Reviewed by: Western Lands, Western Voices: Essays on Public History in the American West ed. by Gregory E. Smoak Debbie Z. Harwell Western Lands, Western Voices: Essays on Public History in the American West. Edited by Gregory E. Smoak. (Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press, 2021. Pp. 240. Photographs, notes, index.) Western Lands, Western Voices: Essays on Public History in the American West grew out of a 2014 symposium commemorating the fiftieth anniversary of the University of Utah’s American West Center, the nation’s oldest regional studies center, to “explore the power and promise of publicly engaged [End Page 149] scholarship in the American West” (1). Comprising presentations and selected essays, the book explores some of the ways that historians do public and regional public history with practical applications in areas across the eleven-state area of the American West. To establish a definition of public history, the authors look beyond intended audiences (the public) and the method of delivery to the ways in which public historians use their skills and training to engage in collaborative projects with community partners in order “to empower communities, inform public decision-making, protect heritage resources, and address the needs of public audiences” (8). The twelve essays fit into four main areas. The introduction by editor Gregory Smoak and the first two essays discuss how public history is defined, with Richard White arguing that “the core of public history lies in who asks the questions rather than in who gives the answer” (22), and Leisl Carr Childress seeing it as a public service. Essays by Michael Childers, Leighton M. Quarles, and Mette Flynt examine the history of place as seen through the work of public historians in the West generally, at national parks, and tourist sites in Lake City, Colorado. A third group of essays explores ethnic and Native American populations. Trisha Venisa-Alicia Martínez and Vanessa Fonseca-Chávez explore the meaning of identity and migration patterns of Nuevomexicanos between Albuquerque and Cheyenne. Yvette Towersap Tuell, E. Richard Hart, and Brittani R. Orona explore issues related to Native American populations including public land management, water rights, and memory and visual sovereignty respectively. The last group of essays examines how public historians educate through Native American Studies programs (detailed by Laurie Arnold), scholarship in a regional print journal (discussed by Jedediah Rogers), and museums as a tool to build bridges between academic and public history (by Stephen Aron and Virginia Scharff). The contributors to this volume are historians with extensive credentials in their fields, whether environmental, indigenous, ethnic, or regional history. Therefore, as one would expect, the essays are extensively researched with sources ranging from theoretical discussions of public history as a field to oral histories and primary source documents on water rights and land treaties, some dating back the to the early twentieth century. Although the articles do not mention Texas other than a reference to a Texas-based company’s efforts to extract shale gas deposits on a Mi’kmaq reserve in Canada, the principles discussed on many topics can be related easily to similar questions in this state. Western Lands, Western Voices has material that will appeal to readers specifically interested in studying the American West as a region, Indigenous peoples, policy decisions, environmental issues, and education. The greatest value to broader audiences, however, lies in the discussion of public history itself, using these topics as case studies to show how public history has [End Page 150] evolved, how it is used today, and how it can be used in the future for the greater public good. Western Lands, Western Voices demonstrates the value of public history standing side-by-side equally with traditional academic history to provide a more comprehensive and useful historical perspective. [End Page 151] Debbie Z. Harwell University of Houston Copyright © 2022 The Texas State Historical Association
Read full abstract