Agricultural researchers recognize the importance of the sustainability of agricultural systems and the need to develop appropriate ways to measure sustainability. The search for agroecosystem performance indicators (APIs) is an urgent task to develop understanding and to facilitate decision-making processes. The paper provides an input/output methodology for a farming system analysis in terms of both energy and monetary values, measurements that are sufficiently homogenizing and comprehensive to document patterns of agroecosystem transfers of bio-physical entities and socio-cultural values. This methodology was applied to two adjacent farms located in Central Italy, which differed in the farming system adopted (mixed farming and arable farming) and in the level of external input applied. A broad range of APIs (structural and functional, direct and crossed) was developed to analyze both the fundamental energy transfers (and associated allocation of monetary values) between the crucial agroecosystem components and the overall efficiency of the farming system in transforming different external input into output. This analysis shows that energy and monetary values do not offer a single, coherent account of the functioning of farm systems. The study stresses the need for the development of an environmental accounting method, which integrates ecological and economic aspects. For the present, it is recognized that structural and functional APIs calculated according to energy, rather than monetary, values are more meaningful in both the designing of sustainable farming systems and in decision-making processes.
Read full abstract