CO2 hydrogenation is a promising process for removing anthropogenic CO2 emissions and yielding C1 chemicals that can be utilized as fuels and valuable precursors for chemical synthesis. Commercial high-entropy alloys (HEAs) have widespread application in various fields owing to their exceptional thermal stability and tunable microstructure. However, their potential application as catalysts is often limited by the low exposure of active sites. In this study, the commercial CoCrNiFeMn powder was applied for atmospheric pressure CO2 hydrogenation and enhanced its catalytic performance by a combined treatment of ball milling and high-temperature H2 reduction. The high-energy ball milling results in a morphological transition in CoCrNiFeMn HEAs from spherical to irregular. This transformation leads to a significant decrease in particle size and more surface reactive sites. The high-temperature H2 reduction promoted the atomic rearrangement on the CoCrNiFeMn surface, thereby improving its alloy structural homogeneity. These modifications greatly improve the performance of CoCrNiFeMn for CO2 hydrogenation. This work introduces a facile modification approach to facilitate the catalytic efficiency of commercial HEAs in CO2 hydrogenation with high selectivity.