Introduction: Femoral shaft fractures are common in children, with intramedullary nailing being the "gold standard" due to its short hospital stay, fast fracture union, and early functional use. Submuscular plating is an alternative, but the choice for adolescents remains unclear. Herein, we systematically review the union rates after submuscular plate or Intramedullary elastic nail treatment to treat closed fracture middle shaft femur and the other clinical outcomes of these methods. Methods: We conducted clinical data searches in PubMed, ScienceDirect, and ResearchGate. The studies included were RCT or cohort studies that assessed the outcomes of intramedullary nailing and submuscular plating in treating adolescent femur fractures with limitation studies published during the years 2008-2023 and using English as its language. Results: Nine studies of 390 cases were included in this review, consisting of 155 cases treated with submuscular plating and 235 with intramedullary nailing. The average time of bone union in 155 patients was 2.71 months, while 235 cases had a faster union time, with an average of 2.37 months. The other complications reviewed were malunion, nonunion, delayed union, length-leg discrepancy, coronal angular deformity, sagittal angular deformity, decreased ROM, implant prominence, implant failure, and reoperation rates. Conclusion: This study found that intramedullary nailing and submuscular plating are safe, feasible, and successful treatments for adolescent femur shaft fractures. Submuscular plating was more effective than ESIN but had a higher risk of complications. Future clinical trials should compare outcomes with a more specific population. Keywords: adolescent, intramedullary nailing, midshaft femur fracture, submuscular plating
Read full abstract