95 Sometimes Mr. Elfenbein’s assertions go over the top (particularly in his chapters on Blake and Coleridge), but on the other hand, his geniuses here were often over the top themselves.Givenhiscareful criticism in the book, this conclusion seems schematic and hurried. His compelling book, however, shifts the way we look at gay and lesbian writers. Romantic Genius is among the bestofcurrentscholarship on the queer eighteenth century. Hans Turley University of Connecticut ALASTAIR HAMILTON. The Apocryphal Apocalypse: The Reception of the Second Book of Esdras (4 Esra) from the Renaissance to the Enlightenment. Oxford: Clarendon, 1999. Pp. xii ⫹ 393. $85. Just in time for the new millennium (and the much anticipated doomsdayscenarios predicted long ago), Mr. Hamilton ’s authoritative study of the latest OT Apocrypha 2 Esdras (c. 90 A.D.), an exquisite expansion of his two articles on the reception of 2 Esdras, should arouse great interest among those who explore the rise and fall of eschatological literature , the philologicalchallengestotheauthority oftheBible, andthehistoryofbiblical hermeneutics. Mr. Hamilton stands on the shoulders of two eighteenthcentury giants, the German Lutherans Johann Albert Fabricius and Georg Serpilius , but weaves into his narrative his profound knowledge of the period and insights of recent scholarship. Each of the twelve chapters charts in chronological order the dispute about the canonicity of 2 Esdras, its date of composition , provenance, and authorship from the early Church Fathers to the Enlightenment . Concomitantly, Mr. Hamilton pays painstaking attention to how the book was employed by Roman Catholics , mainstream Protestants,andradical sectarians alike, who frequently turned the prophetic symbols of 2 Esdras into powerful tools of political and eschatological propaganda. The apocalyptic visions of the three-headed eagle, for instance , variously signified the Ottoman conquest of Byzantium in the East, the breakdown of power of the Roman Church in the West, or the rise and fall of the Habsburg emperors—all giving way to the lion (the true church) at the Second Coming. Thus, the humanist Pico della Mirandola and the Christian Hebraist Johann Reuchlin turned to 2 Esdras for its purported cabbalistic import; the radical prophet Savonarola for evidence of his self-styled messianism and the conversion of Jews and Muslims; the grammarians Pellikan and Bibliander for the advances of the Turks on Western Europe and OT predictions about the Christian messiah; Paracelsians, Boehmenists, and Rosicrucians, for spiritualized alchemy, theosophy, or anti-Catholic hegemony; New Prophets during the Thirty Years War for their role as latter-day Jeremiahs; Hartlib, Comenius, and Dury (with Manasseh ben Israel on their side) for the readmission of Jews in Cromwell’s England ; and, finally, Whiston and Newton for proof of psychopannychism, Arianism , or interminable calculations of prophetic timetables about Christ’s millennial reign. Even the New World and the peregrination of the Lost Tribes of Israel could be identified in 2 Esdras, for was not faraway ‘‘Arsareth’’ in America, where the Lost Tribes lived in their Andean hiding places—that is, if the accounts of Antonio de Montezinos and Manasseh ben Israel could be relied upon?In short,Renaissance philologists examining textual lacunae in biblical manuscripts just as 96 much as eighteenth-century radical Pietists discovering the operations of the Holy Spirit in human history found much in this Apocryphal work to engage their imagination. 2 Esdras became the subject of philological and theological controversies to our modern times. What is missing here is discussion of how such New Englanders as John Eliot, Thomas Shepard, Samuel Sewall, Cotton Mather, and Jonathan Edwards responded to the Apocryphal 2 Esdras. Theirconcern with Native Americans as the descendants of the Lost Tribes and with America’s place in the Christian geography of Christ’s millennial reign was similarly shaped by their response to 2 Esdras, either directly or indirectly through Joseph Mede and Manasseh ben Israel. Mr. Hamilton’shighlyrewardingstudy deserves a prominent place on the bookshelf of every scholar interested in the history of Western philology and the evolution of early modern hermeneutics.Its complementary history of 2 Esdras in the Eastern Church remains to be written. Reiner Smolinski Georgia State University CHRISTOPHER WILLIAMS. A Cultivated Reason: An Essay on Hume and Humeanism . University Park, PA: Penn State, 1999. Pp. vii ⫹ 190. $35; $19.95 (paper). Mr...