Little data support the optimal distance of cuticular suture placement from the wound edge to achieve the most cosmetically appealing scar. To compare Patient and Observer Scar Assessment Scale (POSAS) scores for cutaneous sutures spaced 2mm versus 5mm from the wound edge in head and neck defects repaired via linear closure. Fifty patients were enrolled in this randomized, evaluator blinded, split-scar study. Surgical wounds were repaired with cuticular sutures 2mm from the wound edge on one side and 5mm on the other. POSAS scores and scar width were compared 3months postoperatively. The sum observer POSAS score for this study had a mean (SD) of 16.06 (6.49) on the 2-mm side and 15.82 (6.83) on the 5-mm side (P=.807). Similarly, no difference was seen between scar width with a mean (SD) of 0.100cm (0.058cm) on the 2-mm side and with mean (SD) 0.100cm (0.076cm) on the 5-mm side (P=.967). Linear repairs were studied on head and neck defects after extirpation of cutaneous malignancies, resulting in a homogeneous elderly white patient population. Cuticular sutures placed 2 or 5mm from the wound edge did not result in different cosmetic outcomes in linear closures on the head and neck.