Electrocaloric effects of adiabatic temperature change via the application of external electric fields are explored for energy-efficient solid-state refrigeration. These effects are typically estimated from the thermodynamic analyses of polarization and field in electrocaloric materials, which implies that higher field application gives larger temperature changes. However, this may not be always true. Here, using both indirect and direct methods, we report an anomalous effect where larger thermal changes occur by applications of lower fields in a multi-domain BaTiO3 (001) single crystal. A large temperature change of 1.9 K under a low field change of 8 kV/cm at 404 K is observed in a multi-domain BaTiO3 (001) single crystal in comparison to that of 1.4 K at a high field change of 30 kV/cm. We attribute this counterintuitive effect to the interplay of the c- and a-domains in the BaTiO3 (001) single crystal under the influence of temperature and field changes. This work provides a fundamental understanding of the complex role of domains in governing the electrocaloric response of ferroelectric materials which is often overlooked but critical for their practical applications.