured their mechanical stabilities using atomic force microscopy-based single-molecule force spectroscopy (AFM-SMFS) and compared them to the natural sequence. The AFM results showed that the linker affected the mechanical stability of Ig domains. The linker mostly reduces its mechanical stability to a moderate extent, but the opposite situation can happen. Thus, this effect is very complex and may depend on each particular domain’s property.

Direct Measurements of the Cobalt-Thiolate Bonds Strength in Rubredoxin by Single-Molecule Force Spectroscopy.

Cobalt is a trace transition metal. Although it is not abundant on earth, tens of cobalt-containing proteins exist in life. Moreover, the characteristic spectrum of Co(II) ion makes it a powerful probe for the characterization of metal-binding proteins through the formation of cobalt-ligand bonds. Since most of these natural and artificial cobalt-containing proteins are stable, we believe that these cobalt-ligand bonds in the protein system are also mechanically stable. To prove this, we used atomic force microscopy-based single-molecule force spectroscopy (AFM-SMFS) to directly measure the rupture force of Co(II)-thiolate bond in Co-substituted rubredoxin (CoRD). By combining the chemical denature/renature method for building metalloprotein and cysteine coupling-based polyprotein construction strategy, we successfully prepared the polyprotein sample (CoRD)n suitable for single-molecule studies. Thus, we quantified the strength of Co(II)-thiolate bonds in rubredoxin with a rupture force of ∼140 pN, revealing that it is a mechanostable chemical bond. In addition, the Co-S bond is more labile than the Zn-S bond in proteins, similar to the result from the metal-competing titration experiment.

Atomic force microscopy-single-molecule force spectroscopy unveils GPCR cell surface architecture

G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) form the largest family of cell surface receptors. Despite considerable insights into their pharmacology, the GPCR architecture at the cell surface still remains largely unexplored. Herein, we present the specific unfolding of different GPCRs at the surface of living mammalian cells by atomic force microscopy-based single molecule force spectroscopy (AFM-SMFS). Mathematical analysis of the GPCR unfolding distances at resting state revealed the presence of different receptor populations relying on distinct oligomeric states which are receptor-specific and receptor expression-dependent. Moreover, we show that the oligomer size dictates the receptor spatial organization with nanoclusters of high-order oligomers while lower-order complexes spread over the whole cell surface. Finally, the receptor activity reshapes both the oligomeric populations and their spatial arrangement. These results add an additional level of complexity to the GPCR pharmacology until now considered to arise from a single receptor population at the cell surface.

Detection of weak non-covalent cation-π interactions in NGAL by single-molecule force spectroscopy.

Cation-π interaction is an electrostatic interaction between a cation and an electron-rich arene. It plays an essential role in many biological systems as a vital driving force for protein folding, stability, and receptor-ligand interaction/recognition. To date, the discovery of most cation-π interactions in proteins relies on the statistical analyses of available three-dimensional (3D) protein structures and corresponding computational calculations. However, their experimental verification and quantification remain sparse at the molecular level, mainly due to the limited methods to dynamically measure such a weak non-covalent interaction in proteins. Here, we use atomic force microscopy-based single-molecule force spectroscopy (AFM-SMFS) to measure the stability of protein neutrophil gelatinase-associated lipocalin (also known as NGAL, siderocalin, lipocalin 2) that can bind iron through the cation-π interactions between its three cationic residues and the iron-binding tri-catechols. Based on a site-specific cysteine engineering and anchoring method, we first characterized the stability and unfolding pathways of apo-NGAL. Then, the same NGAL but bound with the iron-catechol complexes through the cation-π interactions as a holo-form was characterized. AFM measurements demonstrated stronger stabilities and kinetics of the holo-NGAL from two pulling sites, F122 and F133. Here, NGAL is stretched from the designed cysteine close to the cationic residues for a maximum unfolding effect. Thus, our work demonstrates high-precision detection of the weak cation-π interaction in NGAL.Electronic Supplementary MaterialSupplementary material (additional SDS-PAGE, UV-vis, protein sequences, and more experimental methods) is available in the online version of this article at 10.1007/s12274-021-4065-9.

One-step asparaginyl endopeptidase (OaAEP1)-based protein immobilization for single-molecule force spectroscopy.

Enzymatic protein ligation has become the most powerful and widely used method for high-precision atomic force microscopy single-molecule force spectroscopy (AFM-SMFS) study of protein mechanics. However, this methodology typically requires the functionalization of the glass surface with a corresponding peptide sequence/tag for enzymatic recognition and multiple steps are needed. Thus, it is time-consuming and a high level of experience is needed for reliable results. To solve this problem, we simplified the procedure using two strategies both based on asparaginyl endopeptidase (AEP). First, we designed a heterobifunctional peptide-based crosslinker, GL-peptide-propargylglycine, which links to an N 3-functionalized surface via the click reaction. Then, the target protein with a C-terminal NGL sequence can be immobilized via the AEP-mediated ligation. Furthermore, we took advantage of the direct ligation between primary amino in a small molecule and protein with C-terminal NGL by AEP. Thus, the target protein can be immobilized on an amino-functionalized surface via AEP in one step. Both approaches were successfully applied to the AFM-SMFS study of eGFP, showing consistent single-molecule results.

Exploration of Metal-Ligand Coordination Bonds in Proteins by Single-molecule Force Spectroscopy

Thanks to the binding of various metal ions, metalloprotein plays an essential role in many different biological processes and represents an indispensable protein subgroup. Thus, the knowledge of the incorporated metal site and metal-ligand coordination bond in the protein is invaluable for understanding this critical bio-macromolecule and designing a new one. Over the last decade, atomic force microscopy-based single-molecule force spectroscopy (AFM-SMFS) has been used to explore the metalloprotein as an emerging methodology, focusing on measuring metal-ligand bond strength. By stretching the protein molecule along its peptide backbone, AFM-SMFS can unfold the protein secondary structure and break and quantify the metal-ligand bond/metal cluster. Moreover, the very recent development of enzymatic, site-specific protein conjugation and immobilization methods for the SMFS system enables the highly efficient and accurate measurement of the metal-ligand bond strength in proteins. As a result, comparing the strength among different types of metal-ligand bonds in proteins becomes possible, and the trend of their strength is gradually revealed, such as the Fe(III)-ligand bond in iron-binding proteins. Thus, we envision that in the future AFM-SMFS may provide a unique insight to uncover the general principle of how protein selectively binds to metal ion.

Pioglitazone Inhibits Metal Cluster Transfer of mitoNEET by Stabilizing the Labile Fe-N Bond Revealed at Single-Bond Level.

Outer mitochondrial membrane protein mitoNEET (mNT) is a target of the type 2 diabetes drug pioglitazone. It contains a labile Fe2S2(His)1(Cys)3 metal cluster with a single Fe-N(His87) coordinating bond and can transfer its cluster to acceptor proteins. Previous ensemble studies showed that pioglitazone's binding inhibited the transfer by stabilizing the cluster, and histidine 87 may be the key mediator. Here we used atomic force microscopy-based single-molecule force spectroscopy (AFM-SMFS) to study the unfolding process of mNT dimer in the absence and presence of pioglitazone, which can distinguish the binding effect for different regions of a protein. By developing a two-step strategy using different mNT monomers with respective purification tags, we solve the problem that the classic polyprotein formation disables the mNT to dimerize. As a result, a polyprotein including a stable, naturally noncovalently bound mNT homodimer is obtained, which is required for reliable AFM measurement and pioglitazone binding. Then, the dissociation rate (koff) of the metal cluster was measured, showing a 10-fold decrease upon pioglitazone binding, while the other parts decreased only 3-fold, verifying that pioglitazone mainly stabilizes the cluster. Moreover, when the Fe(III)-N(His87) bond was ruptured, this effect for the remaining Fe2S2(Cys)3 intermediate largely disappeared. Consequently, AFM results revealed that pioglitazone inhibited the metal cluster transfer of mNT by stabilizing the labile Fe(III)-N(His87) bond. In addition, an alternative method to build a natural, noncovalently bound protein dimer or complex for reliable single-molecule measurement was developed.

Single-Molecule Force Spectroscopy Reveals that the Fe-N Bond Enables Multiple Rupture Pathways of the 2Fe2S Cluster in a MitoNEET Monomer.

The mitochondrial outer membrane protein, mitoNEET (mNT), is an iron-sulfur protein containing an Fe2S2(His)1(Cys)3 cluster with a unique single Fe-N bond. Previous studies have shown that this Fe(III)-N(His) bond is essential for metal cluster transfer and protein function. To further understand the effect of this unique Fe-N bond on the metal cluster and protein, we used atomic force microscopy-based single-molecule force spectroscopy (AFM-SMFS) to investigate the mechanical unfolding mechanism of an mNT monomer, focusing on the rupture pathway and kinetic stability of the cluster. We found that the Fe-N bond was the weakest point of the cluster, the rupture of which occurred first, and could be independent of the cluster break. Moreover, this Fe-N bond enabled a dynamic and labile iron-sulfur cluster, as multiple unfolding pathways of mNT with a unique Fe2S2(Cys)3 intermediate were observed accordingly.

OaAEP1-Mediated Enzymatic Synthesis and Immobilization of Polymerized Protein for Single-Molecule Force Spectroscopy.

Chemical and bio-conjugation techniques have been developed rapidly in recent years and allow the building of protein polymers. However, a controlled protein polymerization process is always a challenge. Here, we have developed an enzymatic methodology for constructing polymerized protein step by step in a rationally-controlled sequence. In this method, the C-terminus of a protein monomer is NGL for protein conjugation using OaAEP1 (Oldenlandia affinis asparaginyl endopeptidases) 1) while the N-terminus was a cleavable TEV (tobacco etch virus) cleavage site plus an L (ENLYFQ/GL) for temporary N-terminal protecting. Consequently, OaAEP1 was able to add only one protein monomer at a time, and then the TEV protease cleaved the N-terminus between Q and G to expose the NH2-Gly-Leu. Then the unit is ready for next OaAEP1 ligation. The engineered polyprotein is examined by unfolding individual protein domain using atomic force microscopy-based single-molecule force spectroscopy (AFM-SMFS). Therefore, this study provides a useful strategy for polyprotein engineering and immobilization.

Enzymatic Construction of Protein Polymer/Polyprotein Using OaAEP1 and TEV Protease.

The development of chemical and biological coupling technologies in recent years has made possible of protein polymers engineering. We have developed an enzymatic method for building polyproteins using a protein ligase OaAEP1 (asparagine endopeptidase 1) and protease TEV (tobacco etching virus). Using a mobile TEV protease site compatible with the OaAEP1 ligation, we achieved a stepwise polymerization of the protein on the surface. The produced polyprotein can be verified by protein unfolding scenario using atomic force microscopy-based single-molecule force spectroscopy (AFM-SMFS). Thus, this study provides an alternative method for polyprotein engineering and immobilization.

Enzymatic biosynthesis and immobilization of polyprotein verified at the single-molecule level

The recent development of chemical and bio-conjugation techniques allows for the engineering of various protein polymers. However, most of the polymerization process is difficult to control. To meet this challenge, we develop an enzymatic procedure to build polyprotein using the combination of a strict protein ligase OaAEP1 (Oldenlandia affinis asparaginyl endopeptidases 1) and a protease TEV (tobacco etch virus). We firstly demonstrate the use of OaAEP1-alone to build a sequence-uncontrolled ubiquitin polyprotein and covalently immobilize the coupled protein on the surface. Then, we construct a poly-metalloprotein, rubredoxin, from the purified monomer. Lastly, we show the feasibility of synthesizing protein polymers with rationally-controlled sequences by the synergy of the ligase and protease, which are verified by protein unfolding using atomic force microscopy-based single-molecule force spectroscopy (AFM-SMFS). Thus, this study provides a strategy for polyprotein engineering and immobilization.

Exploring the Sulfatase 1 Catch Bond Free Energy Landscape using Jarzynski's Equality

In non-covalent biological adhesion, molecular bonds commonly exhibit a monotonously decreasing lifetime when subjected to tensile forces (slip bonds). In contrast, catch bonds behave counter intuitively, as they show an increased lifetime within a certain force interval. To date only a hand full of catch bond displaying systems have been identified. In order to unveil their nature, a number of structural and phenomenological models have been introduced. Regardless of the individual causes for catch bond behavior, it appears evident that the free energy landscapes of these interactions bear more than one binding state. Here, we investigated the catch bond interaction between the hydrophilic domain of the human cell surface sulfatase 1 (Sulf1HD) and its physiological substrate heparan sulfate (HS) by atomic force microscopy based single molecule force spectroscopy (AFM-SMFS). Using Jarzynski's equality, we estimated the associated Gibbs free energy and provide a comprehensive thermodynamic and kinetic characterization of Sulf1HD/HS interaction. Interestingly, the binding potential landscape exhibits two distinct potential wells, which confirms the recently suggested two state binding. Even though structural data of Sulf1HD is lacking, our results allow drafting a detailed picture of the directed and processive desulfation of HS.