While acrylic acid (AA)-based superabsorbent hydrogels (SAHs) have been widely used in multiple applications, the effects of counterion condensation and the polyelectrolyte effect at suppressing the effective degree of ionization in such systems limit their superabsorbency. Herein we describe the use, and investigate the mechanism, of sulfate comonomers containing different types of polymerizable functional groups for increasing the superabsorbency of acrylic acid-based SAHs. Specifically, acrylamido-2-methylpropanesulfonic acid (AMPS), 3-sulfopropyl acrylate (SPAK), and 3-sulfopropyl methacrylate (SPMK) sulfated monomers featuring similar distances between the polymer backbone and the sulfate group but different polymerizable groups were copolymerized with acrylic acid to fabricate SAHs. Measurements of the effective homopolymerization rate constants and copolymerization ratios associated with each copolymerization enabled the prediction of the relative chain distributions of monomers in each copolymer, as quantified by the blockiness parameter (i.e., the instantaneous or average number of consecutive monomers of each type polymerized). While all sulfated comonomers significantly enhanced swelling relative to an acrylic acid control, copolymers in which longer AA blocks are produced (AA-AMPS) resulted in lower swelling than copolymers in which shorter AA blocks are produced (AA-SPAK, AA-SPMK), a result attributed to the suppressed polyelectrolyte effect in copolymers with shorter AA blocks. The formation of limited length blocks of the sulfated monomer SPMK showed additional benefits for enhancing swelling, consistent with enhanced direct charge–charge repulsion between fixed charges in such copolymer systems. We anticipate this linkage between copolymerization kinetics and swelling properties offers the potential to enable improved rational design of superabsorbent hydrogels with higher sorbency.