Prolonged use of atypical antipsychotics (AAPs) is commonly associated with increased cardiovascular disease risk. While weight gain and related health issues are generally considered the primary contributors to this risk, direct interference with mitochondrial bioenergetics, particularly in the liver where these drugs are metabolized, is emerging as an additional contributing factor. Here, we compared the effects of two AAPs with disparate metabolic profiles on the response of Fao hepatoma cells to oxidative stress: olanzapine (OLA), which is obesogenic, and aripiprazole (ARI), which is not. Results showed that cells treated with ARI exhibited resistance to H2O2-induced oxidative stress, while OLA treatment had the opposite effect. Despite enhanced survival, ARI-treated cells exhibited higher apoptotic rates than OLA-treated cells when exposed to H2O2. Gene expression analysis of pro- and anti-apoptotic factors revealed that ARI-treated cells had a generally blunted response to H2O2, contrasting with a heightened response in OLA-treated cells. This was further supported by the reduced activation of MAPKs and STAT3 in ARI-treated cells in response to H2O2, whereas OLA pre-treatment enhanced their activation. The loss of stress response in ARI-treated cells was consistent with the observed increase in the mitochondrial production of O2•-, a known desensitizing factor. The physiological relevance of O2•- in ARI-treated cells was demonstrated by the increase in mitophagy flux, likely related to mitochondrial damage. Notably, OLA treatment protected proteasome activity in Fao cells exposed to H2O2, possibly due to the better preservation of stress signaling and mitochondrial function. In conclusion, this study highlights the underlying changes in cell physiology and mitochondrial function by AAPs. ARI de-sensitizes Fao cells to stress signaling, while OLA has the opposite effect. These findings contribute to our understanding of the metabolic risks associated with prolonged AAP use and may inform future therapeutic strategies.