Artificial spin ice (ASI) systems have emerged as powerful platforms for exploring the fundamental aspects of magnetic frustration and topological phenomena in condensed matter physics. In this study, we investigate the bountiful effects that result from introducing hexagonal magnetic defects into an ASI lattice. The stochastic stabilisation of a plethora of metastable states in the hexagonal defects are explored, as well as harnessing the defect magnetisation state for the selective injection of emergent monopoles of different polarities and proximities within the lattice. We demonstrate a mechanism for tailoring the ASI behaviour using the magnetic state of the defect, which is of interest to applications including magnetic memory devices and spin-based logic.