Abstract Introduction Studies that have reviewed technologies including haptic feedback and virtual reality indicate the usefulness of simulation. However, these technologies are not universally available. Less technologically innovative simulation methods that utilise the learning environment, equipment and presentation can still effectively support surgical teaching. A review was undertaken to assess the effect of these lower fidelity simulation methods on surgical skill acquisition. Method Two courses enrolled 12 and 14 respectively, with trainees ranging in seniority from Foundation Year 1 to Core Trainee Year 2. Four basic surgical skills (suturing, hand tying, local anaesthetic and surgical instruments) were taught in 20 and 30 minute stations. These skills were used to assess trainee confidence before and after teaching, using a 5 point qualitative data collection scale ranging from Not Very to Very Confident. The faculty received a pre-course lecture on teaching methods to ensure standardisation. Result Mean confidence increased following participation in simulation teaching; 1st course demonstrated a post-teaching increase of 42%, 2nd a 60% increase. Individual skill confidence increased more following simulation-based course in hand tying (57% p=0.002, v 89% p=0.00007), local anaesthetic (30% p=0.001, v 41% p=0.005) and surgical instruments (44% p=0.005, v 89% p=0.0001). Suturing was not associated with increased mean confidence, but median confidence score increased more (33% p=0.005, v 60% p=0.0001). Conclusion Greater incorporation of simulation in training is generally associated with increased confidence with surgical skills. This is likely due to better contextualisation, leading to improved understanding of the place of the skills in the clinical setting. Take-home message Greater incorporation of simulation techniques, not necessarily of a technological nature, leads to increased confidence with surgical skills.