Aiming Task Research Articles

Proprioceptive feedback is reduced during adaptation to a visuomotor transformation: preliminary findings

Adapting movements in relation to visual feedback is a ubiquitous characteristic of sensorimotor control and involves the integration of multiple sources of sensory information. We recorded sensory feedback from muscle spindle afferents during visuomotor adaptation while subjects performed an aiming task to investigate whether the activity of the muscle spindles was modulated by the fusimotor system under these learning conditions. None of the muscle spindles showed an increase in activity, rather in 83% of the trials the firing rates were decreased. These preliminary results suggest that the CNS reduces the sensory signals arising from muscle spindles perhaps as a means of resolving the conflict between visual and proprioceptive feedback during the task.

Intercepting a moving target: effects of temporal precision constraints and movement amplitude.

The effects of temporal precision constraints and movement amplitude on performance of an interceptive aiming task were examined. Participants were required to strike a moving target object with a "bat" by moving the bat along a straight path (constrained by a linear slide) perpendicular to the path of the target. Temporal precision constraints were defined in terms of the time period (or window) within which contact with the target was possible. Three time windows were used (approx. 35, 50 and 65 ms) and these were achieved either by manipulating the size of the bat (experiment 1a), the size of the target (experiment 1b) or the speed of the target (experiment 2). In all experiments, movement time (MT) increased in proportion to movement amplitude but was only affected by differences in the temporal precision constraint if this was achieved by variation in the target's speed. In this case the MT was approximately inversely proportional to target speed. Peak movement speed was affected by temporal accuracy constraints in all three experiments: participants reached higher speeds when the temporal precision required was greater. These results are discussed with reference to the speed-accuracy trade-off observed for temporally constrained aiming movements. It is suggested that the MT and speed of interceptive aiming movements may be understood as responses to the spatiotemporal constraints of the task.

Modulation of Postural Sway during Manual Aiming

We examined the modulation of postural sway during performance of a supra-postural aiming task. Participants aimed a laser pointer at a large, medium, or small target located 1.5 m away. There were two aiming conditions: (1) participants held the laser pointer, or (2) the laser pointer was attached to the body using a belt. Participants stood either directly facing the target or facing the target with the head, but with the body facing the side. Postural sway variability was measured. Sway variability decreased with decreasing target size, but the decrease depended upon whether the pointer was held or attached, the direction participants faced, and on the direction of postural motion. The results showed that postural variability was modulated in order to meet the precision, manual, and directional constraints imposed by the aiming task. Implications for human-computer interaction via aiming are discussed.

A distance effect in a manual aiming task to remembered targets: a test of three hypotheses.

It has been noted that manual aiming error and variability when pointing to remembered targets increase as a function of target eccentricity. In the present study we evaluated which one of three hypotheses (target localization, motor, or movement duration) best explains this 'distance effect'. In experiment 1, older and younger participants aimed with their unseen hand at the remembered location of targets distributed between 129 and 309 mm from the starting base. Target presentation time was of either 50 or 500 ms and aiming movements could be initiated following either a 100- or a 10,000-ms recall delay. Participants had either no constraints concerning movement time or were asked to reach the near target in a longer movement time than the farther targets. The results revealed a significant distance effect when no time constraints were imposed but showed a significantly reversed distance effect when the instructions were to reach the near targets in a longer movement time than the far targets. The same results were obtained regardless of target presentation time, recall delay, or age of the participants. These results supported a movement duration interpretation of the distance effect. In experiment 2, a distance effect was replicated when pointing with one's unseen hand toward a remembered target but did not take place when pointing to visible targets. Taken together these results suggest that prolonged movement execution interferes with the stored egocentric target representation.

Directional tuning of human forearm muscle afferents during voluntary wrist movements.

1. Single unit activity was recorded with the microneurography technique from sixteen spindle afferents and one Golgi tendon organ afferent originating from the forearm extensor muscles. Impulse rates were studied while subjects performed unobstructed aiming movements at the wrist in eight different directions 45 deg apart. In addition, similar imposed movements were performed while the subject was instructed to remain relaxed. Movement amplitudes were about 5 deg and the speed 10-30 deg x s(-1). Joint movements were translated to movements of a cursor on a monitor to provide visual feedback. 2. Individual spindle afferents modulated their activity over a number of targets, i.e. were broadly tuned, during these aiming movements. The preferred direction for a spindle afferent was the same during both passive and active movements, indicating that the fusimotor effects associated with active contractions had little or no effect on the direction of tuning. 3. The direction of tuning of individual spindle afferents could be predicted from the biomechanically inferred length changes of the parent muscle. Thus spindle afferents responded as stretch receptors, i.e. impulse rates increased with lengthening and decreased with shortening, in active as well as passive movements. 4. Spindles from muscles, which continuously counteracted gravity exhibited a stretch response and directional tuning during the phase of movement alone whereas their position sensitivity was poor. In contrast, spindle afferents from the muscles that had no or minimal antigravity role were directionally tuned during both the dynamic and the static phase of the aiming task and their position sensitivity was substantially higher. 5. In spite of the limited data base from three extensor muscles it could be demonstrated that wrist joint position was remarkably well encoded in the ensemble muscle spindle data. In some cases the ensemble muscle spindle data encoded the instantaneous trajectory of movement as well.

What Causes Specificity of Practice in a Manual Aiming Movement: Vision Dominance or Transformation Errors?

The withdrawal of vision of the arm during a manual aiming task has been found to result in a large increase in aiming error, regardless of the amount of practice in normal vision before its withdrawal. In the present study, the authors investigated whether the increase in error reflects the domination of visual afferent information over the movement representation developed during practice to the detriment of other sources of afferent information or whether it reflects only transformation errors of the location of the target from an allocentric to an egocentric frame of reference. Participants (N = 40) performed aiming movements with their dominant or nondominant arm in a full-vision or target-only condition. The results of the present experiment supported both of those hypotheses. The data indicated that practice does not eliminate the need for visual information for optimizing movement accuracy and that learning is specific to the source or sources of afferent information more likely to ensure optimal accuracy during practice. In addition, the results indicated that movement planning in an allocentric frame of reference might require simultaneous vision of the arm and the target. Finally, practice in a target-only condition, with knowledge of results, was found to improve recoding of the target in an egocentric frame of reference.

Divided Attention in Bimanual Aiming Movements: Effects on Movement Accuracy

The role of focusing attention on one limb or both limbs in a bimanual aiming task was investigated in two experiments. Participants were prompted to focus attention on either limb (Experiment 1) or were free to choose their attentional strategy (Experiment 2). Fifty-two college-aged participants made quick, bimanual lever reversals in the sagittal plane over 20° and 60° in 210 ms to the reversal point. In both experiments, spatial accuracy was better when participants focused their attention on a single limb compared to the nonattended limb and when they paid attention to both limbs. However, no differences were shown on a no-knowledge of results (KR) retention test when participants paid attention to both limbs. In the second experiment, differences were maintained on a no-KR retention test when participants continued to select their own attentional strategy, although the statistical effect was smaller than in the first experiment. The findings suggested that the movement parameter selection process benefited from attentional focus.

Specificity of Task Constraints and Effects of Visual Demonstrations and Verbal Instructions in Directing Learners' Search During Skill Acquisition

In the present study, the efficacy of visual demonstrations and verbal instructions as instructional constraints on the acquisition of movement coordination was investigated. Fifteen participants performed an aiming task on 100 acquisition and 20 retention trials, under 1 of 3 conditions: a modeling group (MG), a verbally directed group (VDG), and a control group (CG). The MG observed a model intermittently throughout acquisition, whereas the VDG was verbally instructed to use the model's movement pattern. Participants in the CG received neither form of instruction. Kinematic analysis revealed that compared with verbal instructions or no instructions, visual demonstrations significantly improved participants' approximation of the model's coordination pattern. No differences were found in movement outcomes. Coordination data supported the visual perception perspective on observational learning, whereas outcome data suggested that the modeling effect is mainly a function of task constraints, that is, the novelty of a movement pattern.

The patterns of energy used for action are task-dependent

Is there any ecological purpose in assuming that perception for action exists only through a global array of energy? Unlike Stoffregen & Bardy, who assume that behavior consists of movements, we would argue that behavior consists of a stable coupling between perception and action achieved through experience in an adaptive context. Determining target position in an aiming manual task and temporal control of impact movement illustrate that patterns of energy used for action are task-dependent.

Motor Learning as a Function of KR Schedule and Characteristics of Task-Intrinsic Feedback

Forty participants (age range = 18–35 years) practiced 1 of 2 versions of an aiming task (with or without spring resistance). Knowledge of results (KR) was provided to them either immediately or after a delay of 2 trials. Immediate KR led to significantly more accurate performance during the 80 trials in acquisition but significantly less accurate performance on a 40-trial retention test given 24 hr after practice. In addition, the spring version of the task was performed significantly less accurately than the no-spring version on the 24-hr retention test. Most important, a significant interaction on the 24-hr retention test revealed that performance of the no-spring version of the task, when KR had been given after a 2-trial delay, was significantly more accurate than performance of the other 3 combinations of task version and KR schedule. The results suggest that KR dependency in motor skill learning is related to familiarity with task-intrinsic feedback in addition to the schedule on which KR is presented.

Effects of manipulating relative and absolute motion information during observational learning of an aiming task

In the visual perception perspective of observational learning, the manipulation of relative and absolute motion information in visual demonstrations optimally directs learners’ search towards appropriate task solutions. We assessed the effect of emphasizing transformational information and removal of structural information using point-light kinematic displays in approximating the model’s relative motion patterns. Participants viewed computer-simulated point-light demonstrations or normal video demonstrations before and intermittently throughout 100 acquisition trials with knowledge of results on an underarm modified-dart aiming task. On the next day, all participants performed 20 retention trials without demonstrations. The kinematics of spatial and temporal coordination and control variables were examined relative to the model’s action, as well as performance scores. The results indicated that approximation of the model’s spatial and temporal coordination and control patterns was achieved after observation of either type of demonstrations. No differences were found in movement outcomes. In a second experiment, the effects of manipulating absolute motion information by slowmotion demonstrations were examined relative to real-time demonstrations. Real-time demonstrations led to a closer approximation to the model’s spatial and temporal coordination patterns and better outcome scores, contradicting predictions that slow-motion displays convey intact relative motion information. We speculate that the effect of visual demonstration speed on action perception and reproduction is a function of task constraints ‐ that is, novelty or familiarity of relative motion of demonstrated activities.

Function of the ‘direct’ and ‘indirect’ pathways of the basal ganglia motor loop: evidence from reciprocal aiming movements in Parkinson’s disease

The purpose of this study was to test the validity of a neural-network model of the basal ganglia developed by Bischoff and colleagues (A. Bischoff, Modeling the basal ganglia in the control of arm movements (Doctoral dissertation, University of Southern California, 1998). Dissertation Abstr. Int. 59-08B (1998) 3924, 0208; A. Bischoff, M.A. Arbib, Modeling the role of basal ganglia and supplementary motor areas in sequential arm movements, Abstr. Soc. Neurosci. 23 (1997) 466; A. Bischoff, M.A. Arbib, C.J. Winstein, Modeling the role of the basal ganglia in reciprocal aiming task, Proceedings of the Fourth Annual Joint Symposium on Neural Computation, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, 7, 1997, pp. 20–27), and to examine the effects of levodopa on aiming movement performance. Findings confirm the model predictions for repetitive aiming movements. Individuals with late stage Parkinson’s disease demonstrated longer movement times and longer pauses between aiming sequences compared to controls. Levodopa only slightly improved bradykinesia but not akinesia in these patients.

The Benefits of Random Variable Practice for Accuracy and Temporal Error Detection in a Rapid Aiming Task

Click to increase image sizeClick to decrease image sizeKey Words: contextual interferencepractice organizationrecognition capabilitytiming accuracy

The handedness of postural fluctuations

In two experiments we investigated whether the dynamics of standing upright were lateralized. The postural task of Experiment 1 introduced a lateral bias of attention; the postural task of Experiment 2 did not. In Experiment 1, six left-handed and six right-handed participants passively held a laser pointer at the side of the body in either the left or right hand. Successful pointing at targets that varied in distance and size required minimizing the body's medio-lateral (ML) sway. Sway variability, in the range of 2.8–5 mm, was smaller in the anterior–posterior (AP) direction (of relevance to keeping upright) and larger in the ML direction when the pointer was on the preferred rather than non-preferred side. In Experiment 2, six left-handed and six right-handed participants maintained quiet stance while visually fixating a target. Variability of ML and AP sway changed in the same way with difficulty of the precision aiming task and did so independently of handedness. Discussion focused upon the possible mechanism of postural lateralization and the nature of the tasks by which such lateralization is revealed.

Coupling of Eye, Finger, Elbow, and Shoulder Movements During Manual Aiming

Temporal and spatial coupling of point of gaze (PG) and movements of the finger, elbow, and shoulder during a speeded aiming task were examined. Ten participants completed 40-cm aiming movements with the right arm, in a situation that allowed free movement of the eyes, head, arm, and trunk. On the majority of trials, a large initial saccade undershot the target slightly, and 1 or more smaller corrective saccades brought the eyes to the target position. The finger, elbow, and shoulder exhibited a similar pattern of undershooting their final positions, followed by small corrective movements. Eye movements usually preceded limb movements, and the eyes always arrived at the target well in advance of the finger. There was a clear temporal coupling between primary saccade completion and peak acceleration of the finger, elbow, and shoulder. The initiation of limb-segment movement usually occurred in a proximal-to-distal pattern. Increased variability in elbow and shoulder position as the movement progressed may have served to reduce variability in finger position. The spatial-temporal coupling of PG with the 3 limb segments was optimal for the pick up of visual information about the position of the finger and the target late in the movement.

The Effect of Practice on Component Submovements is Dependent on the Availability of Visual Feedback

Participants (N = 16) were given extensive practice (1,500 trials) on a perceptual-motor aiming task. The full-vision (FV) group practiced with vision of their response cursor, whereas the no vision (NV) group practiced in a condition without vision. Movements were made as quickly and accurately as possible, and knowledge of results (KR) was provided. The authors tested the importance of vision early and late in practice by transferring participants to the NV condition without KR. The effects of practice differed between the two conditions. The FV group increased the speed of initial impulse to get to the target quickly, then relied on vision so make discrete error corrections. Transfer tests revealed that reliance on vision remained after extensive practice. For the NV group, practice effects were associated with a reduction in the extent to which discrete error corrections were produced.

Absence of Interhemispheric Transfer of Unilateral Visuomotor Learning in Young Children and Individuals With Agenesis of the Corpus Callosum

This study was undertaken to investigate the role of the corpus callosum in interhemispheric transfer of unilateral visuomotor learning. In the first experiment, the cross-manual performance of 4 callosal agenesis participants was compared to that of 4 age- and IQ-matched controls. In the second experiment, normal children of different ages (6-7 and 11-12 years) and adults were submitted to the same task to assess the impact of callosal maturation on interhemispheric transfer. Participants had to make aiming movements from a starting position toward either a central or a lateral target on the same side as the hand used, while maintaining central fixation. Prior to training, a pretest was performed with the hand contralateral to the hand used during learning. Participants were then submitted to a posttest with the untrained hand. All participants learned the unilateral aiming task in the learning phase, as evidenced by a reduction in spatial errors with an increasing number of practice trials. However, acallosal participants and children aged 6 to 7 years failed to transfer the acquired skill from the trained to the untrained hemisphere. These findings suggest that interhemispheric transfer of visuomotor skills cannot be assumed by other structures in the case of agenesis or morphological immaturity of the corpus callosum. The results further indicate that unilateral visuomotor learning leads to the formation of a single, unihemispheric engram in the absence, whether functional or anatomical, of the corpus callosum.

Movement Substructures Change as a Function of Practice in Children and Adults

An experiment is reported in which participants at 6 (n = 20), 9 (n = 20), and 24 years (n = 20) of age either received or did not receive practice on a rapid aiming task using the arm and hand. The purpose of the experiment was to document the changes in movement substructures (in addition to movement time) as a function of practice. After receiving 10 baseline trials, subjects in the practice groups received 30 practice trials followed by 10 retention trials on each of 5 days, while subjects in the no-practice group had only baseline and retention trials. Retention-only trials were divided into primary (reflecting the ballistic controlled part of the movement) and secondary (reflecting corrective movement adjustments) submovements. In addition, jerk (the 3rd derivative of movement displacement) was calculated as an estimate of the smoothness of the movement. Participants increased the primary submovement as a function of practice; however, the increases were substantially larger in the children (25–30%) than in the adults (10%). Participants also decreased jerk as a function of practice and the decreases were greater in children than in adults. The results suggest that with practice the primary submovement is lengthened so that it ends nearer the target, especially in children. Associated with the primary submovement covering a larger percentage of the movement length and time, movements became smoother.

Specificity of postural sway to the demands of a precision task

We examined a precision aiming task in which a handheld laser pointer was controlled by the postural system. The task was performed in two orientations of the body's coronal plane to the target. In the parallel orientation medio-lateral (ML) sway had to be minimized, in the perpendicular orientation antero-posterior (AP) sway had to be minimized. In the parallel orientation ML sway decreased and AP sway increased with target distance and size. The pattern reversed in the perpendicular orientation. Nonlinear measures found independence of the two directions of sway and differences in their deterministic structure. Apparently a postural organization for upright standing and aiming (as in archery) entails two independent postural subsystems with different but reciprocally related dynamics. Furthermore, it seems as if some amount of postural variability is needed to ensure stability in quiet standing; if postural activity is reduced in one direction it is compensated for in the other direction.

Error, stress and the role of neuromotor noise in space oriented behaviour

In this article both movement errors and successful movements are considered to be the product of varying ratios of muscle force signals and the composite of neuromotor noise in which the force signal is embedded. Based on earlier work we derived four propositions, which together form a theoretical framework for understanding the incidence of error in conditions of time pressure and mental load. These propositions are: (1) motor behaviour is an inherently stochastic and therefore noisy process; (2) biophysical, biomechanical and psychological factors all contribute to the level of neuromotor noise in a movement signal; (3) endpoint variability of movement is related to the signal-to-noise ratio of the forces which drive the moving limb to the target; and (4) optimal signal-to-noise ratios in motor output can be arrived at by adjusting limb stiffness. In an experiment with a graphical aiming task in which subjects made pen movements to targets varying in width and distance, we tested the prediction that time pressure and dual task load would influence error rates and movement noisiness, together resulting in biomechanical adaptations of pen pressure. The latter is seen as a manifestation of a biomechanical filtering strategy to cope with increased neuromotor noise levels. The results confirmed that especially under time pressure error rates and movement noise were enhanced, while pen pressure was higher in both conditions of stress.